Mediafilm Publishes Book of 180 Masterpieces With Villeneuve Preface

Mediafilm, the Quebec film-rating body now in its eighth decade, has published a book gathering the 180 movies it has ever graded 1 — its top “masterpiece” mark — with a preface by Denis Villeneuve.

Chefs-d’œuvre : les 180 films cotés 1 par Mediafilm just arrived from Éditions de l’Homme, and it is already sparking the argument every cinephile loves.

La Presse’s culture desk broke the news this week, noting that Villeneuve wrote in the preface, “Ma cinéphilie y est née” — his cinephilia was born there. As a boy in Trois-Rivières, he waited impatiently for the Saturday Télé-Presse to study the ratings grids, hunting for films marked 1 or 2.

The catch: Mediafilm never gives a 1 on release. The organization waits 20 years before declaring a masterpiece — a patience almost unheard of in an industry that crowns films on opening weekend.

180 films earned lowest rating; only three Quebec titles

  • 180 films earned Mediafilm’s 1 rating across more than 70 years; only three are Quebec titles.
  • Just four of the 180 were directed by women — a gap critics are already flagging.
  • The book organizes films into about a dozen thematic “constellations” rather than a chronological list.

Why the 20-year rule matters now

Martin Bilodeau, the critic and director general who piloted the project, told La Presse the point was to make films “dialogue entre eux” — talk to each other — across eras.

“On voulait que ce soit ludique,” Bilodeau explained: they wanted a playful book, not a scholarly one, one that makes people want to watch the films.

Mediafilm Publishes Book of 180 Masterpieces With Villeneuve Preface
Photo: pesesurstart.com

The timing is not accidental. Villeneuve, now one of Hollywood’s most bankable auteurs, credits a weekly TV listings magazine for his film education.

Three Quebec films made the cut

Of the 180, only three are Quebec-made: Claude Jutra’s Mon oncle Antoine, Michel Brault and Pierre Perrault’s Pour la suite du monde, and Brault’s Les ordres, according to Pesesurstart. They sit alongside Citizen Kane, Taxi Driver, Pulp Fiction, The Godfather and the Coen brothers’ Fargo.

Film Director(s) Why it’s here
Mon oncle Antoine Claude Jutra Quebec’s coming-of-age landmark
Pour la suite du monde Michel Brault, Pierre Perrault Direct-cinema foundation stone
Les ordres Michel Brault The War Measures Act on screen

The blind spot critics won’t ignore

La Presse’s columnist counted only four women-directed films in the whole pantheon: Lotte Reiniger’s The Adventures of Prince Ahmed, Agnès Varda’s Cléo from 5 to 7, Chantal Akerman’s Jeanne Dielman and Jane Campion’s The Piano. The columnist argued Varda’s Vagabond, Barbara Loden’s Wanda and Claire Denis’s Beau travail belong there too.

Mediafilm’s own rule admits as much: masterpieces reveal themselves with time.

Consider The Night of the Hunter. Charles Laughton’s only feature flopped with critics and audiences in 1955, and Laughton never directed again. Only in the mid-1970s, championed by critics like Roger Ebert, did it become the southern-gothic classic now graded 1. The columnist saw it for the first time last week and was transfixed by the underwater shot of a drowned woman, hair drifting like riverweed.

Even Wes Anderson hasn’t seen them all

Nobody has. The columnist confessed to his boss that Soviet films and westerns were missing from his own viewing record. And Wes Anderson, at a Venice press conference years ago, admitted he had never heard of Sergei Parajanov’s The Color of Pomegranates — the very film many assumed shaped his aesthetic.

“Tu les as tous vus, j’imagine?” — you’ve seen them all, I imagine? — the boss asked. The honest answer, for everyone, is no. The book closes with a quiz and a checklist of all 180 titles with boxes to tick, and one veteran critic told the columnist she had seen two-thirds. He matched that count roughly. No cheating allowed.

What the constellations change

Bilodeau explained the “constellations” were born from wanting the films to form “le firmament du cinéma” — the firmament of cinema. So The 400 Blows, The Kid and Mon oncle Antoine cluster under “Childhood,” while Bonnie and Clyde, Taxi Driver and Dog Day Afternoon form “Revolt.”

Quebec filmmakers including Philippe Falardeau, Denis Côté, Pascal Plante, Micheline Lanctôt and Geneviève Dulude-De Celles contribute short texts on first encounters with these films, according to Lapresse. Bilodeau said he knew Villeneuve owed his cinephilia to Mediafilm’s ratings and “toucherais une corde sensible” by asking him for the preface. He accepted quickly.

The open question is whether a print canon built over 70 years can keep its authority — or whether the 20-year rule is exactly what a fast-moving film industry needs. Mediafilm’s own history answers quietly: The Night of the Hunter needed two decades and a generation of critics to be seen at all.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Anthropic Will Price Its Shares at $83 Each