Myanmar’s presidential spokesperson dismissed a landmark ruling from the International Court of Justice as unfair after judges determined the state committed genocide against the Rohingya minority.
The decision handed down on Thursday marked the first time in the world court’s 80-year history that it held a national government responsible for genocide. Judges found that a violent 2017 military campaign in Rakhine State, which forced hundreds of thousands of people to flee into neighbouring Bangladesh, included the systematic destruction of villages intended to eradicate the population.
“So this was not a unanimous decision … I would say it is not fair,” Myanmar’s presidential spokesperson said on Friday, according to reporting by The Guardian.
International Reactions Split over Court Authority
The ruling triggered sharply polarized responses across the international community, laying bare deep divisions over the authority of global legal institutions.
“The Myanmar military tried to convince the world that we had lied,” said 58-year-old Monajat Alam, from Rathedaung Township. “Today, the truth has been recognized.” As the ICJ delivered its landmark genocide ruling, thousands of Rohingya in refugee camps in Bangladesh awaited…
By contrast, European Union officials praised the judgment as a critical milestone for international justice, while the United Kingdom reaffirmed its full support for the court. The United States adopted a cautious stance, with the State Department stating it was examining the judgment while emphasizing the need to avoid the politicization of the court.
Legal Precedent for Global Cases
Legal scholars said that the judgment could significantly influence other high-stakes litigation before the world court, notably South Africa’s genocide case against Israel concerning the war in Gaza.
The @CIJ_ICJ has found #Myanmar responsible for genocide against the #Rohingya, in the case of The Gambia v. Myanmar. It is the first time in the court's history that a State has been held responsible under the Genocide Convention. https://t.co/QckKqbmo36 pic.twitter.com/E3JuQFZvyH
The court established that genocidal intent can coexist with a military objective, overcoming a notoriously difficult legal threshold. Richard Horsey, senior adviser for Asia at the International Crisis Group, observed that the ruling proves the crime can be proven in court despite an extremely high legal bar.
“The ICJ has never before found that a state committed genocide. The legal bar is extremely high, but what this case shows is that it is surmountable,” Horsey told The Straits Times.
Repatriation and Continuing Conflict
Alongside the genocide determination, the court ordered Myanmar to facilitate the safe return of refugees and provide financial reparations, with specific compensation amounts to be determined in subsequent proceedings.
United Nations General Assembly head Khalilur Rahman urged authorities to enact the measures during a visit to a refugee camp in Cox’s Bazar.
MULTIMEDIA: View photos and videos of the reading of the #ICJ Judgment in the case concerning Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (The #Gambia v. #Myanmar: 11 States intervening).https://t.co/oRTwbZIESg pic.twitter.com/y4LqB5ORfv
“A judgment on paper is not justice in life – now it must be given effect,” said Khalilur Rahman, calling for the Rohingya’s safe, voluntary and dignified return.
The International Court of Justice, seated in the Peace Palace in The Hague, is the only principal organ of the United Nations not located in New York City. Established by the UN Charter in June 1945, it began work in April 1946 as the successor to the Permanent Court of International Justice.
Its 15 judges are elected for nine-year terms by the General Assembly and Security Council, with no two judges permitted to hold the same nationality. While its judgments are binding and final, the court possesses no formal enforcement mechanism; compliance ultimately depends on the UN Security Council, where the veto power of permanent members can block action.
Civilian safety remains precarious as Myanmar’s ongoing civil war, triggered by the 2021 military coup, continues to claim lives across the country. In Rakhine State, local residents acknowledged that while repatriation must eventually occur, ongoing military airstrikes present severe risks to returning civilians.
LEARN MORE: The full text of the #ICJ Judgment in the case concerning Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (The #Gambia v. #Myanmar: 11 States intervening).https://t.co/IEAfHOc2Te pic.twitter.com/Ny8sCWLU9P
More on Myanmar
- Sister Jeanne Hagelskamp Installed as General Superior of Sisters of Providence with New Leadership Team
- Oil Set for Third Weekly Decline as Middle East Flows Fail to Offset Geopolitical Risks
- Russia Bombards Ukraine, Killing 8; Zelenskyy Calls It One of Largest Attacks (archyworldys.com)
- Xi Calls on US, Russia to ‘Completely Eliminate’ Nuclear Arsenals (newsy-today.com)