NFL, CBS Sports 2024 Redraft: Drake Maye Goes No. 1 to Bears Over Caleb Williams

CBS Sports published a 2024 NFL redraft on Tuesday that would place Drake Maye at No. 1 overall to the Chicago Bears and drop Caleb Williams to No. 2 to the Washington Commanders.

The redraft reflects two years of regular-season data showing Maye led the league in completion percentage and yards per attempt in 2025 en route to an MVP runner-up finish, while Williams cut sacks dramatically and posted eight fourth-quarter comebacks since 2025, NFL reported.

“It was upsetting at first, but you got two choices,” Jared Verse said at his introductory press conference after being traded from the Rams to the Browns in June. “You can either work or you can give up, and I ain’t never been a quitter.”

Four quarterbacks from the historic 2024 class — Williams, Jayden Daniels, Maye and Bo Nix — have led their teams to the playoffs, while the No. 8 pick Michael Penix Jr. and No. 10 pick J.J. McCarthy have struggled, according to CBS Sports. The exercise assumes the same team needs that existed on April 25, 2024, meaning the Arizona Cardinals still select a non-quarterback at No. 4.

Bears’ calculus shifts to Maye over Williams

CBS Sports slotted Maye to Chicago at No. 1, citing his 2025 leap in accuracy and playmaking that produced an MVP runner-up season. The outlet described the choice between Maye and Williams as “brutally close” after both took massive leaps in their second year.

NFL, CBS Sports 2024 Redraft: Drake Maye Goes No. 1 to Bears Over Caleb Williams
Photo: cbssports.com

NFL detailed Williams’ trajectory under offensive coordinator Ben Johnson, noting his completion percentage rose from 58.1% in 2025 to 68.7% in 2026 and his passer rating climbed from 90.1 to 95.4. He has guided the Bears to a 16-7 record as a starter since 2025 with a division title and a playoff win.

Williams has engineered eight fourth-quarter comebacks, including six in 2025, but carries 24 career giveaways (18 interceptions, six fumbles lost) in 40 regular-season games, NFL reported. A four-interception performance against the Buccaneers in his most recent game shows the volatility that remains.

Commanders and Patriots land the other elite passers

At No. 2, CBS Sports assigned Williams to Washington, noting he “took his game to another level last year by cutting way down on negative plays — especially sacks — and improving massively as a pocket navigator and scrambler.” The outlet highlighted his ball security as a passer and out-of-structure creation as advantages over Maye.

Daniels falls to No. 3 to the New England Patriots in the redraft. CBS Sports acknowledged his electrifying rookie season but said “his second-year struggles — with injuries, a fall off in accuracy and less-than-ideal surroundings — can’t be completely overlooked, either.”

Cardinals address receiver need with Verse

With Kyler Murray still viewed as the franchise quarterback in this April 2024 framework, CBS Sports projected the Cardinals to select edge rusher Jared Verse at No. 4 overall. Verse was actually traded by the Rams to the Browns in June 2026 as part of the package for Myles Garrett, CBS Sports reported.

Trust rankings separate playoff starters from question marks

The 2024 class produced six top-12 quarterbacks, but only four have translated draft capital into playoff appearances. Nix at No. 12 joins Williams, Daniels and Maye as playoff starters, while Penix Jr. at No. 8 and McCarthy at No. 10 have struggled, CBS Sports noted.

Drake Maye entered the league as the third overall pick in the 2024 NFL draft, making him the first Patriot chosen in the top five since Drew Bledsoe in 1993. He earned Pro Bowl honors as a rookie and followed that by leading New England to its first division title since 2019 and an appearance in Super Bowl LX, adding a second Pro Bowl nod and second-team All-Pro honors in 2025.

At North Carolina, he won the Shaun Alexander Award and ACC Player of the Year in 2022 after leading the NCAA in total yards, and he finished his college career fifth in passing yards and fourth in passing touchdowns in program history.

Pick Original Selection Redraft Selection Playoff Appearances
1 Caleb Williams (CHI) Drake Maye (CHI) Yes
2 Jayden Daniels (WAS) Caleb Williams (WAS) Yes
3 Drake Maye (NE) Jayden Daniels (NE) Yes
8 Michael Penix Jr. (ATL) — No
10 J.J. McCarthy (MIN) — No
12 Bo Nix (DEN) — Yes

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Jennifer Lopez Dazzles in Silk Coat at ‘The JLo Show’ Las Vegas Premiere

No. 7 Texas A&M Opens SEC Tournament vs. LSU After Season Sweep