Public Citizen Report: SEC Staffed by Former Defense Attorneys Under Atkins

“Under Paul Atkins, the SEC has radically transformed from a muscular investor watchdog into a drooling, subservient lapdog that does nothing but serve the very corporate interests it’s supposed to be keeping in check,” said Jon Golinger, democracy advocate for Public Citizen, in a statement.

The watchdog’s new report, released Wednesday, identifies at least a dozen high-level officials at the Securities and Exchange Commission with ties to the very firms they are tasked with overseeing. Truthout reported the findings, and the picture they paint is stark: defense attorneys for companies the agency once investigated now sit inside the enforcement division itself.

The SEC was created in response to the Great Depression as a safeguard against the corruption and conflicts of interest that led to that economic disaster. Public Citizen’s report argues those protections are being dismantled from within, with conflicts of interest acting less like a disqualifier and more like a selling point for leadership appointments under Atkins, a Donald Trump appointee confirmed by the Senate last year.

Among the actions since his confirmation: the SEC has dropped several of its cases against Atkins’s own former clients, Truthout reported. Atkins additionally appears to carry conflicts of interest stemming from his work with multiple firms and companies, including his prior leadership of three crypto companies and his holdings in crypto assets — a regulator whose own portfolio sits within the industry he oversees.

The revolving door, in numbers

Division of Enforcement director David Woodcock was formerly in-house counsel for ExxonMobil and a leader at the law firm Gibson Dunn, where he headed the firm’s Securities Enforcement Practice Group. There, he represented AT&T, ExxonMobil, SpaceX, UPS, the Abu Dhabi National Oil Company, and more.

Woodcock was twice named to the “Enforcement Elite” list by the legal publication Securities Docket — a distinction described as “the kind of defensive specialists critical to have on speed-dial should the SEC’s Division of Enforcement come calling.”

The pattern repeats across the agency. A senior adviser to the Crypto Task Force lobbied for the crypto nonprofit known as the Coin Center up until he was appointed in February 2025.

The Office of General Counsel is run by someone who once served as a managing director at BlackRock and as general counsel at the major firm Focus Financial Partners. The Division of Corporate Finance, its public relations head, and other parts of the agency carry similar ties, per the report.

“There are cases where criminal defense attorneys have transitioned to the IG community, but it certainly merits a pause to consider how adequately and aggressively someone who once defended alleged criminals and is now in charge of the office tasked with identifying and pursuing individuals who may have violated the law will be in their newfound role as an inspector general,” the report said.

What nobody can see

Here is the part that resists easy accounting: nobody knows the full extent of the conflicts. Muhlendorf and another official each declined to disclose 22 former clients on their forms, citing confidentiality requirements, the report notes.

The agency’s latest report on fiscal year 2026 shows enforcement actions plummeting, with penalties falling to an 18-year low — decreasing by nearly 24 percent over the previous fiscal year.

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Massachusetts) has previously criticized the SEC for essentially abandoning its mission of law enforcement, contributing to what Warren calls a “Golden Age of Fraud.” The new report may fuel further scrutiny of the SEC.

Public Citizen co-president Lisa Gilbert framed the stakes in personal terms.

“Trump has surrounded himself with people like Atkins, who view government service and political power as a means to bestow favors on their friends and associates and amass ever greater personal wealth,” Gilbert said. “And once again, the millions of Americans whose retirement funds and life savings depend on a fair securities marketplace are left out to dry.”

Why it lands now

The timing matters. Indeed, the most recent report on the agency’s actions in fiscal year 2026 reveals that its enforcement actions are dropping sharply. Over the past year, enforcement penalties at the SEC dropped to their lowest level in 18 years, down nearly 24 percent from the fiscal year before.

Warren’s earlier warnings about a “Golden Age of Fraud” now come with a documented roster of names, firms and undisclosed clients attached — and two officials each declined to disclose 22 former clients, citing confidentiality requirements.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

macOS 27.3 Beta 2 Overhauls Full Disk Access and Device Control Permissions