Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale’s ‘Madden’ Crumbles at 13% on Rotten Tomatoes

Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale’s new film “Madden” is getting pulverized by critics, holding a 13% positive rating on Rotten Tomatoes after its November debut on Prime Video, Espinof reported.

The biopic of the legendary NFL coach and broadcaster, directed by five-time Oscar nominee David O. Russell, skipped theaters entirely — and the reviews suggest the streamer saw it coming.

One of November’s most anticipated streaming releases, the film tells the story of John Madden, the coach and commentator whose name became a multibillion-dollar video game franchise launched in 1988 and still running today. On paper, that’s a winner: two of the most watchable actors of their generation, a beloved sports figure, and a built-in audience of millions of Madden NFL players. The math tells a different story.

The 13% score places “Madden” as the second-worst-reviewed film of Russell’s career, sitting only below “Accidental Love,” a project he abandoned before it was finished, Espinof noted. It has now been more than a decade since the director earned his last Oscar nomination, for “American Hustle.”

The reviews aren't just bad; they detail exactly how the film fails.

  • “Madden,” starring Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale, holds a 13% Rotten Tomatoes score.
  • It’s David O. Russell’s second-worst-reviewed film, behind only “Accidental Love.”
  • Critics call it overacted and choppy — a “glorified Saturday Night Live sketch.”

Critic Avi Offer didn’t mince words, calling it “an insipid, graceless and clumsy biographical picture that seems more like a glorified extended Saturday Night Live sketch with choppy editing,” Espinof reported.

Matt Donato reached for a football metaphor of his own. “It’s not that Russell fumbles at the goal line; he fails to catch the opening kickoff, tears his ACL and gets carted off the field,” he said, per Espinof.

David Rooney went further, questioning whether even the film’s natural audience would enjoy it. “Even if I were passionate about American football, I can’t imagine enjoying this caricatured biodrama much, led by actors who overact so much that they never let you forget they’re acting,” he said, according to Espinof.

When Prime Video announced “Madden” would premiere directly on its platform without a theatrical run, Espinof’s own reporting flagged the decision as suspicious. That instinct has now been borne out by the critical response — a pattern familiar from other prestige titles that quietly migrated to streaming after poor test receptions.

Prime Video released ‘Madden’, the film starring Nicolas Cage and Christian Bale, directly on streaming without a theatrical run, and a 13% score on Rotten Tomatoes is the kind of headline that makes subscribers think twice about what “exclusive” actually promises.

Key facts about “Madden” Detail
Rotten Tomatoes score 13% positive
Platform Prime Video, November release
Director’s Oscar nominations Five (last: “American Hustle,” over a decade ago)
Madden NFL franchise launch 1988, still active

Russell was once one of Hollywood’s most reliably nominated filmmakers, with five career Oscar nods. But the gap matters: his last nomination came more than ten years ago, for “American Hustle,” and the only film of his rated worse than “Madden” is one he walked away from before completion.

What happens next is the audience’s call. Critical consensus on “Madden” is settled; whether Prime Video viewers agree — and whether the film finds the Madden NFL fanbase it was built for — remains an open question as the weekend arrives.

“Even if I were passionate about American football, I can’t imagine enjoying this caricatured biodrama much,” Rooney said.

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Forbes Column: UFC Cut No. 3 Strawweight Virna Jandiroba; Writer Says Shift to Entertainment