Ohio’s Private Economic Development Arm Wants Its Million Dollars Back

Ohio’s private economic development arm wants its million dollars back after a biotech venture promising genetically engineered salmon left behind a half-built plant, three employees, and $122,255 in cash.

JobsOhio demanded repayment by Sunday, according to a Securities and Exchange Commission filing by AquaBounty Technologies. The agency handed over the grant in August 2021, shortly after the company unveiled plans for what was billed as the largest investment ever in rural Williams County — a $222 million facility in Pioneer supposed to deliver 112 jobs and a $5.4 million annual payroll by the end of 2026.

“Why the state was so eager to promote this industry is really puzzling,” said Sherry Fleming of the Williams County Alliance, a grassroots environmental group. “While AquaBounty had genetic engineering know-how, it seemed to have limited experience in production.”

Less than two years after the money arrived, construction stalled at roughly 30 percent complete. The site now languishes at the end of Kexon Drive, a smooth new road the village extended for the plant’s benefit. AquaBounty auctioned off “new” and “unused” equipment in 2024 and 2025 and sold its intellectual property for the genetically engineered salmon, ProPublica reported.

Ohio jobs program wants its money back after companys failure to deliver gmo salmon
Photo: iwpost.com

The mayor’s land deal

Locals had long questioned how Pioneer Mayor Ed Kidston’s personal interests intersected with the project. Kidston bought land the company wanted, then sold it to AquaBounty for $1.5 million more than he had paid. He did not respond to requests for comment; he has previously said his actions were intended only to help the community.

A rare clawback

JobsOhio issued a demand notice in September, informing the company that its equipment sales and its entertaining of acquisition offers for the Ohio farm breached the grant agreement. AquaBounty provided additional information in October, but the agency upheld its demand this month. The filing warns that “any collection or legal action by JobsOhio could result in additional costs and management distraction.”

“It’s pretty rare” for JobsOhio to pursue a clawback, said Kristan Wong Karinen, a research analyst with Good Jobs First, a nonprofit that tracks public subsidies.

“More commonly, it and other agencies will renegotiate the contract — extending the time period for a company to meet commitments, perhaps, or lowering requirements. In this case, with AquaBounty, because they haven’t done anything, they haven’t fulfilled any of the requirements, I feel like JobsOhio is being forced into this.”

Matt Englehart, a JobsOhio spokesperson, said the agency “operates with transparency and accountability,” though its limited disclosures have long been a sore point for Ohioans. He told ProPublica that when metric commitments are not met, “we work closely with those businesses” to help them overcome challenges.

If all options are exhausted, he added, “we will claw back some or all of our dollars so they can be used for future economic development projects to benefit Ohioans.”

AquaBounty said it remains in discussion with JobsOhio over the repayment demand and that “there can be no assurance that JobsOhio will agree to any payment schedule or other accommodation.”

JobsOhio was created in 2011 under then‑Governor John Kasich as a private nonprofit corporation, replacing the state’s traditional development department with a model intended to be more nimble and business‑focused.

Its funding comes from a lease of Ohio’s liquor enterprise rather than taxpayer appropriations, giving it a steady revenue stream independent of the legislative budget cycle. The organization operates with a staff of private‑sector experts and works through six regional partners across the state.

The grant required the company to maintain its investment and payroll commitments through the end of 2028. By the end of September, the company’s primary remaining assets were unsold equipment, the land in Pioneer, and the incomplete build.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

4 Things to Do in New Orleans This Weekend: Usher, French Fry Fest, and More

CleanTechnica Analysis Argues Energy Tracking Must Go Beyond Connections