Springsteen’s Endorsement of El-Sayed Causes Fan Club to Fold

“The breaking point,” Spring-Nuts co-founder Howie Chaz told the Asbury Park Press earlier this month, “was Springsteen’s endorsement of El-Sayed in the Michigan Senate race.”

The quote comes from the man who built Spring-Nuts, a Bruce Springsteen fan club that shut down on Nov. 8 after the 77-year-old rocker backed Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed, the first Muslim elected to the U.S. Senate. Nearly 20,000 members lost their digital home in a single farewell post.

The Los Angeles Times identifies the couple behind the club as Howard and Julie Chazanoff — observant Jews who launched the group in 2011 and long enforced a no-politics policy to encourage “peaceful interactions” among members. Their goodbye statement ran past 4,600 words. The policy, they wrote, did not survive the Nov. 2 endorsement.

Why did a Facebook group fold over an endorsement? Because the man at the center of it had spent the year making politics impossible to avoid.

Springsteen has ramped up his political talk on tour and television, and his 20-date Land of Hope and Dreams tour carried a “No Kings” slogan taking a stance against President Trump, according to the Asbury Park Press. El-Sayed’s critics largely object to his associations with individuals who have open disdain for America and Jews, concerns the Chazanoffs themselves raised in their statement.

Springsteen's Endorsement of El-Sayed Causes Fan Club to Fold
Photo: hastingstribune.com

Why the Nuts folded

  • Spring-Nuts, a charity-raising fan club founded in 2011, announced its shutdown on Nov. 8 after years of political infighting among members.
  • The trigger, per the founders, was Springsteen’s Nov. 2 endorsement of El-Sayed, a Democrat, in the Michigan Senate race.
  • The Chazanoffs, who are Jewish, said they could not reconcile the endorsement with their own convictions; Springsteen’s representatives have not commented.

The no-drama rule broke

Spring-Nuts! I thank you for gathering here at the Pony for this momentous occasion in support of WhyHunger,” he said at the time.

That harmony is what the Chazanoffs say they lost. “What should have been respectful differences of opinion too often deteriorated into personal attacks, bullying, insults, and some genuinely vile and hateful rhetoric,” the couple wrote in their farewell statement, which the New York Post reprinted in part. The Los Angeles Times adds that divisions among the membership had become unmanageable, and that the latest political statement hit a nerve.

Springsteen endorses El-Sayed and divides fans

Springsteen’s endorsement is not subtle. “Dr. El-Sayed is a fighter for our American Constitution, he’s a fighter for our American Democracy, and he’s a fighter against the corrupt, lawless, and anti-American leadership currently in the White House. That’s why I’m in his corner 100%,” Springsteen wrote.

Bruce Springsteen Fan Club SHUTS DOWN After El-Sayed Endorsement Sparks Political WAR — The News Talk

For the Chazanoffs, the statement landed on something deeper than fandom. “Most disturbing to us was Bruce’s recent endorsement of Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed, who has strong relationships with people who have open disdain for America and Jews. El-Sayed refused to retract some of his own statements which we believe to be antisemitic and anti-American,” they wrote, per the Los Angeles Times.

Fans pick sides

The reaction inside the fandom was immediate and split. Did you never listen to his lyrics,” Stefanko wrote on Nov. 9. “I question any Spring-nut member who appreciates Bruce Springsteen and then criticizes his right to practice being an American.”

Springsteen's Endorsement of El-Sayed Causes Fan Club to Fold
Photo: yahoo.com

The Chazanoffs, for their part, wrote that they do not hold Springsteen responsible for some of the behavior they witnessed within the group.

Seventy thousand strong, until now

Here is the kicker: the Facebook group was only part of the operation. A fan club that had been active for more than a decade folded over a single endorsement.

The Spring-Nuts, by the numbers Figure
Year founded 2011
Facebook membership Nearly 20,000
Community across all platforms More than 70,000
Founders’ farewell statement More than 4,600 words

The club even had access at the top of the E Street organization. Nine months earlier, none of this was in question.

Springsteen remains silent following album release

Springsteen’s political year is well documented. The same Los Angeles Times report notes his album “Streets of Minneapolis” arrived on Jan. 28. What is not documented: any comment from Springsteen himself.

And the group’s page? Which leaves one voice to close on — a man who stood on that E Street stage his whole life, telling the fans exactly what they were worth. “Without your guys enthusiasm, you know, what are we doing, right? So, you guys matter just as much… for your enthusiasm and your supporting us.”

Photo of author

Entertainment Desk

Entertainment Desk at Archyde.

Archie McParland Gets First England Cap Against Japan in Nations Championship

Microsoft, FAA, JPMorgan Chase, United Airlines Hit by Separate Tech Outages