University of Bath Study Finds Essential Genes Do Not Mutate Less Often

A massive dataset of spontaneous mutations in E. coli and baker’s yeast shows no evidence that essential genes mutate less often than other genes, a University of Bath study published November 12 in PLOS Biology found.

The result overturns a 1972 hypothesis that evolution installs extra safeguards on critical DNA, a claim that has resurfaced repeatedly, most recently in 2023.

By analyzing mutation-accumulation lines that limit natural selection’s filtering power, researchers Sofia Radrizzani and Laurence D. Hurst found that gene essentiality, protein abundance, and long-term conservation failed to predict mutation rate in either microbe. “The claim that mutation is slower for important genes is a triumph of hype over substance,” Radrizzani said.

Raw mutation rate measured by bypassing purifying selection

Earlier studies counted mutations surviving in natural populations, a method that conflates the raw mutation rate with the aftermath of purifying selection. Harmful changes in essential genes vanish quickly, making those genes look unusually stable. Hurst calls these vanished changes “ghost mutations.” It is like counting cracks only in bridges still standing and concluding the collapsed ones never had any, dailyinference.news reported.

To bypass that filter, the Bath team used mutation-accumulation experiments, which propagate lines through severe bottlenecks so that selection cannot efficiently remove deleterious alleles. They amassed what they describe as the largest and cleanest sample of spontaneous mutations assembled to date for wild-type Escherichia coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Three independent tests for residual selection bias found no substantial distortion, thesciencebeat.com noted.

Evolution Put No Extra Locks on Vital Genes, a Study in E. coli and Yeast Finds
Photo: dailyinference.news

Essentiality, abundance, and conservation all come up empty

Gene importance was measured three ways: knockout lethality, protein abundance, and the strength of purifying selection across evolutionary time. None predicted a lower mutation rate in either species. Genes producing more abundant proteins showed no protection in E. coli or yeast, Radrizzani said.

The team also tested the long-standing claim that genes on the leading replication strand in bacteria mutate less than those on the lagging strand. In E. coli they found no strand difference, consistent with recent findings in other prokaryotes, dailyinference.news added.

A single, weak exception appeared: highly transcribed genes in E. coli showed a slight reduction in mutation rate, an effect absent in yeast. The abstract concludes this does not support a consistent effect of gene importance across the two species.

What actually drives mutation rate variation

Mutation rates are not uniform across the genome, but the variation maps to structural and replicative features, not gene importance. Genes replicated later during DNA synthesis accumulate more mutations than early-replicating genes. None of these differences matched a system that specifically shields essential genes, thesciencebeat.com reported.

The study’s conclusions rest on one bacterium and one yeast. The sources do not describe results for other organisms, so the findings apply to those two microbes. Hurst said the team found no grounds for a paradigm shift. The paper, titled “The importance of genes does not predict their mutation rate,” appears in PLOS Biology volume 24, issue 11 (DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.3004089).

“We found that genes producing more abundant proteins don’t have lower mutation rates,”

The University of Bath, which received its royal charter in 1966 as Bath University of Technology following the Robbins Report, traces its origins to the Bristol Trade School founded in 1856. Its purpose-built campus on Claverton Down overlooks the UNESCO World Heritage city and was constructed from 1964 in the modernist style.

— Sofia Radrizzani, University of Bath

Darwin’s finches remain the standard illustration: random mutations produce beak variation, and selection sorts the outcome.

Photo of author

Technology Desk

Technology Desk at Archyde.

Seven Young Photographers Open Guet Ndar Fishing Exhibition in Saint-Louis