Sarah DiMatteo is advocating for legislative changes in Florida following the death of her husband, Anthony DiMatteo, who died on Sept. 17, 2024, after a full-mouth dental implant procedure in Port St. Lucie.
The family and their attorney argue that the implementation of stricter safeguards regarding sedation could prevent similar fatalities in the future, according to WPBF 25 News.
Anthony DiMatteo, a father of five, had sought the dental work to address long-standing issues with cracked and loose teeth. Sarah DiMatteo dropped her husband off for the procedure shortly before 7 a.m., but was contacted by police three hours later and informed he was being rushed to a hospital. Doctors later determined he was brain dead.
“His absence has left us with an emptiness that’s really hard to describe with words,” Sarah DiMatteo said.
The St. Lucie County Medical Examiner’s Office ruled the death accidental, noting that it was caused by complications from the administration of fentanyl, midazolam and dexmedetomidine. The report also identified hypertension, cardiovascular disease and diabetes as contributing factors.
While the dentist involved held an active permit for moderate sedation from the Florida Department of Health, Sarah DiMatteo believes her husband’s medical history should have prompted more scrutiny regarding his candidacy for sedation.
“We trusted without asking those questions,” she said. “Now we know.”
The family’s attorney, Mike Grife, is calling for legislation that would mandate the presence of a dedicated anesthesia professional—such as an anesthesiologist or a certified registered nurse anesthetist—to monitor patients during dental procedures. Currently, Florida law allows dentists who meet specific training requirements to perform both the dental surgery and the sedation monitoring.
“Wouldn’t it make sense to have a physician, anesthesiologist or a certified registered nurse anesthetist who has gone through years of specialized training there to make sure the patient is protected?” Grife said.
Grife argues that requiring a single person to manage both the dental work and the sedation creates unnecessary risks if complications arise.
“Imagine trying to juggle all those things at once,” Grife said. “You’re handling the sedation, the dental procedure and, if complications arise, you’re supposed to be handling that.”
“We feel that Anthony’s death was preventable, that if the proper safeguards were in place, he would still be here today,” Grife said.