Schumer Faces First Contested Senate Democratic Leadership Race in Decades Against Van Hollen

Twenty-eight votes. That is all Chuck Schumer needs on Dec. 1 to survive the first contested election for Senate Democratic leader in more than three decades — and by Wednesday, the incumbent claimed he already had them.

Sen. Chris Van Hollen of Maryland is challenging Schumer, who has led Senate Democrats since 2017 and just helped the party recapture the Senate in the midterms, The Washington Post reported. Only senators returning next year can vote, and with Sen. Amy Klobuchar (Minnesota) heading to the governor’s office, just 55 of the incoming 56-member majority will cast ballots.

“I’m confident I’ll be the next leader,” Schumer said Tuesday. “I have the votes. And we’re all going to roll up our sleeves and we are going to focus on lowering costs, ending corruption.”

Van Hollen, who acknowledged to The Associated Press that he is the underdog, says he has about 15 Democratic supporters, including some backing him privately.

The Hill reported that Schumer’s allies predict more than 40 votes and have floated moving the election up — a move one former Senate Democratic chief of staff read as panic: “What he’s telling is that he has the votes … but what he’s showing by trying to change caucus rules is panic.”

The math behind 28

Thirteen Democrats publicly back Schumer, according to The Post’s tally, most of them senators with more than a decade in the chamber. Among the newly elected class of 13, only Sherrod Brown of Ohio — returning to the Senate after losing his seat in 2024 — has endorsed him.

The arguments cluster around one number: the midterm result. Sen. Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada wrote on X that Schumer was “instrumental in Democrats flipping 8 — soon to be 9 — Senate seats.” Sen. Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin put it in baseball terms: “The Brewers just had a record season, and next year is not the time to change our management.”

Jeff Merkley (Oregon) and Peter Welch (Vermont) sit alongside two senators-elect: Abdul El-Sayed and Peggy Flanagan of Minnesota. Sanders framed the race in The Guardian as “a debate about the future of the Democratic party” — top-down and billionaire-funded, he wrote, or “a grassroots party of, by and for the working families of our country.”

Outside groups have picked a side, too. NationofChange reported that Indivisible, one of the forces behind the “No Kings” protests, endorsed Van Hollen after what it called a nearly unanimous vote of local group leaders, and National Nurses United — more than 225,000 registered nurses — followed suit.

Van Hollen rules out the White House

Van Hollen told The Associated Press on Friday that he is no longer weighing a presidential run and will focus entirely on the leadership race. At Denver’s “What’s Next” conference, he argued Democrats should “go toe to toe” with President Donald Trump — and made clear the midterm wins were a beginning, not a verdict.

“While they fired the Trump policies, they have not fully hired us,” he said. Schumer, for his part, has been working senators one-on-one on a 2027 agenda covering health care, tariff legislation and efforts to stop the Iran war, the AP reported.

National Opinion: It’s time for Schumer to step aside
Photo: Chattanooga Times Free Press

The undecided middle

A third bloc refuses Schumer without committing to Van Hollen: Sens.-elect Juliana Stratton (Illinois), Troy Jackson (Maine) and Adam Hamilton (Kansas), plus Sen. Elissa Slotkin of Michigan. “I am seeking change,” Slotkin said. “I’ve been very consistent for a very long time that we need a new generation of leadership.”

Then there are the genuinely uncommitted — a list that cuts across the caucus’s whole history. Ron Wyden and Patty Murray have served alongside Schumer since he first won his Senate seat in 1998; Elizabeth Warren and Chris Coons remain publicly silent as well. Some may never reveal their votes at all, because the ballot is secret.

Sen.-elect Josh Turek of Iowa met both candidates and wants more. “I want to know, specifically, what is their plan on two areas: on water, on cancer rates, on farming, on rural communities, health care,” he told reporters, adding he also wants to know “who is going to put forward the most robust anti-corruption agenda?”

Where the outlets disagree

The picture differs depending on who is counting. The Hill’s sources call the race a “distraction” and project 40-plus votes for Schumer; Van Hollen’s allies counter that the push to reschedule the vote signals softness in that count.

The AP described Schumer as the favorite. Van Hollen told Fox News Sunday the contest is “a wide open race.” Both cannot be fully true — and the secret ballot means the public tally may not match the private one.

One more wrinkle: Van Hollen’s own home-state colleague, Sen. Angela Alsobrooks of Maryland, is sticking with Schumer. “Chris is a friend,” she told reporters Wednesday. “He had every right to run. … I am a person of my word.”

Dec. 1 decides it

The caucus votes by secret ballot on Dec. 1, with Republicans holding the chamber until January. Twenty-eight is the floor; the ceiling is whatever the whisper counts say.

As Sen. John Hickenlooper of Colorado put it: “The Democrats are the only party in the country, in the world, where you can flip double the number of seats anybody, even the biggest optimist, thought was possible — and then there’s a revolt [against] the person who helped lead that.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Rosemary Behan: Father Brian Behan Abused Mother Sally Hill for Decades

National Reconstruction Fund Tips Another $10M Into Quantum Brilliance