California voters rejected a first-in-the-nation wealth tax on billionaires and simultaneously approved a constitutional ban on future taxes on financial assets, delivering a major setback to progressive tax advocates in a heavily Democratic state.
Proposition 40, which would have imposed a one-time 5% tax on the net worth of residents worth more than $1 billion, was defeated with 52% of voters opposed, the Washington Post reported. At the same time, voters narrowly passed Proposition 42, which prohibits the state from enacting future taxes on financial assets—a restriction that can only be overturned by another ballot measure.
“I don’t think you’re going to see such a good Democratic electorate in the near future,” said Wesley Hussey, a political science professor at California State University, Sacramento. “This was the time to pass something that was pretty lefty and progressive and had a lot of opposition.”
The dual outcome came despite national gains for “tax the rich” measures. Washington voters upheld a 9.9% tax on household income over $1 million, and Colorado adopted a graduated income tax including an 8.4% rate on income over $1 million. Legislatures in Hawaii, Maine and Rhode Island also approved new millionaire taxes this year, according to the Boston Globe.

California’s measure differed by targeting assets rather than income, and by aiming at billionaires rather than millionaires. A committee opposing Proposition 40 and supporting Proposition 42 raised more than $333 million, including large donations from tech billionaires Sergey Brin and Eric Schmidt, making it one of the most expensive ballot battles in state history. Opponents outspent supporters by roughly 10 to 1.
Gov. Gavin Newsom was among the prominent Democrats warning the tax was a bad financial deal for the state, which relies heavily on the wealthy for income tax revenue. Facing pushback from Newsom, the measure’s primary backer—SEIU United Healthcare Workers West—offered in June to scale the levy down to 2%, but Newsom’s office said the proposal remained fundamentally flawed and talks collapsed.
“We were hopefully optimistic based on the polls that voters would agree with us that Prop. 40 was just a horrible idea for the state and Prop. 42 provides some important protections going forward,” said David Kline, a spokesperson for the California Taxpayers Association.
Proponents, including SEIU UHW, U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders and U.S. Rep. Ro Khanna, are framing the loss as progress. “The game is up, people have had it and this election is just the beginning,” Khanna said on election night. Advocates have signaled they may bring the idea back to voters in 2028.
Davis added that he thinks the pendulum is swinging toward increased interest in taxing the rich.
The vote shows voters did not completely repudiate the concept of taxing the wealthy at higher rates.
Washington and Colorado also directed revenue from their new millionaire taxes toward education, health care and other services. Spending on those measures paled in comparison to the billionaire tax battle in California.
Carl Davis, research director at the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy, said the national results showed “a really good batting average” for higher taxes on the wealthy, but noted California’s effort was hurt by divisions within organized labor.