“It’s not going to happen,” outgoing Freedom Caucus Chair Andy Harris told Axios as House Republicans organize for the upcoming Congress.
One of Minority Leader-elect Jim Jordan's first major challenges will be managing a push by Republican members to punish colleagues who buck party leadership on procedural votes, Axios reported. Jordan, a founding member of the House Freedom Caucus, now leads a conference where lawmakers want to rein in the exact tactics his conservative allies have long used to challenge GOP leaders.
Main Street Caucus Proposes Penalties
Rep. Mike Flood and members of the Republican Main Street Caucus want to penalize members who vote against the party on procedural rule votes, a technical maneuver that conservatives repeatedly used as a hostage-taking tactic. The Main Street proposal empowers the Steering Committee to impose punishments ranging from a loss of committee seniority to more serious consequences, which would then be implemented by leadership or the relevant committee chair.
Flood told Axios that Main Street members developed the proposal collectively over several months through surveys and multiple meetings. Flood and other Republicans pushing accountability measures have been in contact with Jordan’s team while finalizing their proposals.
“This has nothing to do with telling a member how to vote on an issue,” Flood said of the proposal, according to Axios.
Incoming Minority Whip Tom Emmer also advocated for consequences during an interview on the campaign trail in October. A GOP lawmaker told Axios that support extends beyond Main Street, with members in the Republican Study Committee pushing similar proposals.
Freedom Caucus Members Oppose Proposals
Freedom Caucus members strongly oppose the Main Street proposal as the conference prepares to consider amendments and rules when it organizes in December. Lawmakers familiar with Jordan's thinking continue discussions.
“That’s inappropriate,” Rep. Andrew Clyde told Axios of Flood’s original proposal. Clyde added that he does not think the proposal will get anywhere because enough members feel the same way to kill it.
Jordan enters this fight from a wing of the party historically known for challenging GOP leaders using these exact procedural tools. Main Street Republicans represent a large bloc of the conference, creating another group Jordan must manage while building his leadership operation.
“The reason he’s the minority leader is he’s built relationships all across the conference, and he’s built really meaningful, good relationships. And I have, you know, no doubt that we’re going to get a fair shot here,” Flood told Axios.
Lawmakers Set Rules for Majority
With Republicans headed into one of the smallest minorities in recent history, the proposed changes would have little practical effect in the upcoming Congress. Lawmakers nevertheless want to settle accountability rules now so that future divisions do not threaten to derail their agenda when they regain the majority.
“This is us simply setting the table so that when we do return to the majority, we can do so built on a foundation that addresses some of the hiccups we experienced during the 119th Congress,” Flood told Axios.
“We’re in the minority now, this is the time to set the rules. This is the time to get this thing right,” a GOP lawmaker told Axios.
“The goal is to take away the ability of an extremely small group to extort leadership,” another member added.
“There needs to be consequences for those who choose not to play as a team. What’s doubly frustrating is many of those who choose not to be good teammates rarely attend caucus meetings or are willing to negotiate within the tent. Too often, they are the ones talking to reporters on the steps,” a GOP lawmaker told Axios.