Five Aid Groups Give Trump Gaza Plan 4 of 26; One Calls Ceasefire ‘in Name Only

Four out of 26. That is the grade five major aid organizations gave the Trump administration’s 20-point Gaza peace plan this week, one year after the UN Security Council endorsed it — a failing mark that has slipped even lower since the six-month assessment in April 2026, when the same groups scored it five.

Al Jazeera reported the scorecard on Wednesday, published jointly by the Danish Refugee Council, the Norwegian Refugee Council, Oxfam, Refugees International and Save the Children. It grades the plan’s own commitments on civilian protection, humanitarian access, reconstruction and freedom of movement. Humanitarian access received zero. Civilian protection earned one point.

Here is why that matters. The plan was endorsed as UN Security Council Resolution 2803 in 2025 on the promise that it would end the mass killing of civilians and improve conditions for Palestinians. Instead, the agencies found that at least 1,650 Palestinians have been killed and 5,975 wounded since the ceasefire took effect in October 2025 — more than double the death toll recorded at the six-month mark.

“When you’re in Gaza, it does not feel like a ceasefire,” Shaun Hughes, the World Food Programme’s country director for Palestine, told journalists earlier this week. He said Israeli military control across nearly 70 percent of Gaza leaves people with almost no space to grow food, that fishing is prohibited and life-threatening, and that unemployment above 80 percent leaves families dependent on aid to survive.

The line that keeps moving

The most striking number in the report may be territorial. The ceasefire’s “Yellow Line” marked Israeli military control at 58 percent of Gaza when the truce began. According to OCHA figures cited by Al Jazeera, that figure has grown to 65 percent; Israel itself told the UN Security Council in June that it controlled 70 percent.

Five Aid Groups Give Trump Gaza Plan 4 of 26; One Calls Ceasefire 'in Name Only
Photo: Refugees International

Palestinians cannot cross the line. Its westward creep has squeezed roughly 2.1 million people into just 128 square kilometres — about 16,000 people per square kilometre, OCHA said last month. Recent map analysis by NPR, cited by Al Jazeera, puts the confined area even smaller, at 109 square kilometres, or nearly 19,300 people per square kilometre.

“Palestinians in Gaza are being confined as the ‘Yellow Line’ expands. This is displacement by design, and a ceasefire that allows it is a ceasefire in name only,” said Lilu Thapa, executive director for the Middle East, Asia and Europe at the Danish Refugee Council, in remarks carried by Al Jazeera.

Ramy Abdu, founder and chairman of the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, went further. He told Al Jazeera that Israel is carrying out unlawful acquisition of territory by force, and called the Board of Peace — the US-chaired body overseeing the plan — “a political shield for Israel’s occupation and its crimes.”

The numbers behind the blockade

The plan promised a minimum of 600 UN-coordinated aid trucks per day. In September, the daily average was 49, Al Jazeera reported — and only 2 percent of those convoys carried medical supplies. Gaza’s health ministry says 2,027 patients have died awaiting medical evacuation, with 21,000 still on waiting lists.

What does enter is often not what Gazans need. During the week of October 12, of 315 commercial trucks that crossed in, 223 carried food and 51 carried non-essential goods; a single truck carried medical supplies. Israeli authorities cite “dual-use” restrictions on goods with potential military applications.

Measure Planned Actual
Aid trucks per day 600 minimum 49 (September average)
Scorecard grade 26 points possible 4 (down from 5 in April 2026)
Humanitarian access Full opening Zero points
Territory under Israeli control 58% at ceasefire start 65–70% now
Confinement area — 109–128 sq km for 2.1 million

A board divided against its own plan

The Board of Peace, created by President Donald Trump to oversee the plan, delivered its own report to the Security Council on Tuesday. As the Associated Press reported, it warned of “a collapse of the fragile agreement” and acknowledged that a ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely.

The board’s 12-page assessment, seen by Reuters, blamed both sides: Hamas has continued attacks on Israeli troops and, per the report, taxes goods entering Gaza, while Israel rejected the 15-point disarmament roadmap that Hamas accepted on July 30 and has carried out near-daily strikes. Israel says it will not withdraw until Hamas is dismantled.

But the board’s sharpest criticism landed on Israeli political indecision. Its report states that the Palestinian technocratic administration created to run Gaza has still not been allowed into the territory, and that the absence of decisions by Israel’s government on civilian police deployment continues to block implementation of the plan.

When Al Jazeera pressed the board’s head of communications, Brad Klapper, on the territorial encroachment and aid restrictions, he replied: “This is your reply. You have our assessment of where things stand.”

Gaza faces fourth winter as aid remains blocked

Gaza is entering its fourth winter of displacement with reconstruction not yet begun, despite roughly $18 billion pledged through the Board of Peace. Nearly 1.4 million Palestinians live in makeshift shelters; a recent storm flooded more than 70,000 tents in a single day, drowning an infant and killing five displaced people, Al Jazeera reported.

More than 150,000 tents and 500,000 blankets sit outside Gaza’s borders, waiting for entry permission. “What greater moral and legal outrage could there be,” Abdu told Al Jazeera, “than invoking so-called dual-use restrictions to prevent the entry of tents and basic hygiene supplies as winter approaches?”

“One year ago, the world was promised that Gaza’s children would finally see safety, relief and a chance to rebuild their lives. Instead, they are colder, hungrier, more traumatised and more at risk than they were before,” said Inger Ashing, CEO of Save the Children International.

The Washington Institute, in its own analysis of what it calls Gaza’s frozen humanitarian crisis, notes that an estimated 82 percent of buildings in the Strip are damaged and 65 percent of households still live in tents or unsafe structures — and argues that engaging the Palestinian Authority and the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza could start changing that reality.

Where accountability goes next

Abdu outlined five paths he says remain open: enforcing ICC arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other officials, continuing the ICJ genocide proceedings, pursuing universal jurisdiction in national courts, regional arms embargoes, and a public Security Council briefing on the Board of Peace’s failures.

“The United States and other UN Security Council members must use their leverage to ensure those obligations are met,” said Jeremy Konyndyk, president of Refugees International. Oxfam America’s president, Abby Maxman, called the situation on the ground a direct result of policy choices made in Israel, the US and at the UN.

The board’s report, for its part, closes with a warning that echoes the aid groups’ findings from the opposite direction: “The people of Gaza have paid the highest price for this war and should not be asked to pay again for delay.”

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

Mythless (Ex-Fang Island) Announce Debut Album ‘Hex’ Eight Years After First EP

Blood Donation Drive All Types General Güemes Today November 19