Stephen Amell’s Critically Acclaimed Wrestling Series ‘Heels’ Exits Netflix on September 15, 2026
Both seasons of the Starz-originated wrestling drama Heels, starring Stephen Amell and Alexander Ludwig, will officially leave Netflix on September 15, 2026, giving subscribers a narrow window to stream the 94% Rotten Tomatoes-rated series before its removal.
The Bottom Line
- Removal Date: Both seasons of Heels exit Netflix on September 15, 2026.
- Critical Standing: The series holds a strong 94% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes.
- Future Prospects: Despite fan campaigns like #HeelsSeason3, a revival remains unlikely following its 2023 cancellation.
The Ring Dynamics Behind Michael Waldron’s Creation
Created by Michael Waldron, Heels explores the gritty, high-stakes world of independent professional wrestling in Georgia. The narrative centers on two estranged brothers who serve as bitter rivals inside the squared circle. Stephen Amell anchors the series as Jack Spade, the villainous “heel” holding the promotion together, while Alexander Ludwig plays his younger brother, Ace Spade, the heroic “face.”
The ensemble cast features Alison Luff, Mary McCormack, Kelli Berglund, Allen Maldonado, James Harrison, Roxton Garcia, Chris Bauer, Mike O’Malley, and David James Elliott. Despite drawing critical acclaim for its sharp writing and athletic performances, the show faced hurdles when Starz canceled it in September 2023 after airing two seasons.
Streaming Shuffles and the Quest for a Third Season
When the series migrated to Netflix in 2024, it introduced the gritty family drama to a much larger audience and briefly reignited fan optimism. Stephen Amell actively leaned into the momentum, encouraging viewers online to rally behind the project. “If there is a hashtag that gets us, we want it to be #HeelsSeason3,” Amell noted during an interview following the platform shift. He further suggested logical progression steps for the IP, remarking, “And look, okay, no one took my advice by the way. It says Season 1 and Season 2 right there on Netflix. So the logical step forward would be changing it from a Starz original to a Netflix original or Netflix series.”
Here is the kicker: that transition never materialized. With Netflix now clearing the title from its library next month, the window for any streaming savior to step in and fund a continuation is rapidly closing.
| Metric / Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Original Network | Starz |
| Creator | Michael Waldron |
| Lead Cast | Stephen Amell, Alexander Ludwig |
| Rotten Tomatoes Score | 94% Critic Rating |
| Netflix Exit Date | September 15, 2026 |
What the Removal Means for Fans and the Streaming Landscape
When Starz initially removed the series from its own app in late 2023, physical and digital purchases through platforms like Apple TV, Prime Video, and YouTube remained the primary refuge for fans.
For now, viewers looking to experience the heartbreaking season two cliffhanger—where Jack Spade faces off against Ace before suffering a severe in-ring injury—must finish their rewatch before mid-September. Whether the property will ever find a permanent digital home or spark a late-stage revival remains to be seen, but the clock is officially ticking down on Netflix.
What are your thoughts on the sudden departure of Heels from Netflix? Did you hope to see a third season materialize, or are you rushing to finish the final episodes before September 15? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below!
