Atomic Access Co-Founder Alleges Locked Out in Share Dispute

“It was built on years of unpaid work,” Joe Botha said.

The co-founder of South African internet service provider Atomic Access alleges that a dispute with fellow founder Michael Pollock has left him and Nick Soper locked out of the company they built, MyBroadband reported.

Botha is not a minor figure in South African telecoms. He co-founded fibre network operator Frogfoot, data centre company Teraco, and fibre operator Octotel before turning his attention to Atomic Access in 2016, while he was still building Octotel.

His account of how control of the ISP slipped away from two of its three principal founders is a case study in founder-shareholder risk — and in what happens when share issuance is deferred.

Atomic Access, Pollock, and third director Giles Filmer all declined to comment when MyBroadband approached them. In a statement, the company said it does not intend to argue the matter in public: “Atomic does not intend to argue these confidential and commercial issues in public while they are being dealt with through the proper channels.”

It added that its network, services and support continue to operate normally and that the matter does not affect customers.

The allegations therefore remain one-sided on the public record. What follows is what Botha and Soper claim, what the company has said in response, and where the two accounts diverge.

The Bottom Line

  • Botha and Soper say they were offered materially fewer rights than the 2019 founders’ agreement promised, and remain without their issued shares.
  • Pollock, as sole share custodian, allegedly voted down a share-issuance proposal in December 2025 and later appointed a third director, breaking a 50/50 board deadlock in his favour.
  • Both founders lost system access in August 2026, and their founder loan repayments stopped in September 2026; they are weighing legal action and building a new venture, FiClub, targeting a Q1 2027 launch.

How the equity was meant to work

According to MyBroadband’s report, Botha began work on Atomic Access in 2016 and never drew a salary from the company. Soper joined in 2018. In 2019 — the year Botha left Octotel — three more people came aboard and the group signed a founders’ agreement allocating shares, with vesting over four years between 2018 and 2022 and equal voting rights for Botha, Soper, and Pollock.

Founder Agreed allocation Background
Joe Botha 25.1% Co-founder of Frogfoot, Teraco, Octotel; built Atomic’s core network
Nick Soper 25.1% Ran and built the business
Michael Pollock 25.1% Head of ops & finance; sole share custodian
Giles Filmer 5% Former Frogfoot hire of Botha’s
Warwick Duncan 3% Founder

The remainder was held back for late co-founders. Critically, Pollock held all the shares as sole custodian because, Botha says, he offered to handle administration — setting up the company and applying for the ICASA licence. The facts: the person controlling the share register was also one of three equal voting founders, and the shares were never issued.

“The lesson for founders here is if you are promised shares, get them issued. A promise is only as good as the person holding the shares,” Botha told MyBroadband.

Where the founders’ accounts split

Botha says a pattern set in around April 2022, when Pollock applied to register the Atomic Access trademark in his own name rather than in the company’s. He also points to the company’s most visible shortcoming: Atomic is, in his words, perhaps the only ISP without a customer portal, with billing automation that “could have taken six months” stalling for years despite two developers working on it.

The work split, as Botha describes it, was three ways: Botha on network, Soper on growth, Pollock on billing. “Network and growth delivered a solid network and the growth engine. CRM and billing never kept up, so automation was always delayed,” he said.

He noted the irony against the company’s own name — an atomic transaction, in computing, is a single request that reliably delivers what was asked for, which is where the name came from.

Pollock’s side of the story is not on the record. He, Filmer, and the company declined MyBroadband’s request for comment, and the company’s statement frames the dispute as confidential and being handled through proper channels. Readers should treat the timeline below as allegations, not findings.

From boardroom vote to locked mailbox

The sequence, as reported by MyBroadband:

  • 19 December 2025 — at a board meeting, Soper proposes issuing shares per the founders’ agreement; Pollock allegedly votes it down. With only two board members, the vote splits 50/50 and the shares are not issued.
  • 21 January 2026 — Pollock allegedly uses his position as sole shareholder to appoint Filmer as a third director, citing the need to prevent a board deadlock.
  • 26 August 2026 — Botha loses access to network backend systems and his Atomic email account.
  • 31 August 2026 — Filmer allegedly confirms Botha’s mailbox was “forwarded to two custodians for recovery purposes”.
  • September 2026 — repayments of Botha’s and Soper’s founder loans stop without notice, according to the two founders; they are considering legal action to recover the loans.

Once Filmer joined the board, the 50/50 deadlock that had protected the founders’ agreement became a 2-1 majority against it. That, in structural terms, is the pivot of the whole dispute: control of the share register plus a board majority meant the custodian no longer needed the founders’ consent.

Why this matters beyond one ISP

Atomic Access is a small private company, so there is no share price to move and no filing for regulators to publish. The market relevance is precedent, not price.

South Africa’s fibre and ISP sector has consolidated heavily around listed and institutional-backed players — among them the companies Botha helped build — and disputes like this one test how well founder agreements hold up when a single custodian controls issuance. Botha’s own advice distils it: get the shares issued.

The reputational arithmetic cuts both ways. Atomic says customers are unaffected and operations continue normally. But Botha claims the company’s time and money are now going into a legal fight against the people who built it, rather than into the portal and billing automation customers actually need.

“Instead of building what customers need, like a portal and billing automation, its time and money are going into a legal fight against the founders who built it,” Botha told MyBroadband.

Founders build new company targeting 2027 launch

Botha and Soper have not simply walked away. With a few other friends, they have started building a new company called FiClub, aiming to launch in the first quarter of 2027. Whether they recover their founder loans, and what the “proper channels” Pollock’s side invokes produce, remains unresolved.

For Botha, the loss is not only financial. “It’s painful to look at the Atomic website now. Nick and I built it, and so much of our ideas and identity is in there, and we’re locked out of it now,” he said.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Acute Necrotizing Pancreatitis as Initial Presentation of Celiac Disease: A Case Report

18 Hurt in Multi-Vehicle Crash on Columbia Highway 63