Median sand grain sizes on Earth and Mars reveal the speed of the winds that formed ancient and modern dunes, according to a study published November 16 in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Researchers at Stanford University discovered that windblown dunes across planetary bodies are constructed primarily by winds operating just fast enough to move sediment along the ground. This consistent relationship turns sand deposits into speedometers for tracking atmospheric conditions throughout the solar system.
Calculating Wind Speeds
Scientists previously used dune shapes to determine wind direction, but estimating velocity remained difficult. The team tested a 2010 hypothesis from University of Pennsylvania researchers suggesting that dunes form from winds slightly exceeding the threshold required for particle movement.
The study analyzed three decades of wind data alongside grain-size measurements gathered from 24 diverse dune fields worldwide. These sites ranged from the dunes of Namibia’s Namib Sand Sea to Utah’s Coral Pink Sand Dunes State Park.
Calculations showed that the winds responsible for moving the most sand over time correlated closely with median grain size and only modestly surpassed the initial transport threshold.
Dunes are a “great recorder of what happens on a planet’s surface, and particularly the interactions between what’s happening in the atmosphere of a planet and what’s happening on the surface.”
Colin Marvin, lead author
Marvin conducted the work as a PhD student in the lab of Mathieu Lapôtre, associate professor of Earth and planetary sciences at the Stanford Doerr School of Sustainability. Marvin is a postdoctoral scholar at Brown University.
Planetary Comparisons
Researchers applied the analytical model using data from a dune field on Mars. Despite contrasts in gravitational pull, atmospheric pressure, and sediment density between Mars and Earth, the identical grain-size correlation appeared.
This parallel suggests that windblown dunes develop identically across planetary bodies featuring loose sediment and wind speeds that decrease in frequency as velocity rises. It indicates that ancient dunes formed under matching physical constraints during Earth’s deep past.
The discovery will enable scientists to “better reconstruct winds and climates through time, on Earth and beyond,” said Lapôtre. “It works for modern dunes and for sandstones dating back three billion years.”
Mathieu Lapôtre, Stanford University
Funding for the project was provided by a National Science Foundation CAREER grant.