Federal Reserve officials released minutes on Wednesday showing two participants open to raising rates by more than 25 basis points in December, after holding the federal funds target steady at 3.75%-4.00% in October.
The record of the October 27-28 meeting leaves a 50-basis-point move on the table if inflation data arrive unfavorably before the December 8-9 decision, the minutes show. The October pause was not consensus: it passed 10-2, with Lisa Cook and Beth Hammack dissenting in favor of an immediate quarter-point increase, The Apex Index reported.
Here is why it matters now. Wall Street has already locked in a hike for December — the CME FedWatch tool, cited by finwire.io, puts the odds of a 25-basis-point move at roughly 95% and a 50-basis-point move at about 5%. The minutes widen the pricing risk around that consensus.
The Bottom Line
- A 50-basis-point December hike is conditionally on the table, tied explicitly to incoming inflation data.
- The October hold passed 10-2, and participants who supported it called it a “close call” — a hawkish hold, not a pivot.
- A majority of officials flagged the AI investment boom as a material inflation risk, a new variable in the pricing debate.
The Split Room Behind the Hold
Most participants supported no change in October, but a few said they would have preferred a quarter-point increase because they saw little evidence of inflation abating, according to the minutes. Several who backed the hold described the decision as a close call.
On the path forward, the minutes state that “almost all participants judged that, under their baseline outlooks for inflation and the labor market, further action to raise the target range for the federal funds rate—broadly consistent with the September Summary of Economic Projections—would likely be appropriate.”
The condition for a bigger move came in the next sentence: “A couple of participants noted that an increase of more than 25 basis points could warrant consideration at the next meeting if incoming inflation data were unfavorable,” according to the minutes published by the Federal Reserve. The document does not identify who said it.
Waller Forces the 50-Basis-Point Question
Fed Governor Christopher Waller has emerged as one of the biggest supporters of a 50 basis point hike in December. In a CNBC interview on Wednesday, he argued for a half-point December increase, The Apex Index reported — and left himself a fallback: a quarter-point move could suffice if officials clearly signaled another hike in January. Without that guidance, he favored doing more in December.
Per finwire.io, Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack alongside Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan and New York Fed President John Williams have each urged a slower, more measured path.
With Kevin Warsh now at the helm as Fed Chair, the central bank has narrowed its attention to the inflation side of its dual mandate nearly to the exclusion of the other half — and every new data release keeps strengthening the hawks’ case.
Labor market data pointed to strength, and payrolls for August and September were revised up by a combined 84k. Last week’s CPI came in hotter than expected. An in-line PPI offered some relief, but still showed the largest 12-month increase in headline PPI since November 2022 — and both reports showed price pressure spreading out of energy into other categories, per finwire.io.
Once a committee ties a bigger step to data, the next inflation releases become the focal point of market sensitivity, and it is the two-year and short-dated swap spreads — not the long end — that absorb the repricing, since what is being debated is how fast tightening proceeds rather than where it ultimately ends.
The December Scenarios on the Table
The arithmetic differs sharply depending on the committee’s choice. A quarter-point increase would take the target range to 4.00%-4.25%; a half-point move would lift it to 4.25%-4.50%, The Apex Index calculated from the Federal Reserve’s target. Market odds, per the CME FedWatch tool cited by finwire.io:
| December outcome | New target range | Market-implied odds |
|---|---|---|
| 25 bp hike (consensus) | 4.00%-4.25% | ~95% |
| 50 bp hike | 4.25%-4.50% | ~5% |
AI Investment Joins the Inflation Debate
One passage distinguishes these minutes from a routine tightening cycle. A majority of participants noted “the possibility that higher costs could be passed through more broadly and persistently to consumer and business prices,” specifically in the context of the AI construction and equipment boom running ahead of available supply, the minutes said.
There was a counterargument: some officials saw expanding productive capacity and improving productivity eventually easing price pressures, and said that greater scrutiny of AI companies’ returns and financing could slow investment and reduce demand. Officials also flagged upside risks from energy prices and constraints on refined fuels.
Meanwhile, participants described the labor market as stable and close to maximum employment, with economic activity expanding strongly. Inflation has now run above the Fed’s long-term target of 2% for over five years, per finwire.io — context for why the committee treats each print as decisive.
What Settles It Before December 8-9
Two things decide the size of the December move. First, the inflation releases between now and the meeting — the minutes make the 50-basis-point option conditional on exactly those prints. Second, whether the December round of economic projections formalizes the steeper path, as Newsquawk flagged as the follow-on to watch.
The committee's October pause, as officials described it, was meant to show that keeping rates steady did not weaken their commitment to returning inflation to 2%. The minutes deliver that message with a rider: a quarter-point is the baseline, but the tail is wider than futures currently price.
Watch the next CPI release. If it prints hot, the 5% tail on a half-point move becomes the live trade.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.