Jury Convicts Dwain Hall of Murdering Sonia Exelby, Who Paid Him $4,000 to Kill

Dwain Hall, 54, was sentenced to life in prison without parole in a Florida court on Friday after a jury convicted him of first-degree murder and kidnapping in the death of Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old British musician who paid him $4,000 to kill her.

The verdict came after one hour and 20 minutes of deliberation in Marion County Judicial Courthouse in Ocala, concluding a four-day trial that laid bare a two-year online grooming operation conducted on a fetish website. The Sydney Morning Herald reported that Hall, who used the moniker “AlphaSadist,” exploited Exelby’s severe mental illness — including bipolar disorder, depression, and a history of childhood trauma — for his own sadistic gratification. Exelby flew from Portsmouth, England, to Florida in October 2023. Her body was discovered on October 17 in a shallow grave near a highway in Marion Oaks, clad only in a bra and sandals with her dress laid atop her, according to testimony from Special Agent Rebekah McKinzie cited by The Portsmouth News. She had been stabbed four times. Handwritten notes Exelby wrote during her flight and while held captive in an Airbnb cabin in Reddick were read to the jury. “I’m screaming like I’m in a saw trap,” she wrote mid-flight. Sara Exelby, who flew from Australia, testified that the family had contacted police in November 2023 after Sonia warned them she was being threatened by men online. Sara Exelby said Sonia had tried to gather evidence against the predators targeting her and her online friends.

Hall’s defense attorney, Junior Barrett, delivered an opening statement lasting 67 seconds, arguing Exelby had made an informed decision because she could plan a trip and perform daily tasks. He called no witnesses. Hall sat impassively throughout the proceedings, occasionally giggling with his lawyer, and never looked at the family.

She wanted it to be done.”

Agent McKinzie testified Hall admitted to having “rough” sex with Exelby involving choking and hitting her, and that he filmed a video of her he later deleted because she was “not behaving right.” Hall was arrested after using Exelby’s debit card to charge $900 to his roadside repair business; police found her DNA on his customized knife. Exelby, a classically trained musician who played guitar, piano, and flute, had been in foster care as a child due to her father’s drug abuse and her mother’s mental health struggles. She suffered from bulimia, anorexia, and acute self-harm, including using syringes to extract blood, and had attempted suicide twice in her twenties. She lived in Portsmouth with her fiancé, Stevie Hunt. The family is now seeking to establish an organization to protect others with mental health conditions from online exploitation.”

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

David Lynch’s Disowned 1984 ‘Dune’ Adaptation Now Streaming on Canal+

FDA Approves Once-Weekly Sogroya for Turner Syndrome in Children