Two De Standaard Editors Back Parents Asking Friend to Avoid Smoking Near Kids

Three editors at De Standaard have weighed in on a reader’s dilemma, with two siding with parents who asked a friend to avoid smoking or vaping where their children could see it.

The question, published this week in the newspaper’s advice column, came from a smoker who felt a friend’s request was overprotective and threatened to make a holiday gathering less convivial. Each week, three editors answer a question submitted by readers or drawn from conversations along the way.

Editor Frédéric De Gucht backed the hosting parents. “Your freedom stops where another’s begins,” he wrote. “Since seeing people smoke is unhealthy, the person who objects pulls the longest straw.” De Gucht compared the request to refraining from smoking next to someone on a terrace if asked, and suggested the reader simply step into a dark corner out of the children’s sight.

He also noted the practical reality that the smoker would already need to go outside during the Christmas period, and proposed a counter-test: ask everyone to avoid alcohol in front of the children and see how much sympathy that draws.

He added that the reader must presumably stay away from the children during daytime activities if they do not want the children to inhale smoke, and expressed hope that the children are still small and go to bed early.

A second editor acknowledged the friend sounded like a “curling parent” who tries to clear every obstacle from a child’s path. “Newsflash: that’s not how the world works,” the editor wrote. Children will inevitably see people smoking or vaping on the street, on terraces, at school gates, or in films. Parents cannot fully shield them from that reality, but they can explain why something is or isn’t allowed. Still, the editor added, the request was not unreasonable.

“Your friend isn’t asking you to quit smoking or vaping entirely. He only asks to do it out of sight of his children. That seems to me, honestly, not an unreasonable request.” The editor framed the issue as one of mutual consideration rather than principle, noting that secondhand smoke is harmful, especially to children.

“Are there actually good arguments to smoke or vape near children? If so, you can always email them.” The editor recalled seeing a photo of a smoking Koen Wauters as a child and thinking it looked cool.

The third editor focused on the social dynamic. “Your friends make the conviviality, I hope, and the eating and drinking together. You don’t necessarily have to puff together.” The editor conceded it is unpleasant to have one’s freedom curtailed on a weekend, but suggested the reader could smoke discreetly during the day.

Photo of author

Health Desk

Health Desk at Archyde.

Anthropic Stock Tumbles 10% in Wall Street Debut Amid AI Fears