Mary Peltola Defeats Dan Sullivan in Alaska, Giving Democrats 56-44 Senate Majority

Democrat Mary Peltola has defeated two-term Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan in Alaska, the last U.S. Senate race resolved in the 2026 midterms, giving Democrats a 56-44 majority.

Her win on Tuesday completes a sweep of nine GOP-held seats — the party’s biggest midterm gain since 1958.

That is the headline number. The story behind it is stranger, and it matters far beyond Juneau.

Democrat Mary Peltola wins Alaska Senate race, defeating Republican Dan Sullivan — Associated Press

Peltola’s victory — reported first by CTV News and confirmed across the AP’s wire partners, including CBC’s account of the final count — came in a state President Donald Trump carried by roughly 13 percentage points in 2024. She won with 50.1 percent of the vote, a tally Fox News noted was enough to avoid a ranked-choice tabulation altogether.

Yet the win was anything but clean. In the final week of the campaign, the New York Times reported that Peltola’s aides, attorneys and national Democratic operatives had participated in a secret effort — internally dubbed the “ballot composition project” — to recruit a retired teacher named Dan J. Sullivan to run against the incumbent senator of nearly the same name.

Trump called for Peltola’s prosecution. The Justice Department sued to block certification if the incumbent lost. Peltola denied any involvement.

“I knew nothing about any other candidates on the ballot except for me and the incumbent,” Peltola told supporters in Juneau days before the election.

Two Sullivans, one ballot, a federal lawsuit

The second Sullivan — Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired teacher listed without party affiliation — finished third in the August primary with about 2.5 percent, far behind Peltola’s 49.5 percent and the senator’s 41.4 percent. Still, Alaska’s top-four system advanced him to the general election, where he appeared on both ballots alongside Dan S. Sullivan, the Republican incumbent.

He has denied any contact with Peltola’s campaign, according to CTV News, and has not responded to messages from the Associated Press since the Times report published. The Times based its reporting on text messages, documents and interviews with a former Peltola campaign manager, who was fired before the primary and later sought to recant her statements.

Then the machinery of the federal government moved. The Justice Department — in a lawsuit Trump said he ordered — sought to block certification pending an investigation into possible voter confusion. A federal judge dismissed the case; the department appealed.

Peltola called the lawsuit “flagrant corruption.” The Justice Department has confirmed a criminal investigation exists, but Alaska’s U.S. attorney would not say what potential crimes authorities are examining, as The Globe and Mail carried in its report.

Here is why that matters: a losing campaign’s fate is now tangled in unresolved legal questions that neither side has closed out. Sullivan’s spokesperson Nate Adams had said Monday the campaign would let the process “run its course until every legal vote is counted and certified.”

Adams did not respond to a request for comment after the result, and neither did a spokesperson for the National Republican Senatorial Committee — silence the Associated Press reported plainly.

Alaska flips blue: Democrat Mary Peltola wins Senate seat against Dan Sullivan — The Hill

The seat that capped a 56-44 map

Alaska was the ninth flip, and the scale deserves a moment’s comparison.

Senate contest Result
Republicans entering the midterms 53-47 majority
GOP seats flipped by Democrats 9
Democrats’ incoming majority 56-44
Previous Democratic margin this large 16 years ago
Last comparable midterm flip total 1958 (13 seats)
Peltola’s share of the vote 50.1%, avoiding ranked-choice count

“56 seats was an unimaginable result even just a few months ago,” Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer said in a statement posted on social media, as paNOW carried the AP’s report.

Mary Peltola Defeats Dan Sullivan in Alaska, Giving Democrats 56-44 Senate Majority
Photo: The Globe and Mail

The flips stretched far beyond swing territory — South Carolina, Texas, Kansas and Mississippi all fell to Democrats in conservative states. Alaska also elected a Democratic governor for the first time since 1998, as former state lawmaker Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins defeated three Republicans, including one endorsed by Trump. The Associated Press has not yet called the state’s U.S. House race, where independent Bill Hill is challenging Republican Rep. Nick Begich.

The Washington Post’s live results page framed the call the same way national strategists will read it: Alaska was the last domino, and it secured the historic sweep.

Why Anchorage economics beat Washington line items

Peltola’s campaign was not a national message dropped into Alaska. It was a local one that happened to land nationally. She talked about empty fish racks, unaffordable housing and parents in the Bush choosing between heating oil and food.

She spoke of diesel-dependent communities reachable only by air or water, of gas at $17 a gallon in remote places, of salmon grown scarce on the Kuskokwim River where she fished with her father.

“Having somebody who really understands what that means in D.C., representing us in the Senate, is an enormous achievement,” said Sam Schimmel, who is Alaska Native, in Anchorage after the win.

She distanced herself from national Democrats deliberately. “Alaskans who know me know that I’m not liberal or radical,” she said. “I am only interested in working for Alaska.” Sullivan countered by tying her to “Lower 48 liberals” bent on restricting oil and gas development; she answered that she would work with Trump for Alaska but “will never put any Lower 48 politician before Alaskans.”

The Globe and Mail adds a detail worth weighing: the race drew a flood of outside spending, and both Trump and Vice President JD Vance made separate trips to the state in the final month. The incumbent had the presidency’s surrogate power behind him. He lost anyway.

What remains unsettled

Peltola becomes just the fifth Democrat since statehood to hold Alaska’s Senate seat, the first Alaska Native to serve in the chamber, and the first from her party in it since Mark Begich — whom Sullivan unseated in 2014. “Today we take a monumental step forward in addressing those issues and putting Alaska first,” she said in her victory statement.

But the legal threads have not been cut. The Justice Department’s appeal of the dismissed certification suit is still alive, a criminal investigation exists with no public scope, and the second Sullivan has gone quiet since the Times report. Not every vote-certification fight ends when the AP makes its call.

Whether this victory ends as a landmark or an asterisk may turn on what federal investigators find next — and, for now, they are not saying what they are looking into.

Earlier coverage: Mary Peltola Unseats Dan Sullivan, Giving Democrats 56 Senate Seats

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Jennifer Lopez Calls Ben Affleck Divorce ‘Disappointing on Every Level,’ Confirms She Is Single