Recycled Set Sparks Controversy in Oviedo ‘Macbeth’; Juan Jesús Rodríguez Shines

A new production of Verdi’s Macbeth opened at the Teatro Campoamor on November 18, but the staging was immediately recognized as a 2019 set recycled for a fourth opera.

The production, a co-venture between Ópera de Oviedo and Teatro Cervantes de Málaga, credits director Paco López with set, lighting and stage direction, according to Codalario.

Codalario reported that the scenery is the mirror-image Campoamor interior created by set designer Ramón Ivars for director Guy Joosten’s 2019 double bill of Pagliacci and Eine florentinische Tragödie. López repainted it gray, damaged the surfaces and cut holes in the ceiling for ropes used by three acrobats portraying the witches.

“It is not acceptable that a creative profession takes advantage of the ideas of others and does not even give them the credit they deserve,” wrote critic Nuria Blanco Álvarez.

She added that neither Ópera de Oviedo nor Teatro Cervantes de Málaga should label the work a “new production” when it reuses a mutilated house set. The same scenery appeared in a 2021 La flauta mágica directed by Albert Estany, who also claimed authorship of the “scenographic concept.”

Baritone Shines Amidst Production Scrutiny

Baritone Juan Jesús Rodríguez earned the evening’s highest praise. “He is one of the best Spanish singers of the moment and it is a privilege to hear him in Oviedo, given how little they let him perform on the stages of our country,” Blanco Álvarez wrote. His Macbeth was described as dramatically intense and vocally commanding.

Soprano Marigona Qerkezi struggled early as Lady Macbeth. Her “La luce langue” showed “a singing line that was not very attractive and a timbre that was not very homogeneous,” the review said. She recovered in the Act Four sleepwalking scene, delivering a “magnificent” “Una macchia è qui tuttora.”

Bass Gianfranco Montresor offered a “resolute and well-timbred” Banquo. Tenor Alejandro del Cerro and baritone Jorge Rodríguez-Norton were solid as Macduff and Malcolm. Bass Mikel Zabala and soprano Julia Merino, as the Doctor and Lady-in-Waiting, rounded out the principals.

Chorus Outshines Conductor’s Tempo

The Coro Intermezzo opened with some pitch issues but grew into the night’s most dynamic scenic presence. Their “Patria oppressa” drew a direct line to “Va, pensiero” from Nabucco (1842), though conductor Clelia Cafiero “linger[ed] excessively at the end of the piece.” Her Oviedo Filarmonía reading was generally clean, if rough in the first act.

Aerialists Provide Sole Movement on Dull Set

Designer Jesús Ruiz dressed the cast in an original, atemporal style broken only by SWAT-uniformed police carrying rifles. The three aerialists — suspended on ropes and silks — provided the only kinetic energy on a set that otherwise “remained immobile during the almost three hours of performance.”

Baritone Juan Jesús Rodríguez, who earned Best Male Verdian Voice at the Tutto Verdi International Awards (2023) and Best Male Voice from Ópera Siglo XXI (2024), has appeared on many of the world’s foremost stages including the Metropolitan Opera, Royal Opera House, Deutsche Oper Berlin, Teatro Real and the Liceu.

Critic Nuria Blanco Álvarez described him as one of Spain’s best singers yet noted the privilege of hearing him in Oviedo given how little he performs on Spanish stages, even as his signature Verdi roles such as Macbeth, Rigoletto and Nabucco anchor major houses abroad.

Ópera de Oviedo continues to list the original 2019 Pagliacci/Eine florentinische Tragödie production for rental on its website, though the set has now been altered for Macbeth. López previously directed the company’s 2023 Goyescas/El retablo de Maese Pedro, which Blanco Álvarez called a “fiasco.”

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Georgia Maq Wins Nathan Fielder Lookalike Contest, Releases New Single