Forensic pathologist Michael Freeman said on Monday, November 16, that Jeffrey Epstein’s 2019 death in a Manhattan federal jail was more consistent with strangulation than suicide, after reviewing the full autopsy file provided by Epstein’s brother.
Freeman presented his findings at the Middle Temple legal society in London and on the BBC. The official ruling remains suicide.
Seven years after the financier was found dead in his cell at the Metropolitan Correctional Center on August 10, 2019, the question of how he died is back in open dispute. The timing matters: a Congressional inquiry said on Tuesday, November 17, that materials it received did not allow it to refute the joint finding of a New York prosecutor and the FBI that Epstein killed himself.
Freeman, a professor of forensic medicine and editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, worked with neuroscientist Itiel Dror, who studies bias in forensic decision-making, and Anders Eriksson, a professor of forensic medicine at Umeå University in Sweden, according to Slate.
He told CBS News he had not examined the body itself and was not paid by the family. His report has not been peer-reviewed; he acknowledged it was rejected by one academic journal and said he plans to resubmit.
Autopsy injuries contradict suicide findings
Freeman’s case rests on injuries the 2019 autopsy documented but, in his view, left unexplained. He cites deep, irregular ligature marks on the neck — smoother and more uniform in suicidal hanging — along with significant hemorrhaging in the left shoulder, injuries consistent with a blow to the face, and fingernail marks above the ligature.
“The configuration, the distribution and the multitude of the injuries are not explained by a suicidal hanging,” Freeman said when presenting his conclusions at the Middle Temple, as reported by Slate.
He told the BBC the nail marks were “compatible with a strangulation, in particular by behind,” and with a victim’s attempt to pull a ligature away from the throat. “The injuries and the way the body was found do not correspond. That leaves only one explanation: the death is due to a homicide,” he said, according to RTL.
Freeman also addressed the accusation that he was feeding conspiracy theories. “Don’t take my word for it, let everyone see for themselves,” he said. “If you think I’m a conspiracy theorist because I look at something that looks like a strangulation and I say: ‘I think it’s a strangulation and I don’t think it could be a hanging,’ show me where I went wrong.”

Three things to know
- The New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner, which ruled the death a suicide on August 11, 2019, told CBS News it stands by that determination and declined an interview about Freeman’s findings.
- Freeman is the second outside pathologist to challenge the ruling; in 2020, Epstein’s brother hired Dr. Michael Baden, who told “60 Minutes” the neck injuries pointed more toward murder than suicide.
- A June New York Times investigation built on tens of thousands of pages of released documents found indications Epstein intended to end his own life, and the forensic experts it interviewed said almost none believed the manner of death could be conclusively settled from the medical evidence alone.
Why the original investigation was compromised
The 2019 autopsy was conducted under conditions Freeman and others describe as unusually degraded. The city medical examiner could not examine the cell and had access only to photographs of the scene, according to Slate’s account of the file. A cascade of blunders in the hours, days and weeks after the body was found added further uncertainty, CBS News reported.
Context cuts both ways. A psychological report made public after the death showed Epstein had been placed on suicide watch after a July 23, 2019 attempt on his life, Le Parisien reported, according to Leparisien. The pathologist who performed the autopsy found no defensive injuries characteristic of an assault. Both the FBI and the Justice Department’s inspector general confirmed the suicide conclusion after their own investigations.
Two rulings, one set of photographs
| Position | Who holds it | Basis cited |
|---|---|---|
| Suicide by hanging | NYC Chief Medical Examiner Barbara Sampson (2019 ruling, still maintained) | Autopsy performed August 11, 2019; no defensive wounds found |
| Homicide by strangulation | Dr. Michael Freeman, with Itiel Dror and Anders Eriksson | Full case file and autopsy photos from brother Mark Epstein; biomedical reconstruction |
| Doubts about suicide | Dr. Michael Baden (2020, hired by the family) | Neck injuries reviewed for “60 Minutes” |
| Cannot be settled medically | Experts interviewed by The New York Times (June report) | Tens of thousands of pages of released documents, Epstein’s jail notes |
The credibility calculation: Freeman's team worked from a biomedical reconstruction and photographs, not the body, and their paper has so far failed peer review at one journal. Against that, Freeman’s record is not marginal.
His testimony in the prosecution of the officer convicted of killing George Floyd in 2020 helped rebut the defense claim that pre-existing health conditions caused the death, Slate reported. Last year he served on the Maryland attorney general’s audit team reviewing dozens of in-custody deaths.
Freeman’s venue, the Honourable Society of the Middle Temple, is one of the four Inns of Court in London entitled to call members to the English Bar. Lawyers have occupied the site since 1320, when they were tenants of the Earl of Lancaster, on land that had served as the headquarters of the Knights Templar until their dissolution in 1312.
James I granted the Inn its share of the Temple in perpetuity in 1608, on condition it maintain the Temple Church and train lawyers. The Inn also holds a notable first: Helena Florence Normanton, admitted as a student member in December 1919, was the first woman to join any Inn of Court.
Dr. Barbara Sampson, the chief medical examiner at the time of the death, still maintains the suicide conclusion, the BBC reported
Earlier coverage: Forensic Experts Claim Jeffrey Epstein's Death Was Homicide, Not Suicide