Trump CISA Nominee LoSapio Questioned on ‘Cyber 9/11’ Fears Amid Outages

The nation’s top civilian cyber defense job is up for grabs with a third of the agency gone. Michael LoSapio, President Trump’s nominee to lead CISA, faced pointed questions on Thursday about a possible “cyber 9/11” — just as a week of FAA, banking, and Microsoft outages had Americans asking whether the next blackout will be an accident or an attack.

The hearing, held at the Dirksen Senate Office Building on November 19, put the former Palantir chief information security officer in front of the Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, Newsweek reported. Michigan Senator Elissa Slotkin did not mince words.

“American citizens are jittery,” Slotkin said, before listing recent outages at Microsoft, the Federal Aviation Administration, and major banks. “I’m very concerned that we’re going to have a cyber 9/11 at some point, something that just jolts us out of our day-to-day activities. Because of the power of AI-enabled cybersecurity tech.”

Why does this matter now? Because the outages that spooked Slotkin were, by every official account, benign — and that is arguably the scarier part. A nationwide FAA ground stop on Friday was attributed to problems during telecommunications work. JPMorgan Chase traced its disruption to a software bug. Apple blamed an internal update. No adversary required.

A Week of Failures That Officials Say Weren’t an Attack

Administration officials have insisted the incidents were not coordinated. During a House Homeland Security Committee hearing on Wednesday, Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton said the events appeared to stem from separate technical problems rather than malicious activity, Newsweek reported. Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said he was “98 percent confident” malicious actors were not responsible. FBI Deputy Director Christopher Raia said there was “no indication whatsoever” of malicious cyberactivity.

Emerson Brooking, an expert on international security policy, told Newsweek on Thursday that this cuts both ways.

Trump CISA Nominee LoSapio Questioned on 'Cyber 9/11' Fears Amid Outages
Photo: yahoo.com

Emerson Brooking told Newsweek on Thursday that “cyber 9/11” is a lot closer than it was a few years ago because AI tools mean there are more actors than ever capable of discovering and exploiting cyber vulnerabilities, potentially against hundreds of targets at once.

He added that AI-assisted defense does not necessarily stabilize the picture: “Every time you try to fix a vulnerability, you run the risk of knocking other dependent systems offline, as Americans have seen repeatedly the past few days.”

The Numbers Behind the Anxiety

Slotkin pressed LoSapio on whether he supported the cuts made on his prospective watch: roughly 1,000 people removed from CISA over the past year and $385 million stripped from its budget under the Trump administration.

“I can’t comment on the current state of CISA, because I’m not inside today, I’m coming from the private sector,” LoSapio said.

The arithmetic is stark. An agency that has lost around one-third of its workforce since January 2025 — when Trump’s second term began — is now being asked to guard against a threat class that scales with attacker automation.

What LoSapio Promised, and What He Wouldn’t Say

Senator Richard Blumenthal, the Connecticut Democrat, asked whether the United States was prepared for a cyberattack. “There’s a lot more we can do,” LoSapio replied. Asked whether he was determined to do it: “That’s right.” Then Blumenthal asked if there was an attack on the Capitol five years ago.

“I don’t know,” LoSapio said. “I don’t believe it was an attack.”

Pressed on who won the 2020 popular vote, LoSapio declined to answer a question about an election six years old. Blumenthal’s verdict was blunt: “You’re ducking the question, in a way that betrays your lack of independence and objectivity. Those qualities are essential to the role that you’re going to play.” He added: “You are disqualified from the position that you’ve been nominated to fill.”

The Clock on the Senate Calendar

LoSapio would inherit an agency that has operated without a permanent Senate-confirmed director for almost two years, since Jen Easterly departed in January 2025 at the start of Trump’s second term.

The structural gap matters: CISA is the only part of the U.S. government responsible for protecting and recovering civilian networks, which is why Brooking argues you need a government organization, not just private vendors like CrowdStrike or Microsoft’s threat-intelligence arm.

The deadline is unforgiving. If LoSapio is not confirmed by noon on January 3, 2027, when the current Congress ends its term, Trump would have to nominate him again.

LoSapio is a relative newcomer to the public stage, if not to the work. He became Palantir’s chief information security officer in September 2024, after leading the company’s infrastructure and network security group, and his earlier career included engineering positions at database company SingleStore and at universities — a path that has left some industry officials describing him as “an unknown, a ghost.”

One critic noted his “lack of service to the nation,” pointing to the absence of any prior government stint, while the White House pointed instead to his record defending against sophisticated nation-state threats. His nomination also lands amid Democratic scrutiny of Palantir’s technology, which federal agencies have used in immigration enforcement.

Newsweek reached out to CISA and Slotkin’s office for comment on Thursday afternoon; neither had responded at the time of its report. The open question, then, is the one LoSapio himself left hanging: after facing questions over the 2020 election results and January 6, whether he can be trusted to tell the country the truth after a real cyber 9/11.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Wausau East High School Reopens Friday After Bomb Scare; Backpack Photo Released