TVNZ Sport presenter Scotty Stevenson argues Cricket Australia has again chosen expediency over accountability by rejecting a fresh investigation into the 2018 Cape Town ball‑tampering scandal, opting instead for a voluntary, non‑public forum that the board will control.
Stevenson writes that CEO Todd Greenberg and interim chair David Boon fronted media in Hobart on Wednesday to announce the forum, which allows players and staff from the South Africa tour to “share their experiences and perspectives” without compulsion and with no guarantee the findings will be released, 1News reported.
The move came hours after Cameron Bancroft published a 4,000‑word account in The West Australian alleging the entire touring party — bowlers, coaches and support staff — knew sandpaper was being used to alter the ball.
Pat Cummins' camp say his position "hasn't changed" after Cameron Bancroft's fresh Sandpapergate revelations 🤨 pic.twitter.com/lVXXymlolB
“Someone’s version of events will contradict someone else’s version of events so looking for the perfect truth… doesn’t exist, and we’re not chasing that,” Greenberg said, a formulation Stevenson likens to a philosophical evasion of the basic forensic duty an integrity unit owes the sport.
The original 2018 probe, led by then integrity head Iain Roy and team performance boss Pat Howard, concluded in four days that only Steve Smith, David Warner and Bancroft were culpable; Usman Khawaja has since written in his autobiography Sabr that he was never interviewed.
Betting Markets React to Cummins Captaincy Pressure
- Pat Cummins captaincy futures: betting markets have shortened odds on a pre‑Ashes leadership change after a Code Sports poll showed 72 % of 10,000+ respondents believe he should step down.
- Australia XI stability: continued distraction ahead of the 9 December first Test against New Zealand in Perth – Bancroft’s home ground – could force selectors to consider a vice-captaincy shuffle or rest senior bowlers.
The Guardian’s correspondent noted Cummins faced a media scrum outside his Sydney home on Thursday, declining to address Bancroft’s claims while his manager, Neil Maxwell, reiterated: “Pat’s position hasn’t changed in eight years. He’s been consistent and adamant from day one.”
Cummins had earlier denied any knowledge of ball‑tampering during a 68‑minute press conference last Friday, calling Khawaja’s assertions “complete and utter nonsense” and questioning his former teammate’s character.
“The day of reckoning was always going to come” If Cummins is tossing the coin at Trent Bridge at the start of the Ashes on 18th June, then he is extraordinarily resilient” Jonathan Agnew @BBCSport column on #sandpapergate. #bbccricket https://t.co/3OVjEiHs7V
Former captain Michael Clarke told his Beyond 23 podcast: “There is the truth. I call bullshit. I don’t think there’s two sides to the story.”
Mitchell Johnson, writing in The West Australian, backed Bancroft’s account and predicted public pressure would force Cummins to resign before the Ashes. “I believe Bancroft’s account… he came across as himself, and he has nothing to lose now,” Johnson wrote, per the NZ Herald.
“If Cummins is tossing the coin at Trent Bridge on 18 June, then he is extraordinarily resilient. Right now, I can’t imagine that happening.”
BBC analysis highlights the Perth Test as a flashpoint: the match is staged at Optus Stadium, Bancroft’s home venue, in the state where his testimony was published.
Agnew writes the build‑up “will be anything other than a circus, dominated by questions about sandpaper, who knew what and who said what to whom.” A resignation without admission, Agnew adds, might also shield fellow bowlers Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon, who signed a joint 2021 statement denying knowledge.

Cricket Australia’s forum, Greenberg insisted, is not a re‑investigation and carries no sanctioning power. “We recognise the pain and the hurt… the game is genuinely hurting at the moment,” he told RNZ.
Yet the SMH’s column on Kate Hutchison — the lone team media manager who objected to the sandpaper plan in a 2018 team meeting — shows the cultural rot the original probe failed to excavate. “Men still tend to get the fun and the glory, and women still get the mop,” the SMH wrote, framing the scandal as a failure of male leadership to self‑police.
Cricket Australia traces its origins to the Australian Board of Control for International Cricket, formed in 1905 after Sydney talks to wrest tour control from private promoters and players.
The board held its first meeting at Wesley College in Melbourne on 6 May 1905; South Australia initially refused to join because players lacked representation. The current company was incorporated in 1982 with members’ liability limited by guarantee and now governs six state associations through nine independent directors.
| Protagonist | Position on 2018 Knowledge | Current Stance |
|---|---|---|
| Pat Cummins (Captain) | Denies any awareness | Maintains 2021 bowlers’ statement; manager says “position hasn’t changed in eight years” |
| Cameron Bancroft | Claims whole team knew | Published 4,000‑word account; says he feels “very free” after telling truth |
| Usman Khawaja | Alleges open squad discussions | Stands by autobiography Sabr; backed by David Warner |
| David Warner | Admits vice‑captaincy role | Supports Bancroft: “That’s his truth, so I respect that” |
| Cricket Australia (Greenberg/Boon) | Original 2018 finding: three perpetrators only | Voluntary forum, no guaranteed public report, “not chasing perfect truth” |
Stevenson concludes that eight years of “silences, denials and some versions of events” have left the game no closer to resolution.
Veteran journalist Peter Lalor told ABC News Breakfast: “It’s almost like we’re back in 2018. This was buried in a shallow grave and eight years later we’re starting to find out the truth, and it’s a lot worse than we thought.” The first Test against New Zealand begins 9 December in Perth.
The article by Bancroft on @cricinfo reveals what many of us have insisted post Khwaja's book release: @patcummins30 has been lying repeatedly. He is NOT a leader! After throwing teammates under the bus twice before, he did it again in the press conference a few days back. Not…