China is holding direct elections this month for more than 2.6 million local deputies, a process over one billion eligible voters will take part in through 2027 — and a veteran journalist who watched the Soviet Union vote before its 1991 collapse says the arguments used to defend the Chinese system remind him of how elections were once conducted in Moscow.
The comparison comes from Rajiv Shah, writing in Counterview, who reported from the Soviet Union between 1986 and 1993 for the Delhi-based semi-Left daily Patriot and Link Newsweekly.
Shah was responding to an article by Tings Chak, editor of the Beijing-published Wenhua Zongheng: A Journal of Contemporary Chinese Thought and Asia Co-Coordinator of the Tricontinental: Institute for Social Research, distributed by Globetrotter and republished in Counterview under the headline “China’s Mass Elections and the Politics Beyond the Ballot”.
Chak’s article describes what is under way in China as “one of the world’s largest exercises in direct voting”, with “more than one billion eligible voters being called upon to elect over 2.6 million deputies to county and township people’s congresses”, from Beijing to the countryside.
Shah wrote that what prompted him was not only how Chak portrays the Chinese electoral system but how closely it resembled Soviet-era voting, “something I witnessed with my own eyes” during his seven-year stint as a journalist.
According to Chak’s article, “the elections are taking place on a scale rarely seen elsewhere, yet this part of China’s political system remains little understood abroad”.
He cites a village where polling preparations were accompanied by “a rural music festival”, where “elected representatives served freshly ground coffee to local farmers and visitors” while discussing “the village’s development and encouraging people to register and prepare to vote”. Issues raised included access to farms and unlit paths between fields.
In Beijing, Chak writes, “On 6 November, the capital set up 13,054 polling stations to choose 4,898 district deputies and 11,137 township deputies. Voting took place in residential communities, workplaces, university campuses, and state institutions, including Zhongnanhai, where President Xi Jinping cast his ballot.”
The municipal election office reported that the vast majority of candidates were nominated by groups of ten or more voters — 85 percent of the 7,337 district-level candidates and 90.8 percent of the 16,683 township-level candidates — with the remainder recommended by political parties and mass organisations. Women made up 46.3 percent and 48.5 percent of the respective lists.
Chak describes a people’s congress system operating at five levels across a country with 503,000 administrative villages and 112,000 urban communities. Citizens elect county and township deputies for five-year terms; those congresses in turn elect city, provincial and National People’s Congress representatives. The process is to produce a new national legislature in 2028, while the Communist Party of China prepares its own 21st National Congress in 2027 through a separate internal vote.
Shah joined Link Newsweekly in Delhi as a sub-editor in January 1979 and stayed with Link and Patriot for 14 years, until June 1993. After covering the World Indebtedness Conference in Havana in August 1985, he was offered the Moscow correspondent’s post for both papers, which he accepted.
Before flying to Moscow in February 1986, he was made to meet the Soviet ambassador in what was described as a courtesy call. During his posting, the Soviet information department organised trips for him with an interpreter, and on occasion the authorities were “displeased” with his reports, including one drawing on a Soviet research journal about the ageing Russian countryside.
On nomination, Chak acknowledges that candidates may belong to the CPC or China’s eight other parties, but that these parties “operate within the political system under CPC leadership”, in a system of “whole-process people’s democracy” in which “the CPC’s leadership is established in the Constitution”.
Shah, for his part, writes that he has no direct knowledge of how Chinese elections are conducted, but that it requires no extraordinary effort to establish that dissent is not tolerated there — the ground on which his Soviet comparison rests.
Related reading
- Denmark Approves Trilateral Security Deal with U.S. and Greenland to Expand Arctic Military Presence
- Merz: EU Ready for Russia Talks If Included in Ukraine Negotiations
- Xi Declares ‘Full Turnaround’ in China-Australia Ties as Albanese Seeks Trade Certainty (archynewsy.com)
- China Begins Process to Elect 2.6 Million Deputies Through 2027 (newsy-today.com)