Sandpapergate’s ‘War of the Ghosts’ Highlights Perils of Relying on Recall

Almost eight years after Cape Town, the 2018 ball-tampering scandal has re-erupted in Australian cricket, and a professor of memory argues that Pat Cummins and Usman Khawaja can both be telling the truth as they see it.

The trigger was Cameron Bancroft’s newspaper column, published on Wednesday, in which he said the entire Australia Test team knew about the sandpaper used on the 2018 tour of South Africa. Pat Cummins’ management responded that nothing in the statement had not already been answered in Cummins’ press conference, where the captain denied any knowledge. The Guardian’s Spin column then took the row to an unlikely place: cognitive science.

Writing there, Professor John Sutton — Leverhulme International Professor and director of the Centre for the Sciences of Place and Memory at the University of Stirling, who spent most of his career at Macquarie University in Sydney — pushed back against the binary framing. The prevailing view among commentators and fans is that one of the two men must be lying about what happened in South Africa in 2018.

“I just strongly disagree with that,” Sutton told the Guardian. “I think eight years is actually a hell of a long time, but even at the time people were experiencing different things. The emotional significance of what they were facing was different. It’s perfectly possible that there’s nobody involved here who’s not telling the truth as they see it.”

The spin sandpapergates war of the ghosts highlights perils of relying on recall
Photo: onfieldnews.com

So neither man may be lying? “Absolutely,” he replied. A beat later: “But it’s absolutely possible that one of them is. Or that both of them are.” That is the uncomfortable arithmetic this saga now runs on.

Bartlett's 1932 cricket metaphor explains memory reconstruction

The intellectual spine of the argument comes from the English psychologist Frederic Bartlett, who in 1932 used cricket as a metaphor for memory in his landmark book Remembering: A Study in Experimental and Social Psychology. “When I make the stroke I do not, as a matter of fact, produce something absolutely new and I never merely repeat something old,” Bartlett wrote.

Sandpapergate's 'War of the Ghosts' Highlights Perils of Relying on Recall
Photo: aol.co.uk

His point: no two cover drives are identical. Each is manufactured afresh — the “schemata of the moment and their interrelations”. “When we remember something, we are always manufacturing a version of the past,” Sutton said. “You’re retouching, you’re retelling, you’re reconstructing a version of past events.”

Sutton distinguishes between the time of encoding — what happened then — and the time of retrieval — what is happening now. Even a player who kept a diary, he argued, is still retrieving a narrative, and it never comes out in a block with the sequence perfectly laid out.

He speaks with some authority on the days themselves. Sutton was in Cape Town watching the infamous Newlands Test with his father and friends, and remembers feeling “something was off” in the body language of the Australian players during South Africa’s second innings, long before the images of Bancroft stuffing sandpaper down his trousers hit the big screens.

Cricket’s civil war continues as Cummins denies ‘Sandpapergate’ claims — 9 News Australia

But the tape tells a different story on his certainty, too. Asked whether his group might have retrofitted that memory, Sutton conceded the point: “We are confident we felt that way and discussed it well before the images were shown … but, well, you start to see how tricky this stuff is.”

Dressing room divided, on the record

The public record now features a splintering between batters and bowlers from that Cape Town dressing room, each side backed by former teammates and coaches. This week added two names to the list of on-record witnesses, per the Guardian’s round-up of the saga.

Graeme Hick, at the time an assistant coach, publicly declared that Khawaja’s claim — that the entire dressing room was in on the plot — was “absolutely false”.

Reserve fast bowler Chadd Sayers told Australian radio station SEN the opposite: “Everyone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used. [Sandpaper] was used in two Test matches and there were discussions in the changing rooms.” Sayers added that after the Cape Town Test the whole team spent 60–90 minutes in the changing rooms discussing what had happened.

The spin sandpapergates war of the ghosts highlights perils
Photo: khanlist.com

Sutton’s explanation for the split is collaborative memory. Witnesses to a crime are kept apart before court precisely because shared recollection can condense into a fixed narrative that encodes errors — yet such collaboration can also test emotions against those who experienced events differently. With highly dramatic, emotional events, he said, “memory can get trapped and fixated”.

Witness Role in 2018 Position on team knowledge Where stated
Cameron Bancroft Opener, caught on field Entire Test team knew Newspaper column, Wednesday
Graeme Hick Then-assistant coach Khawaja’s claim “absolutely false” On record, this week
Chadd Sayers Reserve fast bowler Everyone knew; sandpaper used in two Tests SEN radio
Pat Cummins Player in 2018, now captain Denies any knowledge Press conference, via his management
Usman Khawaja Player in 2018 Entire dressing room was in on the plot As characterised by Hick

Dressing room rift saddens fans as BCCI eyes IPL expansion

  • Dressing-room stability: the public disagreement between current Test players Pat Cummins and Usman Khawaja has produced a pervasive sense of sadness among fans as their relationship is torn apart by the saga.
  • Broadcast and expansion backdrop: the BCCI is exploring an IPL expansion from 74 matches toward 94 in future editions, a reminder that cricket’s commercial growth continues regardless of the scandal cycle.

Vic Marks discovers his cricket memories were false

Here is what the analytics of memory missed — until Vic Marks checked. The former Somerset and England player, and former Guardian and Observer cricket correspondent, told the Guardian’s Spin column how his own recall failed him. At Southport in 1977, facing the West Indies fast bowler Colin Croft, “Croft scared the life out of most of us.”

For decades, Marks wrote in his book Original Spin, he recalled being part of a Croft hat-trick — in fact he was out first ball to him in the second innings. Worse, he remembered Graham Burgess consoling Mervyn Kitchen in the dressing room before he batted. “I’m looking at the scorecard now. Burgess wasn’t playing in that game,” Vic said.

One abiding detail, Marks notes, is completely true: Kitchen solemnly removed his false teeth and placed them in his blazer pocket before walking out to face the chin music. Once witnessed, never forgotten.

The verdict nobody can deliver

Sutton’s conclusion — no cheating allegation is settled by who remembers what. Bartlett titled his 1932 folktale experiment War of the Ghosts, tracing how a story changed with each retelling; the Spin column notes it makes a better title than Sandpapergate. Eight years on, Australians are watching relationships — notably between Cummins and Khawaja — torn apart by a dispute over recall itself.

Photo of author

Sport Desk

Sport Desk at Archyde.

Attack on Titan: The Musical Announces Bangkok 2027 Run, Tickets On Sale Now