The Padres locked in Gavin Sheets on a three-year, $11 million contract Friday, avoiding arbitration with a structure that pays $2.5 million in 2027 and attaches $4 million player options for 2028 and 2029, MLB reported.
The deal replaces a projected $6.5 million arbitration salary for 2027 with a lower guarantee while handing Sheets two opt-outs — a rare compromise that protects both sides if the 30-year-old rebounds from a .212/.313/.397 season marred by a plantar plate tear. San Diego acquired him on a minor-league deal after Chicago non-tendered him following 2024; he responded with 19 homers and a .746 OPS in 2025 before the foot injury sapped his second-half production.
“Ho-ly Sheets” chants echoed through Petco Park after his pinch-hit, two-run homer clinched the Wild Card Series sweep of the Cubs, a moment that crystallized his value as a left-handed power bat against right-handers. Sheets has slashed .237/.326/.445 with a 118 wRC+ in 740 plate appearances versus righties since joining the Friars, MLB Trade Rumors noted, while posting a .228/.281/.320 line against southpaws.
Gavin Sheets and Padres have a deal: $11M, 3 years @ByRobertMurray 1st
Sheets Adds Power Versus Right-Handers and Luxury-Tax Flexibility
- Sheets profiles as a platoon DH/1B with power versus right-handers; his ADP should rise in deeper mixed leagues where daily lineup management is allowed.
- The $2.5 million 2027 salary creates $4 million in immediate luxury-tax relief versus the arbitration projection, giving A.J. Preller flexibility to pursue Tarik Skubal or other rotation upgrades.
- If Ty France departs in free agency, Sheets becomes the leading candidate for the strong-side platoon at first base, boosting his playing-time floor.
San Diego’s front office framed the agreement as a hedge: the club retains a proven righty-masher at a below-market rate while Sheets bets on a healthy 2027 to trigger his first opt-out.
“This new arrangement guarantees him some extra money while also providing multiple chances to test free agency if he performs at a high level,” MLB Trade Rumors wrote, calling the extension “a three-year deal in name only.” Yahoo Sports echoed that the structure is “extremely team-friendly,” saving roughly $4 million against the competitive-balance tax in the first season.
The Padres still face a first-base vacancy if France signs elsewhere. Sheets logged 43 games at first and 42 in the outfield corners in 2026, but defensive metrics grade him below average at all three spots.
Preller has indicated the club will explore external upgrades, yet retaining Sheets ensures a known quantity for the platoon while the market develops. Friars on Base argued non-tendering him would have risked “another batch of at-bats to fill” alongside the departures of Miguel Andújar and France.
Holy Sheets! We have signed infielder/outfielder Gavin Sheets to a three-year contract through the 2029 season with player options following the 2027 and 2028 seasons. pic.twitter.com/Od2ntfJFX5
Sheets opted to rehab the plantar plate tear rather than undergo surgery, per general manager A.J. Preller, targeting a full spring training. His first-half 2026 line — .236/.326/.461, 121 wRC+ in 288 plate appearances — suggests the injury, not skill erosion, drove the second-half collapse. The Padres are betting that health restores the 2025 form that made him a 1.4 fWAR contributor.
With the CBA set to expire Dec. 1, San Diego secured cost certainty on a roster piece before potential labor turbulence. The deal also preserves draft capital — no qualifying offer was required — and keeps the clubhouse culture intact around a player teammates credit for leadership. “He’s a beloved clubhouse presence,” the club’s announcement stated, underscoring the intangible value that analytics alone miss.

Sheets will report to Peoria in February with a chance to reclaim the strong-side platoon role and audition for his first opt-out. The Padres, meanwhile, pivot to the rotation market with $4 million in cleared tax space and one less arbitration hearing on the docket.
Sheets, born April 23, 1996, grew up in Baltimore and starred at Gilman School before the Atlanta Braves drafted him in 2014; he declined to sign and played three seasons at Wake Forest, batting .317 with 21 home runs as a junior in 2017.
The Chicago White Sox then took him 49th overall that year, and he debuted in the majors on June 29, 2021, collecting a hit, an RBI, an extra-base hit and a run in his first game — all off Kenta Maeda — before hitting a walk-off three-run homer off José Berríos weeks later.
Disclaimer: The fantasy and market insights provided are for informational and entertainment purposes only and do not constitute financial or betting advice.
Padres, 1B/OF Gavin Sheets reportedly agree to 3-year extension, per multiple reports including MLB’s @Feinsand. pic.twitter.com/V4XrrIA9Fc
Outfielder Gavin Sheets and the San Diego Padres are in agreement on a three-year, $11 million contract, sources tell ESPN. The deal includes player options for the second and third years at $4 million each. Sheets gets a $500,000 signing bonus and $2.5 million salary in 2027.