The midterm election results have handed Democrats a 56-seat Senate majority that takes power on Jan. 3, effectively freezing President Trump’s judicial agenda and reopening the fight over the Supreme Court’s ideological balance.
El País reported that the new Senate can block every Trump nomination, creating a window for Democrats to reshape the court if they retain the White House in 2028.
The stakes are immediate. Justices Samuel Alito, 76, and Clarence Thomas, 78, face intensifying pressure to step down while a Democratic Senate could confirm their replacements. Alito has told associates he will not retire to allow a rushed confirmation, The New York Times reported.
Thomas, the court’s longest-serving member since his 1991 appointment by George H.W. Bush, is viewed by court watchers as motivated to become the longest-serving justice in history, a milestone he would reach in roughly 18 months.
Democrats haunted by Ginsburg death and Breyer retirement
Democrats are haunted by 2020. Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg declined to retire despite health struggles, died weeks before the election, and was replaced by Amy Coney Barrett in a sprint confirmation that shattered norms. The memory of that loss — and the successful 2022 persuasion of Justice Stephen Breyer to retire at 84, clearing the path for Ketanji Brown Jackson — drives the current urgency.
“The pressures on Breyer were far more acute than what Alito faces now,” said Paul Collins, a professor at the University of Massachusetts Amherst who studies court politicization. “Then, the goal was simply preserving three liberal seats. Now the calculus is different.”
A 6-3 supermajority built for durability
The court’s conservative supermajority — the strongest since the 1930s — rests on three Trump appointees: Neil Gorsuch, 59; Brett Kavanaugh, 61; and Barrett, 54, according to Elpais. Chief Justice John Roberts, 71, rounds out the conservative wing alongside Alito and Thomas. That youth profile means the 6-3 split could endure for decades unless vacancies arise under a Democratic president and Senate.
Reform talk moves from fringe to floor
The new Senate majority revives structural reform proposals that have circulated since the Barrett confirmation: 18-year term limits, expanding the court to 13 justices, curbing the “shadow docket” of unsigned emergency orders, and imposing a binding ethics code. President Biden, Vice President Harris, and congressional leadership have all endorsed versions of this agenda.
“A Republican attempt to replace Alito or Thomas at warp speed would be institutionally catastrophic,” wrote Supreme Court analyst Steve Vladek in his newsletter the day after the midterms. “It would hand the judiciary to a president and a Senate the voters just rejected, with a velocity that would make the Barrett confirmation look deliberate.”
The McConnell rule cuts both ways
Vladek noted the symmetry: Republicans blocked Barack Obama’s nominee Merrick Garland for over a year in 2016, insisting “the people should decide.” A lame-duck confirmation now would expose the court as “partisan politics by other means,” he argued, further eroding public trust that Gallup measured at a historic low in September.
Two divergent futures after 2028
Collins maps two scenarios. If Democrats win the White House in 2028, “there will undoubtedly be an effort to confirm one or more liberal justices.” If Republicans prevail, “they will be forced to nominate moderate conservatives because the Senate will remain under Democratic control.” Either path requires cross-party cooperation that has vanished from the confirmation process.
El País, the Spanish daily founded in May 1976 — six months after Franco’s death and at the start of the democratic transition — first appeared on 4 May of that year with a print run of 116,600 copies. It was the first pro-democracy newspaper in a market still dominated by Franco-era titles, a role cemented when it published a special pro-Constitution edition during the 23 February 1981 coup attempt while state television remained silent.
The Senate convenes Jan. 3. The court’s next term begins weeks later. The only certainty is that the battle for the court’s soul, dormant since Barrett’s confirmation, has rejoined the daily order of business.