Parents Jailed for 20 and 15 Years in 39-Year-Old ‘A10 Martyr’ Cold Case

A court in Blois sentenced the parents to 20 and 15 years, ending a 39-year wait for an answer.

They were expected to walk free, and instead they left in silence.

On Tuesday evening, after more than eight hours of deliberation, the Loir-et-Cher assize court sentenced Halima El Bakhti to 20 years of criminal imprisonment and Ahmed Touloub to 15 years, closing one of France’s oldest cold cases — the death of 4-year-old Inass Touloub, found by the A10 motorway in August 1987, according to Le HuffPost.

Both parents, aged 72 and 74, were immediately jailed. The verdict came two weeks into a trial that opened on November 2 in Blois, and it ends a 39-year wait for an answer to the question the little girl’s body posed: whose?

What made the outcome matter was what the court refused to do. The defense had asked the jurors to acquit Ahmed Touloub outright, according to Lemonde. The jurors declined, finding that he “could only have known of the abuse suffered by Inass Touloub” and that he had “facilitated the violence committed on Inass by Halima El Bakhti.”

Presiding judge Audrey Debeugny read the court’s reasoning shortly after 10 p.m. The acts of torture and barbarity were “perfectly characterized,” she said. Inass, the court found, in sa qualité de père, il lui appartenait de garantir la sécurité, la protection et la santé de sa fille.

Le Parisien described the scene: no cry, no sound, just two septuagenarians rising with difficulty and disappearing behind a door, their lawyers carrying supermarket bags toward their prison.

Parents Jailed for 20 and 15 Years in 39-Year-Old 'A10 Martyr' Cold Case
Photo: franceinfo

Thirty-nine years from a ditch to a verdict

The body was found on August 11, 1987, in a ditch beside the A10 at Suèvres, a village between Orléans and Tours. The remains bore burn marks from an iron and scars from human bites. Stumped for leads, the gendarmerie launched the largest witness appeal ever initiated in France, spanning some thirty countries.

Identification came only in 2018, more than three decades later, when DNA taken from one of Inass’s brothers in an unrelated violence case led to the parents’ arrest in June 2018. Le Monde notes the file, the subject of several books and documentaries, ranks among the oldest cold cases ever resolved in France.

Why the mother got 20, not life

Halima El Bakhti had faced life imprisonment. The court instead retained an “alteration of discernment” at the time of the acts, which lowered the legal maximum to 20 years — exactly what prosecutors had requested, with a 10-year security period. She was convicted of torture and acts of barbarity resulting in death without intent to give it.

On the stand, she could not explain the twenty-odd bites, the burns, the fractures, or the tearing of her daughter’s nipples. “I was not a human being, I slapped her, I hit her without knowing why,” she said, describing the period as “black.” In tears, she added: “Je suis désolée, je regrette,” before the court retired at 1:30 p.m. to deliberate.

Her lawyer, Camille Radot, conceded in her final plea that her client’s words were “inaudible,” “incomplete,” “sometimes confused” and “often shocking” — but insisted there were “You n’avez pas d’aveux, but not no contestation either.”

The father who watched

Ahmed Touloub’s defense had asked to acquit him. He had admitted witnessing some of the violence and called himself a “vaurien”, “incapable de protéger sa petite Inass.”

The prosecution was unmoved. Advocate general Stéphane Javet, who had sought 14 years with a seven-year security period, called him “un acteur central de cette stratégie,” insisting that “un parent n’a pas le droit de s’abstenir” and that the father “avait conscience du caractère criminel des actes commis par sa femme.”

Prosecutor Anaïs Allio had earlier told the court: “Les mots manquent pour décrire l’agonie d’Inass, qui s’est vidée peu à peu de son sang.”

Where Inass will rest

Even the verdict leaves one question open. Inass has lain in the cemetery of Suèvres since 1987, her grave regularly flowered. But her brothers and sisters have asked to “offrir un autre lieu de repos” for her, “en correspondance avec ses liens familiaux,” their lawyer Eléonore Terrien-Freneau said at the trial.

The mayor of Suèvres, Frédéric Dejente, hopes she stays. “Elle est là depuis 40 ans. On n’a pas l’intention de la voir partir,” he told France Inter on Wednesday, adding: “Enfin, on va pouvoir mettre un point final à toute cette histoire et Inass va pouvoir reposer en paix.”

The fratrie also put the child-protection association Mouv’Enfants on formal notice. All six surviving children of the couple joined the case as civil parties. Though Belmokhtar indicated that Ahmed Touloub will appeal the decision.

What remains unresolved is quieter: whether a nameless child on a motorway verge, once the subject of France’s largest witness appeal, finally gets to rest where a village has kept her grave for 40 years.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Max Admits He Is Dating Someone to Skip Caring for Tortu in RDS