The 1914 Colonial Revival church at 2601 W. 34th Ave. stands vacant today, its future hanging in the balance after the Denver planning board voted last month to rezone the property from U-TU-B residential to U-MX-2X mixed-use.
The decision clears a path for potential offices, food service, or multifamily housing at the site, which formerly housed Iglesia Palabra de Vida.
GMASH LLC purchased the building in July for $630,000, a price point neighbors noted is a fraction of the $1 million-plus valuations currently seen for surrounding residential homes on smaller lots.
The move has sparked friction in the Potter Highlands neighborhood, where residents contend they were provided insufficient notice of the zoning shift. While the city’s Community Planning and Development office stated it adhered to notification requirements by alerting property owners within 200 feet, a spokesperson for the board said decisions are strictly based on whether requests meet basic technical requirements.
“I mean, it was hell,” said Bert McMurtry, who moved to the neighborhood in 1985. “But my God, this neighborhood had such potential that we built it together into something that’s quite remarkable.”
Developer Kevin O’Brien and RealArchitecture Ltd. have pitched the project as a “community gathering place,” presenting renderings of a restored sanctuary that preserves stained-glass windows while hosting musicians and a neighborhood bar. “We looked at multifamily,” O’Brien told the Denver Gazette. “This zoning would allow for multifamily. If we were doing multiple units right now based on the market, I don’t think that’s feasible at all.”
However, local opposition remains firm.
Amy Van Ostall, who hosted a community meeting last week, described the rezone as a “ticking time bomb” centered on developer profit. “We’re privatizing a public space,” Van Ostall said.
“If they believed they could come into this neighborhood they have no history with, change the zoning to the point of radically altering the character, all without any kind of real plan for this building, that is the height of naivety,” Amy Berglund, real estate agent, said.
Two construction experts who declined to be identified estimated that the cost of renovating the historic structure could exceed $3 million. One expert warned that successful historic repurposing requires deep neighbor cooperation, noting that a low purchase price does not guarantee a project will be financially viable.
Tim Boer, who chairs the land use committee for Highland United Neighbors Inc., said the group is pursuing restrictive covenants.
“What we’ve proposed is a document of restrictive covenants that would be recorded to limit it to beyond what the city allows to uses that would be less invasive,” Boer said.
The rezoning proposal now moves to the City Council. Meanwhile, O’Brien acknowledged that the vacant property has already been the target of four break-ins and three lock changes.