Pentagon policy chief Elbridge Colby walked out of the Ramstein meeting at NATO headquarters in Brussels on Monday, November 17, after publicly rebuking Ukraine for its long-range strikes deep into Russia.
He left before Ukraine’s defense minister delivered a closed briefing said to argue those strikes are essential to the war effort.
Colby, the under secretary of defense for policy, told the 37th meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group that strikes on what he called Russia’s civilian infrastructure — including oil refineries and Wildberries warehouses — are “not effective in terms of ending the war” and do not deter Russian advances on the front line, as the Ukrainian outlet European Pravda reported his remarks.
He added that such strikes had “likely only strengthened the resolve” of the Russian public and the Kremlin’s readiness to escalate.
The walkout startled German, British and other European officials in the room, The Telegraph reported on Wednesday. One German source told the paper: “In that room, the US was the only country that gave credence to the Russian narrative, not Ukraine and the rest of the coalition.”
Europe’s defense ministers did not stay quiet. Boris Pistorius of Germany called Colby’s assessment, in his words, “stupid.” British Defense Secretary Вес Стритинг — referred to in Ukrainian reports of the meeting as Wes Streeting, so a spelling confirmation is warranted here — defended Kyiv’s campaign instead.
“Эти удары помогли ослабить военную машину Путина, выигрывая время и спасая жизни”, Healey said after the talks, according to the Interfax-Ukraine account of the meeting.
A Walkout With Awkward Timing
The timing is difficult to dismiss as accident: Ukraine has spent roughly two weeks hammering Russia’s oil industry, and the results are measurable. Between October 30 and November 11 alone, Ukraine’s defense forces hit at least nine Russian refineries with Fire Point long-range drones, according to figures the company and Ukraine’s General Staff gave the outlet NV. Those plants represent more than 120 million tons of annual refining capacity — 36% of Russia’s total.

| Refinery | Status |
|---|---|
| Omsk | Struck November 11, some 2,500 km from Ukraine’s border; largest in Russia at over 21 million tons per year |
| Kirishi | Struck since October 30 |
| Ryazan | Struck since October 30 |
| Nizhny Novgorod | Struck since October 30 |
| Yaroslavl | Struck since October 30 |
Reuters reported on November 9 that the drone campaign since late October had cut Russia’s refining capacity by roughly 30% and left fuel shortages in at least six Russian regions. President Volodymyr Zelensky called the strikes a fair answer to Moscow’s attacks on Ukraine’s own power grid: “Вполне справедливый наш ответ на отказ России от деэскалации и на их удары по нашей энергетике”, he said in his evening address on November 15.
The Splits Run Deeper Than One Meeting
Colby was not, by his own account, demanding that Ukraine stop fighting at range altogether. “Это не означает, что Украину следует заставлять воевать со связанными за спиной руками”, he told the Ramstein gathering, according to Українська правда.
He argued the priority should be holding the front line, and he conceded that strikes on Russia’s war-sustaining facilities “may help slow Russia’s advance.” He also flagged an uncomfortable arithmetic: the balance of advantage in long-range exchanges “may well lie with Moscow.”
U. S. deputy Pentagon chief Elbridge Colby hit out today at Ukraine for its long-range strike campaign against Russia — a fresh blow to Kyiv as it seeks to shore up its negotiating position during peace talks with Moscow. https://t.co/Iwt2GX9iVW
Colby’s posture fits a pattern reported since August 2025, when American media described the Pentagon as blocking Ukrainian deep-strike requests for months — a review mechanism the Pravda report credits to Colby himself. This context lends weight to the suspicion one German source voiced to The Telegraph: that the administration of President Donald Trump is effectively siding with Russia’s reading of the war.
There is also a pointed irony circulating in European capitals, RBC-Ukraine noted: the United States has itself struck deep into Iran, while asking Kyiv to accept limits on targets it considers military.
The official reason for the early exit was a flight. Colby held a press conference in the NATO atrium at around 5 p.m. local time — 7 p.m. Moscow time, dw.com reported — and then headed to the airport, leaving Ambassador to NATO Matthew Whitaker to represent Washington for the rest of the session.
He skipped the secret presentation by Ukrainian Defense Minister Евгений Хмара — identified in the dw.com report as Yevhen Khmara — whose slides, sources said, stressed deep strikes as a vital component of the war effort.
NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte had drawn his own conclusion just that Monday, saying of Ukraine’s strike on the Kerch Bridge that Kyiv must be able to defend itself, including by hitting Russian logistics hubs.
Berlin Gets the Next Word
The argument now moves to Berlin. On Thursday, November 19, the UK prime minister — listed in dw.com’s report as Энди Бёрнем — co-chairs a meeting of the “coalition of the willing” with the French president and the German chancellor.
Around twenty heads of state and government, mostly European, will discuss continued support for Kyiv and postwar reconstruction, and The Telegraph adds that Trump’s special envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner will attend, with Kushner saying the talks will focus on postwar security guarantees and rebuilding Ukraine’s economy.
Domestic American politics complicate the picture further. NBC News reported, via RBC-Ukraine, that House Republicans are pressing to strip Ukraine military aid, intelligence-sharing and Russia sanctions provisions from the defense budget, while Democrats — who take the House majority in January — are preparing a $15 billion military aid package for Kyiv alongside tougher sanctions on Moscow. A White House bracing for Democratic investigations sits behind all of it.

Meanwhile, a separate dispute over Starshield access shows how fragile Ukraine’s Western support has become. Zelensky said on November 12 that satellite restrictions were crippling Ukrainian drone interception along the front; Ukraine’s chargé d’affaires in Washington, Denys Senik, said mission failure rates climbed from 10% on the first day to 50%, then effectively 100%. A bipartisan group of 105 members of Congress demanded the administration and SpaceX restore full access.
Republican Representative Don Bacon put it bluntly: “Независимо от того, это решение исполнительной власти или господина Маска, оно приводит к гибели большего количества украинцев. Такие действия помогают военному преступнику Путину. Конгресс должен провести масштабный надзор и установить, кто несет ответственность. Становиться на сторону тирана — это не по-американски”, he wrote when calling for a congressional investigation into who ordered the limits.
For now, the question European officials are asking is the one The Telegraph’s German sources posed: whether Washington’s posture inside the Ramstein format now tracks Moscow’s. The answer gets its next test on Thursday, when the coalition of the willing convenes in Berlin with two American envoys in the room.
❗️US Deputy Secretary of Defense Elbridge Colby criticized Ukrainian deep-strikes at the Ramstein meeting, specifically targeting logistics centers like Wildberries that were actively supplying drone components and ammunition. He stated that such strikes fail to achieve the goal… pic.twitter.com/mSFUdirO0R