KiwiSaver Providers Warn Against Cashing Out at 65 Amid Inflation Risk

“Turning 65 shouldn’t automatically mean cashing out or moving everything into conservative investments,” Ana-Marie Lockyer, chief executive of Pie Funds, argued this week, highlighting a critical disconnect in the financial services industry. Experts across the New Zealand wealth management landscape are raising alarms that the industry has focused too heavily on helping people accumulate retirement savings, while neglecting the crucial advice needed to manage and draw down those funds.

The Financial Markets Authority has officially said that more guidance must be provided to those reaching the age of 65 and becoming eligible to access their KiwiSaver accounts. This isn’t merely a technical update; it’s a strategic warning. For many New Zealanders, their retirement savings could need to last another two decades, or even longer, making the way they handle their money today fundamentally important.

Lockyer emphasized that there is a lack of awareness regarding the ability of individuals to remain invested in KiwiSaver even after turning 65. For those with growing nest eggs, that option makes profound financial sense, particularly when faced with the realities of increasing life expectancy and persistent inflation.

The Erosion of Savings Through Over-Conservatism

One of the most insidious traps for retirees is the temptation to move all their capital into cash or overly conservative investments immediately upon reaching retirement age.

“Robyn Conway, general manager of wealth at Fisher Funds, said many people had been conditioned to think they needed to withdraw all their money when they had access to it,” Robyn Conway, general manager of wealth at Fisher Funds, said. However, experts suggest this mindset could be financially detrimental over a 20-plus year retirement.

The industry’s shift in focus is being driven by the need to protect purchasing power. Without growth, savings effectively lose value every day due to rising costs, a phenomenon known as inflation. As Milford, through Ben Brinkerhoff, pointed out, putting all your money in the bank and watching it sit can be a slow way of going backwards against inflation.

The reality is that keeping money working hard for you, while still allowing for withdrawals to top up income or address big-ticket items, is the key to sustainable retirement income. This strategy requires a sophisticated approach that moves far beyond simple cash withdrawals.

The Strategic Power of the “Bucket” Method

The solution being championed by leading firms is the adoption of a “goals-based approach,” or the “bucket” method. This involves segmenting one’s entire savings portfolio into different risk profiles based on when the money is actually needed. Short-term needs require safety, but long-term capital demands growth. This isn’t about risk tolerance alone; it’s about synchronizing spending with market cycles.

Ana-Marie Lockyer detailed this strategy, stating that while money needed in the short term might reside in cash or conservative assets, savings not required for another 10 or 20 years should remain invested for growth. The precise balance of this allocation is, of course, dependent on individual circumstances, income requirements, and personal risk appetite.

Fisher Funds echoed this sentiment, suggesting that the bucket method allows individuals to keep their second and third investment buckets actively working over time. This keeps the cash bucket replenished as needed for immediate expenses or large purchases. The goal is to provide stability while maximizing long-term growth potential.

A Culture of Proactive, Independent Advice

Perhaps the most significant gap identified across the industry is the timing of financial education. The conversation about retirement security shouldn’t begin at age 65; it should start long before. The industry must move from merely accumulating savings to actively supporting how those savings are managed once the door opens to drawdown.

Ben Brinkerhoff, speaking for Consilium, expressed concern over those who lack professional guidance during these critical transitions. He said that having lump sums suddenly available is a major temptation, and without expert advice, making the best decision can be genuinely unclear. For those who use schemes available only through advisors, the process is planned and anticipated; for those without that structure, the transition can be chaotic.

This is where the demand for independent advice is critical. Brinkerhoff stated his desire to see advice become easier to access for those who are not served by the specific provider holding their KiwiSaver account. This external perspective is vital, ensuring the advice is truly in the client’s best interest, not just the provider’s.

Retirement Planning Requires Individual Assessment, Not Generic Advice

The complexity of modern retirement planning means that generic advice simply won’t suffice. As Helen McDowall, chief investment products officer at MAS, noted, there is no inherent need to automatically change investment settings or withdraw savings at 65. The right approach requires a deep dive into individual circumstances, including other income streams, existing assets, spending needs, and personal risk tolerance.

The data suggests a growing recognition of the need for tailored support. For instance, MAS reported that about 15.3 percent of its members were aged over 65, significantly higher than the national average of 7.42 percent at the time of the report.

To help bridge this knowledge gap, many providers are rolling out sophisticated tools. Milford mentioned that they send members a series of emails as they approach 65, outlining fund options and highlighting an online tool. This tool allows members to project how much they can draw down annually depending on their chosen fund and how long they wish the funds to last, making the complex math more accessible.

Ultimately, the conversation is shifting from simply reaching retirement to achieving genuine financial security throughout the entire retirement phase. As Ana-Marie Lockyer concluded, “Ultimately, KiwiSaver shouldn’t just be about getting New Zealanders to retirement. It should be about helping them achieve financial security throughout retirement.”

Pie Funds, the Auckland-based fund manager behind the Pie KiwiSaver Scheme, has made a name for itself with a straightforward offering: four actively managed KiwiSaver funds whose names — conservative, balanced, growth and aggressive — are deliberately free of buzzwords. Notably, the scheme charges no performance fees despite its active management style, and membership is free for anyone under 13.

The scheme, previously known as the JUNO KiwiSaver scheme, has also pledged to follow an ethical investment policy, avoiding companies involved in weapons, tobacco, gambling and nuclear business. Its most aggressive fund, launched in May 2025, aims to maximise capital growth over periods exceeding ten years.

The consensus among experts is clear: a proactive financial strategy starting years before age 65 is essential. Transitioning from an accumulation mindset to a sustainable distribution model is the new frontier, one that requires nuanced planning to protect decades of hard-earned wealth from the relentless pressure of inflation and longevity.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Microsoft Adopts Intel Foundry EMIB-T Packaging for Azure Custom Chips