Ford, Honda, Stellantis, VW Sue New Jersey to Block ‘Extortionate’ Vehicle Repair Law

Four major automakers filed a federal lawsuit against New Jersey on Friday, seeking to block a state law that shifts more than $375 million annually from manufacturers to franchised dealers for warranty and recall repairs.

The complaint, lodged in Trenton federal court by Ford (NYSE: F), Honda (TYO: 7267), Stellantis’ (MIL: STLAM) FCA unit and Volkswagen (ETR: VOWG), argues the Motor Vehicle Open Recall Notice and Fair Compensation Act hands dealers a “blank check” to inflate labor and parts reimbursements, Boursorama reported. The statute took effect April 1 after former Governor Phil Murphy signed it in September 2025.

The $375 Million Annual Transfer

The legislation mandates that manufacturers reimburse dealers at retail rates for warranty work, using a “labor multiplier” derived from repair-order samples. Automakers contend this formula allows dealers to bill for hours no technician actually worked. They also object to provisions forcing payment of marked-up prices on parts obtained at discount or for free, while stripping manufacturers’ ability to source cheaper alternatives.

“In short, the act rewards dealers for charging their customers more,” the manufacturers said in the filing. Since the April effective date, each plaintiff reports receiving dozens of invoices demanding payment “for hours that no technician works, that surpass what comparable dealers charge for the same work, and that exceed what retail customers pay,” according to the complaint cited by live.euronext.com.

Four OEMs Challenge New Jersey Warranty Reimbursement Law

  • Four OEMs challenge New Jersey law shifting $375M+ annually to dealers via mandated retail-rate warranty reimbursements.
  • Constitutional claims target Commerce Clause, Takings Clause, federal preemption, and state constitution violations.
  • Dealer coalition counters that OEMs have historically underpaid for warranty labor and parts by imposing steep discounts.

Constitutional Battle Lines Drawn

The suit alleges violations of the U.S. Constitution’s Commerce Clause and Takings Clause, arguing the law regulates interstate commerce and effects an uncompensated taking of manufacturer property. Plaintiffs also claim federal preemption under the National Traffic and Motor Vehicle Safety Act, which governs recall remedies, and cite violations of the New Jersey Constitution.

The New Jersey Coalition of Automotive Retailers, named as a defendant, expressed confidence in prevailing. Its president, Laura Perrotta, accused automakers of having for decades “helped themselves” to deep discounts on parts and labor at dealers’ expense. She told Reuters it is “not an option” for competing dealers to pass warranty and recall repair costs to consumers.

Dealer Franchise Economics Under Pressure

New Jersey’s law follows similar statutes in other states, but automakers say it will shift more than $375 million a year from them to dealers.

For context, Ford reported tens of billions of dollars in 2023 revenue; Stellantis posted hundreds of billions of euros.

Exposure estimates are derived from U.S. market share and New Jersey vehicle registration data; the automakers said the New Jersey law will shift more than $375 million a year from automakers to dealers.

Attorney General Silent as Court Weighs In

The office of New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport, tasked with enforcing state laws, declined to comment on the litigation.

One side calls it a windfall; the other, a taking.

New Jersey, where the capital Trenton hosts the federal court hearing the case, is the most densely populated U.S. state and the only one in which every county is deemed urban by the Census Bureau.

It is also the fastest-warming state by average air temperature over a 100-year period beginning in the early 20th century, a trend attributed to significant warming of the North Atlantic Ocean and coastal waters of the Jersey Shore.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice.

Photo of author

Newsroom

Newsroom at Archyde.

Lansing Town Board Votes 3-2 for Data Center Ban, but Landowner Petition May Nullify It