World leaders are banking climate policy on carbon capture technology that has buried less CO2 annually than a single large power plant emits, because the models guiding global negotiations assume it will work at massive scale despite three decades of underperformance.
Antalya, Turkey — The labels on airline tickets and shipping boxes promise “carbon neutral” and “net zero.” Those pledges rest on a comforting premise: we can keep burning fossil fuels if we simply capture the pollution and lock it away underground.
But a joint investigation by ProPublica and Drilled reveals that the world’s reliance on carbon capture and storage (CCS) is built on models that assume success rates and storage capacities the technology has never achieved.

How big is the gap between projections and reality?
After 30 years of development, only 12 large-scale geologic storage projects have been built globally. At least seven have underperformed or failed outright. Last year, the total amount of CO2 buried underground was less than the annual emissions of a single large power plant.
Meanwhile, the International Energy Agency’s scenarios project an industry that would rival the entire current global oil sector within two decades. Solar power, by contrast, has consistently blown past model projections, while CCS capacity has flatlined.
Why do the models assume CCS will work?
Because the modelers have baked in optimistic assumptions that contradict real-world data. The investigation, based on interviews with leaders of the three most influential integrated assessment models — based in the Netherlands, Germany, and Austria — identified four critical flaws:
- Capture rates: Models calculate up to 92% capture efficiency. Actual projects show far lower rates. Keywan Riahi, who leads the Austrian model (MESSAGEix), told ProPublica that capturing concentrated CO2 from industrial emissions “is not high-tech, this is very easy to do,” arguing that carbon taxes and subsidies will drive performance.
- Injection limits: Only the German model (REMIND), led by Jessica Strefler, assumed any limit on how fast CO2 can be pumped underground. She based that limit on “expert interviews” with industry insiders, citing a lack of good public data. Chevron’s Gorgon project in Australia — billed as the world’s largest CCS operation — has struggled with clogged wells and pressure spikes, venting most of its CO2 to the atmosphere.
- Storage capacity: Models treat underground storage as effectively infinite, drawing on a 2005 UN report written at the behest of Saudi Arabia and allied petrostates, with authors from Saudi Aramco, Chevron, and Shell. Riahi conceded his model assumes infinite capacity, though the real potential may be “smaller.”
- Leakage: Detlef van Vuuren, leader of the Dutch model (IMAGE), confirmed his model does not factor in leakage risk. “Nope,” he said when asked. Scientists warn even tiny annual leak rates over long horizons could erase the climate benefit. The investigation found two large-scale sites that have leaked, one reaching the surface.
What about the cost assumption?
Models assume CCS gets cheaper over time. Real-world costs have climbed. When asked if it makes sense to assume future generations will pay heavily to remove CO2 when current governments won’t spend modest sums to avoid emitting it, Strefler replied: “If a country is not willing to do that, I don’t see how they would be willing to” pay for CO2 removal.
Keywan Riahi, who leads the Austrian MESSAGEix model, has been working with the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change since the late 1990s and served as a lead author on its third through sixth assessment reports.
His doctoral thesis at Graz University of Technology examined long-term technological change in energy systems including carbon capture and sequestration. Reuters lists him as the most influential climate scientist globally, and Clarivate has named him a Highly Cited Researcher. He also co-chairs the Austrian Panel on Climate Change.
Modelers defend CCS assumptions as policy choice not technical limit
Van Vuuren said his team is revising some assumptions but sees no technical reason CCS cannot work or should be excluded. He characterized the choice as a policy decision: whether countries wish to invest the dollars and effort to make it happen.
Riahi, half-joking when asked why not assume aliens will solve climate change, said: “You can quote me that I think carbon dioxide removal is more likely than an alien.”
What happens next?
The UN climate summit in Antalya wrapped last week, but the negotiations’ foundation — the modeled pathways that presume gigaton-scale CCS — remains unchanged. Van Vuuren said revisions are underway, though no timeline was given. The 2005 UN report underpinning the storage estimates still stands, with the IPCC saying it stands by the work. As long as the models treat CCS as a guaranteed ingredient, the world’s “net zero” labels will rest on a recipe that has yet to prove it can be cooked.