England’s cricket press is savouring every twist of the Sandpapergate saga, with the English papers lining up Pat Cummins after Cameron Bancroft’s explosive 4,000-word defence of himself in The West Australian.
The Telegraph’s chief cricket writer Oliver Brown likened Cummins’s denials to Bill Clinton’s “I did not have sexual relations with that woman” speech, writing on Wednesday that the Australia captain’s credibility was “in ruins”. The Daily Mail’s Oliver Holt went further still, demanding the Test skipper resign under the headline “Pat Cummins has torched his own reputation over Sandpapergate”.
Bancroft, one of the three players suspended when the scandal broke in 2018 after cameras caught him rubbing sandpaper on the ball against South Africa, wrote that the entire team knew what was going on. The final straw, he said, was Cummins’s press conference, at which the captain denied any knowledge of the 2018 plot.
Cameron Bancroft has claimed that the entire Australian team was involved in the ball-tampering scandal in South Africa in 2018 🚨 pic.twitter.com/ePyG07mBJA
“It made me feel angry, betrayed and alone.”
Cummins, through his manager Neil Maxwell, rejected the suggestion that Bancroft’s revelations contradicted his own position.
“Whilst we feel for Cam and everything he’s been through there’s nothing in the statement that hasn’t been answered by Pat in his press conference.”
said Maxwell, according to CODE Sports.

Cummins Rejects Khawaja's Ball-Tampering Claims
In the memoir, Khawaja alleges sandpaper was used on the ball in the second Test of the 2018 series in Port Elizabeth, now Gqeberha, and he told Nine newspapers that “it was all of us. Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us” who were responsible for the plot in the third Test at Cape Town.
Cummins, who faced questions on the topic for more than an hour at his press conference, rejected the claim directly.
Another earthquake in Australian cricket with the Bancroft revelations. They have no option now but to address the issue directly. A forum to express thoughts with no further action is now untenable. This is one of Australian cricket's biggest moments and just requires them to do…
“When (Khawaja) says we all knew, if by that he means that we knew sandpaper was going out on the field, he’s 100 per cent wrong.”
Cummins said. “I’ve said that consistently for the last eight years, I did not know that was happening.”
Khawaja was not the first to point the finger. Back in 2021, Bancroft mumbled to the Guardian that the bowlers knew he was tampering, saying: “Yeah, look, I think, yeah, I think it’s pretty probably self-explanatory.”
Bowling coach David Saker said at the time: “There were a lot of people to blame”, and Chadd Sayers said: “I believe everyone in that side knew what was going on and what was being used.”
The forum
Former England players have piled in. Matt Prior, speaking to The Cricketer, said he did not believe Cummins and Australia’s other bowlers were unaware of the tampering.
“There is just no way that a conversation wouldn’t have been had in any of the dressing rooms that I’ve played in.”
Prior said.
Writing from Perth before a one-day match between the old enemies, The Times’s chief cricket correspondent and former England captain Mike Atherton relished the upheaval.
The article by Bancroft on @cricinfo reveals what many of us have insisted post Khwaja's book release: @patcummins30 has been lying repeatedly. He is NOT a leader! After throwing teammates under the bus twice before, he did it again in the press conference a few days back. Not…
“Can there ever be a better time to be in this beautiful country than when Australian cricket is tearing itself apart?”
Atherton wrote, answering “obviously, no”. Atherton himself was accused of ball tampering in 1994, when he was fined after being accused of using dirt in his pocket during a Test against South Africa. He has always denied wrongdoing.
But Australia’s crisis may soon come to a formal head. Cricket Australia, whose board met on Tuesday evening, has announced an independent forum in which players and staff from the 2018 South Africa tour can give their version of events in a confidential environment.
Chief executive Todd Greenberg, speaking in Hobart on Thursday, said no new sanctions would be handed down and that the process, run by an independent senior lawyer or former judge, is expected to take about a month.
Greenberg insisted Cricket Australia was not “re-prosecuting” the initial investigation, and that the forum was a “circuit-breaker” to the rumbling controversy.
For English fans near the Oval, which is set to host the fifth Ashes Test next year, the view was blunter. “Hopefully, they’ll get what’s coming to them,” supporter Charlie Banfield told the ABC at The Rose pub near the ground.
Eight years after three players were sanctioned at Cape Town, it is the Australian captain, not the suspended trio, who now stands most exposed in the eyes of England’s press.