“Overnight we’re not going to have a place to live,” said J.L., a 24-year-old Los Angeles public housing resident who could be forced apart from her undocumented parents under a federal rule taking effect mid-December.
Public Counsel, a Los Angeles-based nonprofit law firm, sued the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development in federal court late Monday night to block the rule, which would require every person living in federally funded public housing to prove certain legal immigration status to remain in their home.
The lawsuit was filed on behalf of three Los Angeles public housing residents identified in court papers only by their initials.
The rule would end a decades-long provision that let families whose members hold different immigration statuses live together in subsidized public housing or in units paid for with federal vouchers.
Under the current framework, family members without certain legal status — such as U.S. citizenship or asylum — do not receive the federal subsidy themselves, and the household’s monthly rent is prorated, generally meaning it pays more. Households still must prove income to qualify, even when some members are ineligible for rental discounts.
Attorneys with Public Counsel argue HUD lacks the authority to make the change on its own. That power, they contend, rests with Congress, which enacted the original rule allowing mixed-status families to live together. According to KABC, the plaintiffs are asking the court to postpone the rule’s effective date, bar its enforcement in California’s Central District and ultimately declare the policy unlawful.
Thousands of mixed-status households at stake
According to HUD, the nationwide public housing population included 79,300 members of mixed-status families as of 2024, among them 7,190 households in California. In the city of Los Angeles, the Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, or HACLA, reports 7,700 mixed-status family members in public housing, and 1,709 mixed-status families currently receiving public housing assistance.
A separate account carried by MyNewsLA cited HACLA estimates of roughly 1,700 families representing an estimated 7,500 Angelenos — a figure that does not exactly match the 7,700-person count, so the local impact estimates remain unsettled.

HACLA serves more than 67,000 households, making it the largest low-income housing provider in Los Angeles. In a statement, the agency said: “We are currently reviewing the final regulation and assessing its applicability, operational requirements and compliance timelines. We will pursue all avenues.”
The rule excludes immigrants in the country illegally and people with certain temporary protections — including recipients of DACA, or Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals — from federally funded rent subsidies. According to HUD, residents lacking a qualifying immigration status get no rent discounts, yet they are nevertheless not entitled to occupy publicly funded housing.
HUD defends the rule; families describe the stakes
HUD Secretary Scott Turner defended the change in a statement posted online before the rule was finalized.
“President Trump warned that the days of illegal aliens and ineligible noncitizens exploiting government-funded welfare programs would be over,” HUD Secretary Scott Turner said in a statement posted online as the new rule was being finalized.
“It’s unacceptable that America’s homeless veterans, disabled, elderly, and victims of domestic violence languish on waitlists while illegals and ineligibles scam our system. American taxpayers will no longer foot the bill. Promises made, promises kept.”
In a separate statement to KABC, Turner said the rule fully implements federal law and “guarantees only American citizens and certain eligible noncitizens will reside in HUD-funded housing.”
For J.L., the stakes are concrete. She has lived in the same HACLA-run apartment for 15 years, sharing a three-bedroom unit with her two brothers, her mother and her stepfather. The family pays $2,700 a month for the apartment. The lawsuit states that she and her siblings hold U.S. citizenship; she said her parents are undocumented.
She has considered staying in public housing with her younger siblings, all of whom qualify for rental subsidies. But her parents rely on her for daily life — translating at doctors’ appointments, buying groceries. The family has been afraid to leave the house amid a reported ramp-up of ICE activity in the state. J.L. works as a pharmacy technician.
KABC’s coverage adds community reaction from a news conference at Public Counsel’s Koreatown office. Los Angeles Councilmember Eunisses Hernandez said the proposal would add pressure to families already facing economic pressures, noting that her district includes William Mead Homes, one of the city’s oldest public housing communities.
A public housing resident named Natividad, a co-founder of the tenants’ union Unión de Vecinos, described the proposal in Spanish as horrifying, inhumane and crushing, according to KABC.
Kathryn Eidmann, president and chief executive officer of Public Counsel, said that for 30 years, mixed-status families have lived together in public housing and Section 8 homes.
HUD’s own analysis expects families to leave
An impact analysis from HUD, referenced in the reporting, showed a yearslong drop in the count of mixed-status families in public housing, and the agency suggested that some departed following the rule’s initial proposal in 2019. The agency expects the same pattern once the rule takes effect.
“[W]e expect that a fear of the family being separated would prompt the departure of most mixed families,” the agency’s analysis reads.
HUD also wrote that because mixed-status families generally pay more, the change would likely reduce the number of families receiving public housing assistance. “The primary effect would be to assist proportionally fewer households and household members, but with higher subsidies,” the analysis says.
Public Counsel attorneys said they worry the rule could deepen an existing affordable housing crisis. “You’re gonna have more demands for shelters and other services, and that’s going to impact not just the families that are displaced but everybody else who relies on those services,” said attorney Amanda Mangaser Savage.
Attorneys involved in the case told KABC the policy could force families to choose between homelessness and separation, and that more than a third of the tens of thousands of people expected to be affected live in California. “They’re trying to undo what Congress has in place for the last 30 years,” one attorney said.
The rule is scheduled to take effect mid-December. Until a court rules, families like J.L.’s face a decision the lawsuit is trying to prevent: split the household, or leave subsidized housing altogether.
Worth a look
- Bears’ Luther Burden Clears Concussion Protocol, Set to Face Saints; Kyler Gordon Day-to-Day
- Niue Ocean Wide Trust Wins Earthshot Prize; Endowment Arithmetic Unclear
- California Announces New Homekey+ Projects and Funding to Address Homelessness and Veteran Housing (newsdirectory3.com)
- What Trump's Housing Order Means for a $360,000 Loan at 7.32% (daybreakwire.com)