Consumer NZ: Noel Leeming ‘Mega Deal’ Coffee Machine at Highest Tracked Price

A coffee machine advertised by Noel Leeming as a “Mega Deal” carried the highest price Consumer NZ recorded for that product in 12 weeks of tracking — $869 — and the consumer watchdog says New Zealand’s biggest retailers are increasingly making it hard to tell whether a sale is real.

Consumer NZ tracked 13 products across five major retailers over 12 weeks, examining how sale prices and promotional language such as “Mega Deal”, “Price Smash” and “Red Hot Deal” were used, according to reporting by 1News.

“There may be a discount, but it’s not perhaps as good as consumers are led to believe.”

That is Consumer NZ research lead Rebecca Styles, who said retailers risked breaching the Fair Trading Act if customers were misled.

The watchdog ranked the five retailers on how easy it is for shoppers to spot a genuine sale. Noel Leeming came last, described as “heavy-handed” with sale promises.

“It’s impossible to know which promotional label represents the biggest opportunity to save.”

“The mega deal was actually a meagre deal.”

Both quotes are Styles, on the Noel Leeming Breville coffee machine promoted at $869 — the highest price recorded for the machine during the study.

Noel Leeming chief executive Jason Bell said the coffee machine regularly featured in promotions and that the “Mega Deal” price was still among the best available on the market at the time. Bell also rejected the suggestion the promotion could breach the Fair Trading Act.

“We are confident this is not a breach of the Fair Trading Act or misleading, as it was just positioned as a deal, we did not claim a specific saving.”

According to 1News, other retailers had not yet responded to questions.

Briscoes topped the rankings because its sale prices were generally clearly cheaper than usual prices, prices regularly returned to full price between promotions, and it used less promotional language than competitors.

“What sets Briscoes apart from the other stores is that prices don’t fluctuate as much.”

That did not mean Briscoes always had the lowest prices: a Ninja air fryer fell to $125 at Briscoes, while the same product later dropped to $97 at Noel Leeming.

Farmers placed second, but Consumer NZ said some of its labels could confuse shoppers. One washing machine carried a “great price” label throughout the entire 12-week tracking period despite ranging from $1248 to $1669, and a Samsung heat-pump dryer was labelled a “great price” at both $1399 and $1989.

At JB Hi-Fi, a Breville Barista Express coffee machine was advertised “On Sale” at $600; weeks later it appeared as a “Red Hot Deal” at $698 and also $848. Consumer said the labels gave little indication of actual savings.

Harvey Norman, fourth, had reduced its use of promotional labels since being criticised in a similar investigation last year, but a handheld garment steamer was still $34 cheaper when unlabelled, and an air fryer $10 cheaper when not promoted as a “birthday deal” or “hot deal”.

Consumer NZ is an independent, non-profit consumer advocacy organisation established in 1959, when it began life as the Consumers’ Council. It lost its government funding in 1986 and became an incorporated society funded by member subscriptions, adopting its current name in 2007.

The watchdog has a history of campaigning against misleading supermarket promotions, filing a complaint to the Commerce Commission in 2023 with 600 examples of pricing and promotional errors. It also runs Powerswitch, a website that helps consumers compare power plans.

Styles said constant promotions make it difficult for shoppers to know what a product’s normal price actually is.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Nikon Builds Semiconductor Lithography Systems for Over Four Decades