On Thursday, U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday issued an order in Tampa delivering a partial win for President Donald Trump in a defamation lawsuit, which a press freedom group argued relied on a distortion of landmark Supreme Court precedent.
The case involves a complaint filed by Trump against The New York Times, three of its journalists, and Penguin Random House over two articles and a book, MS NOW reported.
Trump’s lawyers argued that the publications tarnished his professional reputation as a businessman and television star, according to MS NOW, Yahoo, and AOL. The defendants countered that Trump failed to prove “actual malice” under the 1964 Supreme Court ruling in New York Times v. Sullivan.
Judge Merryday Issues Partial Ruling
Merryday, a George H.W. Bush appointee, said that both sides agreed the Sullivan precedent governs the case, though they debated how it applies.
The judge ruled that the lawsuit cannot proceed on most challenged statements, but allowed claims regarding seven specific statements to advance. Surviving passages include assertions from a book that Trump received over $400 million from his father through fraudulent tax evasion schemes, and an article alleging authorities found money laundering rule violations.
“that the defendants knew they needed a formal legal expert opinion but failed to obtain that expertise. The judge reached that conclusion notwithstanding the journalists' reliance on experts, including one who called the conduct at issue” highly suspicious and potentially criminal, U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday wrote.
This conclusion came despite the journalists’ reliance on experts who called the conduct “highly suspicious” and potentially criminal, MS NOW, Yahoo, and AOL reported.

Trump Seeks Supreme Court Review of Clinton Lawsuit
Meanwhile, Trump has asked the Supreme Court to revive a lawsuit against Hillary Clinton over the 2016 election, which lower courts rejected because it was filed too late in 2022. Clinton’s lawyers urged the justices to stay out of the dispute, highlighting other personal lawsuits Trump initiated while in office.
“Trump filed a slew of lawsuits in his personal capacity during both of his presidential terms,” Clinton’s lawyers stated in a court filing, according to MS NOW, Yahoo, and AOL.
Trump-aligned figures have previously sought to narrow or reverse the Sullivan precedent without success, including a recent bid by Alan Dershowitz against CNN, MS NOW reported.
Merryday, born in Palatka, Florida, in 1950, served as student body president at the University of Florida before entering private practice in Tampa. Nominated by President George H.W. Bush in 1991, he later served as Chief Judge of the Middle District from 2015 to 2020. During the COVID-19 pandemic, he issued high-profile rulings blocking CDC cruise ship restrictions and preventing the Navy from removing the unvaccinated commander of a $1.8 billion warship.
“No party disagrees” that it governs the case, Merryday wrote in his order, according to MS NOW and Yahoo.