International Court of Justice Rules Thursday on Myanmar Genocide Case

The International Court of Justice rules Thursday on whether Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya, ending a seven-year case that began when Gambia filed suit in 2019.

Judges will read the decision at 10:00 (09:00 GMT) at the Peace Palace in The Hague, and it is final — there is no appeal.

At stake is more than one country’s record. The way the court defines genocidal intent — the hardest element of the worst crime in international law — will echo directly into the case South Africa brought against Israel in 2023 over Gaza, El País reported. The ruling could also shape how states are held to their duties to prevent genocide and punish its perpetrators.

World Court to Rule Thursday on Genocide Case Against Myanmar Over Rohingya — World News Checked

University of Amsterdam international law expert Marieke de Hoon told EFE that the court must examine not only whether genocide occurred, but whether Myanmar failed to prevent it, investigate the facts and punish those responsible, according to Abc. “The court does not have many opportunities to clarify the meaning of the terms used in the Genocide Convention,” she said.

“These are real people, real histories and a real group of human beings: Myanmar’s Rohingya. They have been subjected to an attempt at destruction,” said Dawda Jallow, Gambia’s justice minister, when hearings opened in January, according to EFE.

The numbers behind the case

More than 700,000 Rohingya fled to Bangladesh in 2017 alone, after a Myanmar army offensive in Rakhine state that witnesses described as murders, rapes and the burning of whole villages, EFE reported. The UN put it more bluntly: over a million Rohingya now live outside their homeland, most in Cox’s Bazar, which the organization calls the world’s largest refugee settlement.

El País, citing Amnesty International, traces the violence to October 2016, when armed Rohingya groups — including the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army — attacked police posts in Rakhine state and triggered a massive military crackdown. A 1982 law had already stripped the Rohingya, a Muslim minority of 1.1 million, of the ethnic status that carried citizenship, leaving them stateless.

Gambia’s distant hand

Gambia, a majority-Muslim nation thousands of kilometers from Rakhine, filed the case in 2019 backed by the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation. Under the 1948 Genocide Convention, any signatory state can sue another at the ICJ — but this is the first time a country with no direct connection to the alleged crimes has done so.

Eleven states, among them Canada, France, Germany, the United Kingdom and the Netherlands, later filed statements supporting Gambia’s reading of the convention.

“It is extraordinary that little Gambia decided to act on behalf of humanity,” American lawyer Reed Brody told El País.

Myanmar rejects the charge outright. Its representative Ko Hlaing told the court the 2016 and 2017 operations were responses to ARSA attacks, called the group terrorist, dismissed Gambia’s investigation as “rudimentary and partisan,” and blamed the pandemic, natural disasters and instability in Rakhine for hampering repatriation efforts.

International Court of Justice Rules Thursday on Myanmar Genocide Case
Photo: abc.com.py

Proof of intent, from Srebrenica to Gaza

The legal bar is brutal. To establish state responsibility, the flaw in the evidence must leave only one possible conclusion — that the state intended to destroy a group in whole or in part, Asier Garrido Muñoz, a former ICJ clerk, told El País. Intent is rarely announced; de Hoon told EFE it usually must be proven through circumstantial evidence such as dehumanizing speech or patterns of violence.

In 2007, the ICJ found Serbia had not committed genocide directly at Srebrenica — where about 8,000 Bosniak Muslim men were killed — but had violated its duty to prevent and punish it. That distinction between committing and failing to prevent is exactly where Thursday’s ruling is expected to land.

Rohingya Refugees Hope ICJ Will Deliver Justice — The Daily Guardian

It is the precedent South Africa leaned on in 2023. De Hoon warned that “many genocides are committed alongside military objectives,” and that it would be “very strange” if a military aim could ever fully exempt a state from the convention, EFE reported. How these judges weigh UN reports and circumstantial intent, Brody told El País, “will have enormous repercussions for the Gaza case.”

What a ruling can and cannot do

The ICJ settles disputes between states; it does not try individuals. If Myanmar loses, the court may order it to halt any conduct violating the convention, punish perpetrators and compensate victims, El País reported. Separately, the International Criminal Court opened a 2019 investigation into deportation and persecution of the Rohingya — a crime partly committed on Bangladeshi soil, which gave those judges jurisdiction despite Myanmar not being an ICC member.

Human Rights Watch said the ruling “will mark a crucial moment in the Rohingya’s search for justice,” while warning that persecution continues and that a safe, voluntary return of refugees remains far off, according to EFE. Since the February 2021 coup, the Rohingya have been caught between the junta and the very armed groups the army targeted in 2016.

Whatever the judges decide Thursday, the verdict — like the earlier Srebrenica case — carries no appeal.

Verdict week in the Myanmar genocide case — FRANCE 24 English

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Miss Ireland 2026 crowned at Dundalk’s Fairways Hotel on Saturday, 21 November