Albanese Stands Beside Lavrov In Manila Photo; Ukrainian Group Calls It Appalling

Anthony Albanese wanted a summit stage to condemn Russia’s war.

Instead, on Tuesday in Manila, the Australian prime minister found himself standing shoulder to shoulder with Sergei Lavrov in the East Asia Summit’s traditional family photo — and, 1News reported, Ukraine’s advocates in Australia are calling the result “appalling.”

The photo, shared with representatives from more than a dozen nations at the annual gathering hosted by the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, put the leaders of Australia and Russia in the same frame for the first time since Moscow invaded Ukraine in February 2022, according to 1News.

New Zealand Foreign Minister Winston Peters and Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi also appear in the picture, caught in the awkward cross-over handshake familiar to anyone who has watched a summit close.

For the Australian Federation of Ukrainian Organisations, the image landed like a slap. The federation had already urged Albanese not to pose with Vladimir Putin at the APEC leaders’ summit in China later in the week — and it saw the Manila photo as a betrayal of a principle Australia itself had enforced just weeks earlier.

“This is deeply disappointing and sends an appalling message,” federation chair Kateryna Argyrou told AAP, as quoted by 1News.

Trump, Modi, Albanese And Takaichi Pose For Family Photo At Manila Summit | DWS News — DWS News

A principle dropped in Manila

The contradiction sits at the heart of the criticism. At a G20 summit in October, the traditional family photo was cancelled altogether after opposition from European, Australian and Canadian delegations — sparing Foreign Minister Penny Wong from posing alongside Lavrov, 1News reported.

“Australia refused to legitimise Lavrov through a family photograph at the G20,” Argyrou said. “The question is, why that same principle apparently does not apply in Manila and we now see the prime minister appearing alongside a representative of a war criminal?”

Her sharpest line cut to the inconsistency itself. “You cannot condemn Russia’s war crimes in one room and normalise its representative in another without raising serious questions about consistency,” she said.

Albanese’s office has not, in the material reported, offered a distinction between the two summits. What is known is what the prime minister said before the trip: on Sunday, he did not rule out appearing in a photo alongside Putin, saying he would consider and respect the wishes of APEC host China, 1News reported.

What Albanese said on stage

True to a promise he made if he ended up in the same room as the former KGB officer, Albanese used his summit address to condemn Russia’s “unprovoked and unjustified war,” according to 1News.

“Russia’s continued aggression against Ukraine is fundamentally at odds with our region’s commitment to peace, sovereignty and territorial integrity and we will support Ukraine for as long as it takes to resolve this conflict on its terms,” he said.

He also called out “destabilising and dangerous conduct in the South China Sea” — a veiled criticism of Chinese military activity in the strategic waterway, where maritime encounters between China and the Philippines have escalated in recent years over disputed shoals. A 2016 international arbitration deemed the shoals situated in Philippine territorial waters.

So the record now holds both things at once: a prime minister who condemned Russia’s war in the summit hall, and a prime minister photographed beside Russia’s top diplomat in the corridor. Argyrou’s argument is that the second undoes the first.

Albanese’s defenders would point to the format — a family photo is a host’s protocol, not a bilateral meeting — and to the fact that the leaders of Australia and Russia have not actually met since the invasion began.

The APEC question still open

The immediate test comes later in the week. The APEC leaders’ summit, hosted by China, is the event the federation originally feared: Putin is attending, and Albanese declined on Sunday to rule out sharing a frame with him. Whether the Manila precedent makes a Shenzhen photo more or less likely is the question his critics intend to keep alive.

The stakes are not merely symbolic. Australia has supplied Ukraine with military aid and remains among Kyiv’s most committed partners outside NATO — a posture that makes every protocol decision involving Russian officials read, in Kyiv’s friendly circles, as a signal. The federation’s letters and statements exist precisely because it believes those signals matter.

What remains unresolved is the simplest question of all, the one Argyrou posed and nobody in Canberra has yet answered: why the G20 rule did not travel to Manila. Until that is explained, the family photo will keep circulating — seventeen world leaders, one frame, and one face that Australia says it refuses to legitimise.

The East Asia Summit is one of several gatherings that the Association of Southeast Asian Nations convenes, operating on a principle of “centrality” under which concerns from outside powers about Southeast Asia are routed through ASEAN rather than individual states.

The organisation was created on 8 August 1967, when the foreign ministers of five countries signed the ASEAN Declaration — originally to contain communism, before reorienting toward economic development and keeping foreign interference out of the region. It has since grown to include all 11 Southeast Asian states, representing more than 680 million people and around 6.3% of global GDP, with its headquarters in Jakarta.

The next date on the calendar is the APEC summit in China, where Albanese has committed to restating Australia’s position if he ends up in the same room as Putin. “If he did end up in the same room,” 1News reported of the prime minister’s Sunday pledge, “he would restate Australia’s position that the war in Ukraine was an illegal and immoral invasion.”

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Working Students Triple to 17% of Enrollment as Italy Living Costs Top €1,000/Month

White House National Cyber Director Sean Cairncross Ousted After Tech Outages