Men have not always been bad at friendship, according to historian Tiffany Watt Smith, who points out that deep, romantic, and involved bonds between men were once the societal standard.
The cultural debate surrounding male loneliness frequently contrasts atomized, isolated men against the backdrop of modern social disconnection. Yet historians note that the gender roles driving these assumptions are far more fluid than current perceptions suggest.
“I can definitely tell you that men in the past had much more intimate and romantic and involved friendships than we see today, for sure,” said Tiffany Watt Smith, a historian who has published books on the histories of friendship and emotions, in an interview with vox.com.
For millennia, classical and historical texts elevated male companionship above other social bonds.
Ancient Philosophy Viewed Male Friendship as a Soulful Bond
Ancient Greek philosophy placed the ideal friendship squarely between two men.
“He calls it the perfect friendship,” Smith told vox.com, describing Aristotle’s view of two men as soulmates capable of enduring, meaningful bonds.
Centuries later, 16th-century essayist Michel de Montaigne echoed this perspective following the death of his close companion, La Boétie. Montaigne outlined an ideal meeting of souls in his famous essay “On Friendship,” arguing that such profound emotional commitments required a strength of spirit he believed was exclusive to men.
Historians characterize these historical bonds as romantic friendships.
The 19th-Century Shift in Gender Roles
The framework surrounding emotional expression shifted dramatically during the 18th and 19th centuries as urbanization and industrialization transformed society. Public life and rational enterprise became associated with the male sphere, while the home and emotional intimacy increasingly defined the female sphere.
Middle-class ideals redefined female friendships as deeply expressive training grounds for marriage and motherhood. Simultaneously, cultural depictions of male bonding began to emphasize superficiality and a lack of emotional vulnerability.
By the early 20th century, growing visibility surrounding gay culture and changing societal understandings of homosexuality across Europe and America introduced new anxieties.
Redefining Modern Connections
History demonstrates that social norms governing interpersonal relationships are malleable rather than biologically fixed. Smith emphasized that current assumptions regarding male sociability do not reflect immutable human traits.
“The history of male friendships shows us that that is completely not true. So we can be released from that idea,” Smith told vox.com.
Rather than seeking an unattainable, rigid standard, contemporary social dynamics require individuals to negotiate the boundaries of connection on a case-by-case basis.
“Friendship is something that we have to negotiate on an individual basis. Each friendship is completely singular and we have to work out its rules,” Smith told vox.com.