Federal military courts have stripped two former career soldiers of their pensions this year after they continued unauthorized side businesses despite direct orders to stop, marking a sharp escalation in disciplinary enforcement.
Broker’s Six-Figure Venture Leads to Forfeiture
The Federal Administrative Court ruled in June that a soldier who earned more than 140,000 euros in commissions as a financial-products broker forfeited his retirement pay entirely. The court found the venture amounted to a second career and that the soldier persisted after a formal prohibition and a disciplinary hearing, even while on sick leave.
DJ’s Medical Leave Operation Draws Maximum Penalty
In August, the same court revoked the pension of a servicewoman who performed as a DJ and built a professional operation while on medical leave, ignoring multiple orders to cease. “If a soldier continues a side activity to the extent of a second career during periods of unfitness for duty despite multiple orders, the maximum measure is to be imposed,” the court held.
Persistence, Not Just Permission, Defines Punishment
Both rulings turned on the scale and persistence of the work, not merely the lack of a permit. Section 20 of the Soldiers’ Act requires prior approval for any paid outside activity, with narrow exceptions for managing one’s own assets and certain writing, scientific, artistic or speaking engagements. Approval must be denied when service interests are at risk — including time overload, conflicts of interest, impaired impartiality or work that equates to a second job.
A verbal nod from a commander does not satisfy the statutory requirement.
“A superior who, in violation of statutory provisions, selfishly pursues an unapproved side activity shakes his personal and official integrity,” the court wrote in a January decision upholding a service offense for a soldier who earned 4,737.64 euros in referral commissions after repeated warnings.
The Federal Administrative Court in Leipzig serves as the court of last resort for administrative law disputes, including military discipline cases involving pension revocation for former career soldiers.
Unlike Sozialgerichte, which handle social security law with the Bundessozialgericht as the federal appeals court, or Finanzgerichte and the Bundesfinanzhof for tax and customs matters, the Federal Administrative Court holds exclusive final authority over administrative disputes such as the loss of retirement pay under military disciplinary law.
2025 Decisions Signal Tougher Scrutiny
Disciplinary penalties range from reprimands and fines to demotion and dismissal; for former career soldiers, the harshest sanction is loss of retirement pay. Christian Steffgen, a reserve lieutenant colonel and attorney specializing in military disciplinary law, said soldiers should verify whether a permit or at least a notification is required before starting any side work, and seek counsel early if investigations begin, according to Anwalt.