The microwave fish pie was supposed to be the office’s one settled rule — but this week, BBC News found boiled eggs, tuna and cinnamon pretzels cheerfully testing it.
Few things test workplace relationships like the colleague proudly unveiling a container of reheated fish, and what counts as acceptable desk food turns out to be divisive — tuna sandwiches, boiled eggs, anything crumbly or sticky enough to reach the keyboard.
“We all know not to bring in a microwave fish pie, that is the law,” said Sarah, a civil servant.
She has form, she admits — she committed the offence herself at a previous workplace and jokes “that’s the reason I left.” And the stakes run beyond social awkwardness: one company boss banned fish outright after the smell made a pregnant colleague physically sick.
The fish, the eggs, the 56%
- Fish remains the nuclear offence. Ashlea Fisher, who runs her own recruitment company, asked a member of staff to stop bringing it in.
- The new menace is sweet, sticky and crumbly. Cinnamon pretzels are putting sugar inside laptop keys, one content creator admits.
- Gen Z takes the break; millennials take the desk. A 2025 Just Eat report found 56% of Gen Z take a full break — the highest of any generation.
Casey Has Reformed
Casey, a content creator at an energy company, used to eat tuna at his desk. He has since “reformed,” he says, because you have to “suss out the smelliness” before deciding whether the desk is the right venue.
“The sugar’s going everywhere and it’s getting in my laptop keys,” he says.
Nobody in the office has commented yet. He is managing the evidence by “shuffling them off the desk.”

Laura Defends the Boiled Egg
Boiled eggs split the room too. Laura, who works in finance, has been teased by colleagues for eating them at her desk.
“In my defence, it was high protein, it was cost-effective and healthy – I swear by a good boiled egg,” she says.
And she goes further than mere defence: in her view, no food is off limits. “Coming from an Asian background where you’d eat fish for breakfast I am very open to it being eaten,” she says.
When the Smell Turned Physical
Fisher, the recruitment boss, tackled smelly food head on after asking a member of staff to stop bringing in fish. “The smell was so bad that a pregnant colleague was feeling physically sick,” she says.
“I’m a big believer in being able to have an honest conversation with your team,” Fisher says, suggesting other managers raise it lightly and without embarrassing anyone.
Her line in the sand: “Nobody should feel judged for what they eat, and we should respect different cultures and dietary requirements, but being mindful of the people around you is simply good workplace etiquette.”
So the desk-lunch debate now has two opposing camps with no referee: Laura, who says nothing should be off limits, and Fisher, who says awareness of your neighbours is basic etiquette. Neither side has budged.
Gen Z Walks Away From the Desk
But the food is only half the argument. The other half is whether anyone is actually taking the break — and the generations disagree there too.
According to a 2025 report by Just Eat, 56% of Gen Z take a full break, the most of any group, while millennials are the generation most likely to eat at their desk. Yahoo’s version of the report adds a photo caption noting that finance worker Laura takes a lunch and dinner break when she’s working long hours.
Alan Price, an employment law and HR expert and CEO of BrightHR, draws the line between convenience and habit. “While it can be convenient to eat at your desk, it’s not best practice to remain glued to the screen all day,” he says.
“Taking a break isn’t just an employment right, there are proven benefits for both physical and mental health,” he adds.
Laura sits firmly on the strict side. Her working day can occasionally finish at 2am, and stepping away is non-negotiable — she makes a point of taking an hour, which she calls “essential for maintaining my sanity.”
“I take my lunch break as much as possible, for the sake of my eyes and mental wellbeing,” she says.
Manny, also a content creator, sits at the other end. He has lunch at his desk most of the time, and his company operates a policy of “do the work when you want to do it.” The break flexes with the workload.
| Worker or group | Lunch habit | The figure |
|---|---|---|
| Gen Z | Most likely to take a full break | 56% (Just Eat, 2025) |
| Millennials | Most likely to eat at their desk | No figure given |
| Laura, finance | An hour away from the desk; days can end at 2am | One hour |
| Manny, content creator | Eats at his desk most of the time | 20 minutes to an hour |
And then the numbers get interesting, because they cut against the stereotype of the young worker chained to the screen. It is the generation above them — the millennials — who are most glued to the keyboard with a sandwich in one hand.
What nobody in the report resolves is the underlying rule, if there is one: whether the desk lunch is a personal right, as Laura argues, or a shared courtesy, as Fisher insists.
Just Eat, which commissioned the report, began life in 2001 in Kolding, Denmark, founded by five Danish entrepreneurs including Jesper Buch, and moved to London in 2006. It was bought by Netherlands-based Takeaway.com in 2020 to form Just Eat Takeaway.com, and its brands include Menulog in Australia and New Zealand and SkipTheDishes in Canada.
“Usually you just take 20 minutes to eat something, but on another day you might take an hour,” Manny says. “You just kind of feel it out.”