Homicide clearance rates in the United States have fallen from 92 percent in the early 1960s to roughly 60 percent in most recent years, and economist Philip J. Cook has spent five decades tracing why — arguing, counterintuitively, that the decline may partly reflect something positive.
The full conversation airs this week on the Jeff-alytics podcast, published on Jeff-alytics, the Substack run by the show’s host.
The episode, titled “Why Fewer Murders Get Solved These Days With Phil Cook,” Jeff-alytics reported, digs into the real story behind the clearance rate decline, how one city addressed non-fatal shootings unlike anywhere else, and findings from a half-century of Cook’s research.
The numbers frame the stakes. In the early 1960s, police departments nationwide reported solving 92 percent of homicides. Today that figure hovers around 60 percent most years.
Cook’s explanation, as previewed by Jeff-alytics, resists the obvious conclusion that the decline is purely a failure. His argument is that the drop might, in part, be a good thing — a claim the episode unpacks at length.
Duke professor emeritus leads criminology research
Cook is Professor Emeritus of Public Policy and Economics at Duke University and a research associate at the National Bureau of Economic Research. He trained as an economist at the University of California, Berkeley, and built a career studying non-fatal shootings, gun markets, weapon effects, robbery, crime deterrence, and nearly every other major question in American criminology.
He did this when almost no other social scientists would touch the field. Cook was among the first scholars of any discipline to take up research on gun violence prevention, work that earned him the Stockholm Prize in Criminology in 2020. In 2001, he was elected to membership in the National Academy of Medicine.
That longevity matters for this particular question. Clearance rates are easy to misread — raw percentages hide shifts in what counts as a homicide, in forensic capability, and in the nature of the shootings themselves.
Cook has spent fifty years working across all of those variables, and his most recent book, Policing Gun Violence, written with Anthony A. Braga and published by Oxford University Press in 2023, focuses directly on the police role in combating gun violence.
The non-fatal shooting problem
One thread in the episode stands out for anyone who follows crime data: non-fatal shootings. Jeff-alytics highlighted how one city figured out how to address them like no other, a case study drawn from Cook’s current research program.
The reason this matters is arithmetic. Non-fatal shootings vastly outnumber homicides, yet they historically receive a fraction of the investigative attention.
Cook’s work with Braga has pushed exactly this reframe. Policing gun violence as a continuum — fatal and non-fatal treated as one problem — is the throughline of his current research, and the episode sits squarely inside it.
Why the clearance decline is complicated
The 92-to-60 drop is not a simple story of police getting worse. Cook’s body of research points to structural shifts in gun violence itself: the widespread availability of guns in the United States, the way weapon effects have changed the lethality of encounters, and the difficulty of building witness cooperation in the shootings that dominate the modern caseload.
His suggestion that the decline might be a good thing rests on that context. A homicide rate shaped differently than it was in 1960, investigated with different tools and against different street conditions, does not owe anyone a 1960s clearance number. The episode, Jeff-alytics indicated, walks through what that actually means rather than leaving it as a provocation.
Where to hear it
The episode is available on Apple and Spotify, and on the Jeff-alytics YouTube page. The post accompanying it is public, so the outlet is inviting shares and comments.
Recent guests on the show include Dan Semenza, Lt. Governor Austin Davis, New Orleans Police Chief Anne Kirkpatrick, and Gloria Gong — a lineup that tracks closely with Cook’s own territory of gun violence, policing, and policy.
For readers who want the primary source, Cook’s case for rethinking clearance rates is laid out in Policing Gun Violence (Oxford University Press, 2023), and his half-century of gun research is the reason the Stockholm Prize committee came calling in 2020.