Two former residents of Nexus Family Healing’s youth treatment center in Austin, Minnesota, are speaking publicly after 5 INVESTIGATES uncovered dozens of maltreatment reports and at least one active criminal investigation at the nonprofit’s facilities, which received about $36 million in public funding since 2022.
As teenagers, Charlotte Phoenix Welton, now 25, and Margaux Wegscheid, now 28, were each placed at Nexus Gerard in Austin for inpatient care — at the time, neither was aware of the other. Both say their experiences there still shape their lives. “It has impacted my entire life. I have dreams and nightmares about the things that have happened,” Welton said.
A 5 INVESTIGATES examination of maltreatment reports filed since 2022 shows the Austin site is among five Nexus facilities flagged by the Minnesota Department of Human Services over repeated instances of abuse and neglect. Nexus says it self-reports suspected maltreatment to the state and cooperates with its investigations.
Days after the two women spoke with 5 INVESTIGATES, DHS issued a new report determining that a staff member had sexually abused three residents at Nexus Gerard. The alleged victims lived in the facility’s Cherbourg unit — the same unit, Welton says, where she stayed years earlier. An Austin Police Department criminal investigation of an incident at the campus is underway, which Nexus later confirmed is connected to the same allegations.
What the former residents say happened
Welton and Wegscheid described long periods of isolation and “town hall” meetings, which Wegscheid called “mass hazing sessions.” She said: “Everybody would basically gang up on one person and the staff would egg it on. It’s bullying taken on steroids.”
Welton said she was placed on “room restriction” — which she described as “solitary confinement dressed up nicely” — for 72 days. Asked what actual therapy she received, Wegscheid said, “none.”
According to Nexus, the labels “town hall” and “room restriction” are not part of its vocabulary. A spokesperson pointed instead to “individualized safety planning” for each resident, explaining that such measures are “clinical decisions made by the treatment team, documented in the young person’s plan, reviewed regularly, and ended when they are no longer needed.”
Clinical debate on restrictive interventions in residential treatment
- Residential treatment can involve restrictive interventions — seclusion and restraint among them — whose safety and therapeutic value are contested in the clinical literature.
- Minnesota regulators have cited five Nexus locations for abuse and neglect findings since 2022, per 5 INVESTIGATES’ review.
- Nexus states that restrictive practices at its facilities are individualized, documented, and reviewed — a direct contradiction of the former residents’ accounts that regulators and readers must weigh.
Why restrictive practices are clinically contested
Isolation-based interventions sit at the center of this dispute, and the tension between the two accounts is not unique to Minnesota.
The use of seclusion and restraint in psychiatric and residential settings has drawn sustained scrutiny from federal health authorities; the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration has published guidance urging facilities to reduce and ultimately eliminate seclusion and restraint, citing evidence that such practices can re-traumatize young people already carrying histories of abuse. SAMHSA funds much of the research behind that guidance.
The clinical concern is straightforward: adolescents in residential care often arrive with trauma histories. Prolonged isolation — Welton described 72 days of “room restriction” — can worsen the very symptoms treatment is meant to address, a mechanism SAMHSA’s technical papers describe as re-traumatization.
Peer-reviewed research indexed on PubMed has documented high rates of trauma exposure among youth in residential treatment programs, which is why trauma-informed care models have become the stated standard across the sector.
Mental health care is also a health care access question. When a state channels roughly $36 million in public funding into a single nonprofit chain over three years, the quality of that chain’s care directly shapes whether families in Minnesota’s less-served regions have a safe option at all — or whether the alternative is no treatment.
DHS report finds former Nexus employee sexually abused three residents
The DHS report issued days after the interviews determined that a former Nexus Gerard employee sexually abused three residents in the Cherbourg unit. “What the state found a former employee did to young people at our Gerard campus is appalling and intolerable, and nothing excuses it,” Nexus said in a statement.
The nonprofit says it brought the suspected abuse to state authorities when it first surfaced and opened an investigation of its own. It also notes that the employee in question passed both a state and federal background check and completed required training. That employee no longer works at Nexus Gerard, according to the DHS report.
Nexus declined an interview request with Gerard’s executive director, Karen Wolf. A spokesperson said Wolf recently announced her resignation but is staying on until next month.
| Finding | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Staff member sexually abused three residents at Nexus Gerard | Minnesota DHS report | Confirmed by state investigators |
| Criminal investigation of an incident at Nexus Gerard | Austin Police Department | Active |
| Five Nexus locations cited for abuse and neglect since 2022 | 5 INVESTIGATES review of DHS maltreatment reports | Reported |
| Approximately $36 million in public funding since 2022 | 5 INVESTIGATES | Reported |
Nexus’s position is that its self-reporting system is functioning — that it flags suspected maltreatment itself and cooperates with state investigators. Welton and Wegscheid point to the pattern across a decade as evidence that the system fails the young people inside it. “We were told time and time again that no one’s going to believe you,” Wegscheid said.
What families can weigh before residential placement
Both women said they hope their stories lead other former residents to come forward and to change. Wegscheid was blunt in her advice to parents: “If you have a choice not to put your child there, don’t.”
Welton drew a distinction between the need and the delivery. “I think there’s 100% a need for mental health services. There’s no arguing that. I mean, I needed help,” she said. “I think the way they’re going about it is wrong.”
Check licensing and inspection records before placing adolescents
For families considering residential treatment for an adolescent: a facility’s licensing status, state inspection history, and maltreatment reports are public records in Minnesota through the Department of Human Services, and reviewing them before placement is a reasonable step.
If a young person in residential care describes prolonged isolation, unexplained injuries, or contact they were told to keep secret, that warrants immediate consultation with a pediatrician, the state’s reporting hotline, or law enforcement. Adolescents discharged from restrictive placements who experience nightmares, flashbacks, or trauma symptoms — as Welton described — should be evaluated for trauma-related conditions by a qualified clinician; effective, evidence-based treatments such as trauma-focused therapy exist outside institutional settings.
The question still open
The criminal investigation by Austin police remains active, and DHS’s oversight of the other four cited Nexus locations continues. What has not been answered is what Welton asked: with ten years between her own stay and the state’s newest findings, why the same pattern persisted. Nexus, for its part, says the conduct the state found at Gerard is “appalling and intolerable, and nothing excuses it.”
Nexus Family Healing has been in operation for more than 50 years and today serves over 4,600 children, families, and individuals annually through community mental health, crisis and stabilization, foster care and adoption, and residential treatment.
In 1991, the organization ended all adult programming and shifted its focus entirely to the mental health needs of youth. During the 1990s it expanded beyond Minnesota into Illinois and earned national accreditation from the Council on Accreditation, which it has maintained ever since.
References
- 5 INVESTIGATES — “Former residents call for change at Minnesota nonprofit’s youth treatment facilities”
- Minnesota Department of Human Services — maltreatment investigation reports concerning Nexus Gerard
- Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration — guidance on eliminating seclusion and restraint in behavioral health settings
- Peer-reviewed literature on trauma exposure among youth in residential treatment, indexed via PubMed
This article is reporting on allegations and regulatory findings affecting real people. Nothing here is medical advice; families making treatment decisions should consult qualified clinicians and their state’s licensing authorities.
Related reading
- Scotland Issues ‘Isla’s Principles’ Guidance After Teen’s Cancer Death
- 5 Essential Micronutrients Most People Are Not Getting Enough
- No. 16 Penn State Women’s Volleyball Defeats No. 18 Indiana 3-1 (newsdirectory3.com)
- CBS Sports Flags Utah, UCLA, BYU, Texas Tech, Ohio State as Week 12 Upset Risks (news-usa.today)