New Mexico Advocates and Lawmakers Decry Federal Education Tax Credit as Voucher Scheme

New Mexico’s teachers union president says a federal tax credit worth up to $1,700 per donor is really a voucher scheme — and on Tuesday she stood beside lawmakers to say so publicly, as the program takes effect on Jan. 1, 2027.

The clash centers on a decision Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham made earlier this month, when she announced the state would join the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit program as its 32nd participant, as Source New Mexico first reported. Advocates call it a backdoor privatization. The governor’s office calls it the only way to keep federal tax money flowing into New Mexico classrooms.

At stake is the legacy of Yazzie/Martinez, the landmark court ruling that found the state had failed to provide equitable education support to English language learners, Native American students, students from low-income families and students with disabilities. Opponents argue the new program risks undoing exactly what that case was fought to protect.

“May be packaged as an opportunity for families, but let’s be clear, this is a voucher scheme,” said Bethany Jarrell, president of the National Education Association New Mexico, at Tuesday’s news conference. She said that the New Mexico Constitution establishes a responsibility to educate all children, while the private “scholarship granting organizations” at the heart of the program carry no such obligation.

How the credit works

The program was created in President Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act, enacted last year. Eligible taxpayers can claim a federal tax credit of up to $1,700 annually for charitable contributions to qualified nonprofit scholarship granting organizations, which then award scholarships to K-12 students in both public and non-public schools for qualified educational expenses.

States choose whether to opt in. New Mexico’s participation begins Jan. 1, 2027.

New Mexico Advocates and Lawmakers Decry Federal Education Tax Credit as Voucher Scheme
Photo: newsfromthestates.com

Lujan Grisham framed her decision as pragmatism in a tightening fiscal climate. “Time of diminishing federal investment in education, New Mexico must take advantage of every dollar we can to bolster public education and continue our state’s upward trajectory in literacy and student achievement,” she said in a statement announcing the opt-in.

The governor’s defense

Her communications director, Michael Coleman, pushed back against critics in an emailed statement to Source New Mexico. The governor “would have preferred more direct federal investment in public education in lieu of this tax credit — full stop,” Coleman wrote.

He added that the credit is open to public school students and that Lujan Grisham “is doing everything she can to make sure they benefit from it.”

Coleman laid out the choice as the governor saw it: opt in and let donations flow to public and private school students in New Mexico, or opt out and watch donors in New Mexico and elsewhere who claim the credit send their money to other states. “Given those limited choices, Governor Lujan Grisham decided to keep that money in New Mexico where it belongs,” he said.

New Mexico Advocates and Lawmakers Decry Federal Education Tax Credit as Voucher Scheme
Photo: yahoo.com

Lawmakers see a backdoor

Several Democratic legislators aren’t buying the arithmetic. Sen. Linda Lopez of Albuquerque said at the news conference she was “very disappointed” in the governor’s decision, calling it a “voucher program is a backdoor entry to remove money from our public schools.”

The Legislature, she said, has stood against “anything that is associated with vouchers” — and she pointed to the political horizon. “As we move forward under a new governor, I will stand with my colleagues to say no, we will not.”

Rep. Andrés Romero, chair of the House Education Committee, went further in a phone call with Source New Mexico, arguing the decision undermines the Legislature’s work on behalf of Yazzie/Martinez students. “These voucher programs in the states that have had them disproportionately gone to affluent families and students, and have benefited private school over public schools,” Romero said.

Claims that the program will fund things like after-school programs? He called those “a hope and a wish.”

Why the equity ruling hangs over this fight

The Yazzie/Martinez case is more than legal history here — it’s the measuring stick both sides are using. Loretta Trujillo, executive director of Transform Education NM and a Yazzie/Martinez reform advocate, told Tuesday’s gathering the state cannot afford to import the policy.

“New Mexico must not import a policy that risks deepening educational inequities while leaving public schools with greater responsibility and fewer resources,” said Loretta Trujillo, executive director of Transform Education NM.

The tension is structural: the constitutional duty to educate every child rests with the state, but the scholarship organizations that will distribute this money are private entities with no such mandate. That gap — between a public obligation and private discretion — is where opponents say the inequity lives.

Voucher opponents prepare for the 2027 program implementation

The program takes effect Jan. 1, 2027, leaving a narrow window before donors can start claiming credits. Lopez’s reference to “a new governor” signals the fight may outlast Lujan Grisham’s tenure, with voucher opponents already organizing for the next legislative session.

Source New Mexico notes the story was updated after publication to include the governor’s office comment, a sign the administration felt the pressure of the backlash.

Whether the $1,700 credit becomes a lifeline for New Mexico’s underfunded classrooms or a slow leak from them is the question Lopez and Romero intend to force in Santa Fe. “As we move forward under a new governor, I will stand with my colleagues to say no, we will not,” Lopez said.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

BBC and CBC Adapt E.M. Forster’s “A Passage to India” with Indian Perspective in Five-Part Series

Publix Employees Federal Credit Union Limits Membership to Publix Workers