The piece lands as the country still reckons with the riots that followed the police killing of Nahel Merzouk, a 17-year-old of Algerian descent, during a traffic stop in Nanterre on June 27.
French law forbids the state from collecting data on race, ethnicity, or religion, a prohibition rooted in the 1789 Declaration of the Rights of Man and reinforced by a 1978 data-protection statute that carries penalties of five years in prison and a €300,000 fine.
The Journal notes that this legal architecture makes it impossible for officials to confirm or deny whether those detained in the rioting were disproportionately descended from immigrants, a claim traded freely by politicians across the spectrum.
Marine Le Pen, leader of the National Rally, attributed the violence to neighborhoods with large immigrant populations. Jean-Luc Mélenchon, head of La France Insoumise, countered that brutal and chaotic police tactics fueled the conflagration. The government of President Emmanuel Macron pointed instead to “ultraleft” agitators. Without statistics, the Journal writes, each faction argues from conviction rather than evidence.

The taboo traces to the Vichy regime’s collaboration with Nazi Germany, when identity cards stamped “Jew” facilitated deportations. Postwar France embraced universalism — the idea that the Republic recognizes only citizens, not communities — as a bulwark against that history. The 1958 Constitution enshrines equality before the law “without distinction of origin, race or religion.”
The request was denied.
The Journal contrasts the French model with the United States and the United Kingdom, where racial and ethnic statistics underpin affirmative-action programs, voting-rights enforcement, and public-health targeting.
Critics in France counter that such categories reify the very divisions the Republic seeks to dissolve, and that American-style identity politics would import a foreign taxonomy ill-suited to a country where the largest minority groups trace their roots to former colonies in North and West Africa rather than to a history of chattel slavery.
Macron acknowledged the tension in a televised address on July 14, calling for a “republican awakening” but stopping short of endorsing ethnic statistics. A parliamentary commission launched in September is examining whether the 1978 law should be amended to allow limited, anonymized data collection for research purposes. Its report is due before the summer recess.
The riots have also revived debate over the 1905 law on secularism, which bans religious symbols in public schools. Some lawmakers argue that the inability to measure religious affiliation hampers efforts to monitor radicalization; others insist that any breach of the colorblind principle would betray the Republic’s founding compact.
For now, the official portrait of France remains a silhouette — equal in theory, opaque in practice.