Hundreds of former rugby union and league players will wait until the end of the year to learn whether their concussion lawsuits survive, after a two-day hearing at the Royal Courts of Justice ended without a ruling on the first batch of 378 cases, The Telegraph reported.
The verdict, expected from Mr Justice Cotter and Senior Master Cook before December closes, will likely be appealed by whichever side loses, The Telegraph reported. That appeal threat means the defining legal fight over rugby’s handling of brain injuries will drag on, with the claimants’ own team pitching a trial date of October 2028 — a target the defendants have dismissed as “impossible”.
At stake is the union case inherited from Rylands Garth and now run by KP Law, representing claimants that include World Cup winners Steve Thompson and Phil Vickery. The immediate question before the judges was blunt: strike the first 378 cases out, or grant another extension after yet another missed deadline for disclosing medical documents.
“When does this stop?” said William Audland KC, representing the Rugby Football League. “There never does seem to be an end to this problem because of the mess they got themselves into in the first place. Millions of pounds have been spent and wasted, when does this stop? If this isn’t the occasion when the court says ‘no’, when will we ever get there?”
Striking Out Batch Would End Case
- A judgment striking out the batch would end the case, while a reprieve keeps the defending bodies — the RFU, World Rugby and the Rugby Football League — spending millions of pounds on legal costs.
- Litigation-funder economics are now part of the story: Asertis, which underwrote Rylands Garth’s work, owns KP Law — meaning the funder’s position, not just the players’, is on the docket.
Ninety-Nine Days Versus Three Years
The claimants’ case for patience came down to a ratio. Paul Downes KC, acting for the claimants — a group that also includes dozens of rugby league players — revealed that only 36 players in the union case had secured medical letters of diagnosis, The Telegraph reported. He argued that “more has been achieved in 99 days than in the previous three years” in supplying medical documentation, and asked for an extension through January.

But the tape tells a different story, say the defendants. Their lawyers argued there had been no material change in circumstance to legally justify a further extension “two years, two weeks and five days” since the claimants missed their first deadline — a figure that itself sketches how long this case has been slipping.
Audland went further, predicting the next deadline “will come and go and there will be some form of non-compliance.”
Downes laid the blame on the previous incumbent. Rylands Garth left the case in a “shambolic” state, he claimed per The Telegraph, and Richard Boardman — the solicitor removed from the record in August — declined to co-operate in transferring the medical files unless he was paid.
“Impenetrable Chaos” Meets a Sharp Question
KP Law’s defense was that it inherited the litigation “blind,” drowning in what it called the “impenetrable chaos” left by Rylands Garth. The defendants had an answer ready.
Nina Goolamali KC, representing World Rugby, showed the court that KP Law knew Leigh Day — acting as consultants on the case since February 2026 — had estimated four months of due diligence would be needed to understand the case’s complexities, The Telegraph reported. Leigh Day declined to take the case on. Instead it went to KP Law, which is owned by Asertis, the litigation funder that had already underwritten Rylands Garth’s work.
“This may be a situation where Asertis and KP Law having run out of options because they couldn’t get Leigh Day to come on board, decided, ‘Well, let’s have one last throw of the dice’ and bring on our ‘in-house’ team,” said Michael Kent KC, representing the Rugby Football Union. The defendants also branded KP Law’s target trial date of October 2028 “impossible.”
The Paper Trail Behind the Paper Trail
The mess runs deeper than procedure. The Telegraph Sport revealed last week that Boardman is being sued by his own barrister, who has accused him of improperly making payments to his wife — an allegation reported, not proven, and one Boardman has not answered in the material on record.
For Thompson, Vickery and the wider claimant group, the arithmetic is unforgiving. Thirty-six completed medical letters against a docket of 378 cases is roughly one diagnostic letter for every ten claims — and it is exactly the documentation gap that has repeatedly endangered the case.
| Milestone | Status | Source detail |
|---|---|---|
| Medical diagnosis letters secured | 36 of 378 union cases | Downes KC, per The Telegraph |
| Progress claim under KP Law | “99 days vs previous three years” | Downes KC, per The Telegraph |
| Leigh Day due-diligence estimate | Four months; declined the case | Goolamali KC, per The Telegraph |
| Leigh Day consultancy role | Since February 2026 | The Telegraph |
| KP Law target trial date | October 2028 — called “impossible” | Defendants, per The Telegraph |
What Judgment Day Can and Cannot Settle
A ruling before the year ends settles only scope — whether the first batch of 378 cases lives or dies. It does not touch liability for the underlying claim that professional rugby’s concussion protocols damaged these players’ brains. The judges can strike the cases out, extend again into January, or split the difference; the sources give no steer on which way Cotter and Cook lean.
The hearing itself produced no winner on the day, only the promise of one by December.
World Rugby, one of the three defending bodies, is the global governing body of rugby union, based in Dublin and counting 133 national unions among its members. It was founded in 1886 as the International Rugby Football Board, born of a dispute over a try between Scotland and England — with England refusing to join until 1890 — and adopted its current name in 2014 after two decades as the International Rugby Board.
The organisation stages the Rugby World Cup every four years, the sport’s most profitable competition. Its history is also entangled with the split at the heart of this case: the 1893 “Great Schism” over payments to players in northern England led 22 clubs to break away and form the code that became rugby league.
Ahead of that verdict, the practical reality for the players is unchanged: more waiting, and for most of the 378, still no medical letter filed. The verdict is expected this year — and, per The Telegraph, the losing side is likely to appeal it.