Naples City Council Re-evaluates Underground Garage Standards to Balance Parking, Flood Risks

Rising groundwater and roughly 7 inches of sea level rise since the mid-1960s force Naples officials to re-evaluate building standards for underground garages, balancing parking shortages and land costs against severe flood risks.

As reported by Gulfshore Business, the municipal government in Naples is looking again at underground parking facilities and ways to justify stricter standards that weigh aesthetics, land expenses, flood hazards, and safety amid limited downtown parking. City leaders are currently assessing whether extra construction rules and flood-mitigation tactics are necessary to safeguard subterranean parking from rising groundwater, torrential rain, and storm surges.

“Below grade parking has real community and development benefits in Naples,” Naples Building Official Steve Beckman said council at its Nov. 16 workshop.

“High land values create pressure to place parking beneath a building rather than use scarce ground area. Moving parking below grade frees the site for landscaping, open space, pervious area. It also avoids an above-grade garage or podium facing the street, so buildings sit lower and fit the scale of their neighborhood.” City Building Official Steve Beckman said.

Beckman said that such advantages come paired with heightened vulnerability, explaining that a subterranean facility in Naples could encounter heavy rainfall, king tides, elevated groundwater, storm surges, and the conditions associated with Federal Emergency Management Agency Special Flood Hazard Area designations in Coastal A and AE zones.

“The policy question is how Naples should balance the land use and aesthetic benefits against the increased flood, structural, operational and construction exposure” Naples Building Official Steve Beckman said.

Following Hurricane Ian and its associated severe storm surges, safety hazards—such as underground saltwater fires and electric vehicles—and intense flooding, the Naples City Council voted in September 2023 to halt all approvals and plans for subterranean parking structures.

M Development, operating under the name Fifth Avenue South Holdings, filed a lawsuit against the municipality three months later, asserting that the vote constituted an unlawful moratorium that disrupted its downtown redevelopment initiatives, even though five separate plans featuring underground parking had already gained approval.

In June 2024, the municipality resolved the litigation, permitting the development—currently known as The Avenue—to proceed minus any below-grade parking. Because more parking is needed downtown, council voted in March 2025 to define underground parking.

Established in the wake of Hurricane Andrew in 1992, Florida boasts one of the strictest building codes in the United States, which severely limits or outright bans subterranean garages across numerous locations due to rigorous water-table, coastal, and floodplain regulations. “Naples already enforces a strong state code and has adopted targeted local measures where flood risk supports them,” Naples Building Official Steve Beckman said.

Following the resolution of the legal dispute, the Four Seasons Naples Beach Club constructed subterranean parking, and during June, the council greenlit 64 underground spots for The Viceroy—now designated as The Victor—which is a mixed-use project situated beside the Gordon River along the Fifth Avenue South bridge.

The city’s 2024 vulnerability assessment documents pressure from both coastal water and rainfall, with Gulf satellite data suggesting the rate of sea level rise is accelerating.

Beckman pointed out that overlapping weather phenomena can exacerbate situations, observing that heavy urban stormwater drainage can be hampered when a king tide diminishes the discharge capacity of outfalls. Hurricane surge adds another pathway, as Naples experienced during Hurricane Ian in 2022 and hurricanes Helene and Milton in 2024.

The city can consider a technical amendment to the Florida Building Code, a flood-related amendment to improve flood resistance, or using the floodplain ordinance or land development code without changing building design or construction. Officials also must consider Senate Bill 180, which ends Oct. 1, 2027, restricting municipalities from adopting more restrictive comprehensive plan or land-development regulation amendments or more burdensome permitting procedures.

FloodReady founder and engineer Shimi Tzobery addressed Naples City Council during the Nov. 16 workshop, emphasizing that less than 10% of the city is in a special flood-hazard area.

Last year marked the publication of ASCE 24-24, a fresh Flood Resistant Design and Construction standard from the American Society of Civil Engineers, which Tzobery noted will see integration into the International Building Code this December, with anticipated adoption by Florida arriving by December 2029.

Higher design water levels change how underground parking must be designed and floodproofed, Tzobery said, including hydrostatic uplift, water entry, filtration, drainage, utilities and any opening that could need to be sealed and mitigated. He outlined four goals: protecting people, protecting the building and surroundings, controlling water entry, and ensuring buildings operate as designed.

“This will need to be a procedure and somebody will need to inspect it,” Tzobery told Gulfshore Business, noting that preplanning is needed to relocate vehicles before a storm hits due to risks of saltwater damage to EV batteries and hazardous electrical damage.

Steve Beckman, the city’s building official, has served as director of Building Services for Naples and holds state certifications as a General Contractor, Building Contractor, Building Code Administrator, Standard Building Inspector, and Plans Examiner. He earned a Bachelor’s degree from Concordia College and is a member of the Building Officials Association of Florida and the Association of State Floodplain Managers.

Regulatory Milestone Date Action Taken
Initial Moratorium September 2023 City Council stopped underground garage approvals following Hurricane Ian.
Lawsuit Settlement June 2024 City settled with M Development, allowing The Avenue to proceed without below-grade parking.
Definition Vote March 2025 Council voted to officially define underground parking to address downtown needs.
Statutory Deadline October 1, 2027 Senate Bill 180 restriction period ends for municipal land-development regulations.

Before presenting potential paths forward to the council, Beckman indicated that the subsequent phase involves assessing Naples-specific hazards and practical mitigation strategies through preliminary cost-benefit evaluations, feasibility reviews, engineering analyses, and residual risk assessments. Council member Berne Barton said that being able to provide underground parking without exceeding height restrictions would provide relief to local parking issues, and council will continue the discussion in January or early February.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Khuzani Releases “Isihlangu Somnumzane” Album (21 Tracks) Nov 20, 2026

Russia Rejects NATO Membership for Ukraine, Open to Other Guarantees