France Seeks UN Security Council Meeting After Myanmar Rejects ICJ Genocide Ruling

France is seeking a United Nations Security Council meeting after Myanmar rejected a landmark ruling by the International Court of Justice that found the state guilty of genocide against its Rohingya Muslim minority, The Jerusalem Post reported.

The 9-6 decision marks the first time in the 80-year history of the United Nations’ top court that a state has been held responsible for genocide, according to CNN. The Gambia brought the case against Myanmar in 2019, alleging that military campaigns in Rakhine state included killings, serious bodily and mental harm, and measures intended to prevent births.

Court Rejects Defence

During the proceedings, Myanmar defended its military operations by arguing they targeted terrorists and insurgents following attacks that left security personnel dead. Presiding Judge Iwasawa Yuji said that the court dismissed these explanations, finding the scale and nature of the atrocities were characteristic of an intent to destroy the Rohingya population.

“The court is of the view that the only reasonable inference that can explain Myanmar’s actions is an intention to destroy” the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine state, Iwasawa said during the ruling.

Myanmar’s government rejected the verdict as unfair. A presidential spokeswoman called the decision unjust while maintaining that authorities were countering an armed uprising.

Human Rights Groups Demand Criminal Probe into Arms Exports

“It is a very significant judicial precedent that has been created by this judgment, and in that regard, as South Africa we will study the judgment very carefully, with the clear intention to show that a state, like it has been shown in the Rohingya case with Myanmar, can’t commit genocide,” Lamola said, according to SABC News.

Examing Evidentiary Standards and Hate Speech

The tribunal evaluated seven years of collected evidence and witness testimony before determining that the nature and scale of the atrocities met the threshold required under international law.

Mia Swart, writing as an assistant professor at the University of Dubai and visiting professor at the University of the Witwatersrand, explained that Gambia shouldered the dual burden of proving the crimes occurred and demonstrating the specific intent to destroy the Rohingya group.

Rahama Khatun, 43, a Rohingya woman whose husband, Shaker Ahmed
Photo: TimesLIVE

ICJ Historically Reluctant to Rule on Genocide

Writing in TimesLIVE, Mia Swart observed that the International Court of Justice has historically displayed a reluctance to find genocide, which previously contributed to the crime’s almost mythical status and its perception as the supreme violation.

Although Aung San Suu Kyi did not order the killings and lacked control over the military during the crackdown, Swart pointed out that the disgraced political leader will now always be associated with the genocide following her December 2019 appearance in The Hague.

In its formal defense, Myanmar maintained that its military operations functioned as counter-terrorist measures directed specifically against insurgents and terrorists. The tribunal ultimately rejected these explanations, while legal observers said that the court tends to follow precedent for the sake of consistency even though it is not strictly bound to do so.

Myanmar Ordered to Compensate Victims and Ensure Refugee Return

The court ordered Myanmar to provide restitution and compensation to victims, along with ensuring safe passage home for hundreds of thousands of displaced refugees currently stranded in camps in Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh. While the tribunal cannot enforce its own verdicts, the ruling adds international pressure on leader Min Aung Hlaing.

China raised concerns regarding judicial overreach following the decision, while the United States emphasized the need to avoid the politicisation of international tribunals.

Myanmar has been governed by the State Administration Council (SAC), chaired by Senior General Min Aung Hlaing as Commander-in-Chief of the Tatmadaw, since the military seized power in the February 2021 coup d’état. The junta dissolved the civilian-led National League for Democracy government and declared a state of emergency that remains in effect, ruling by decree while facing civil war and widespread internal displacement.

“We want to return to our homeland in Rakhine state with our rights, our citizenship, and our dignity fully restored,” a Rohingya community member told CNN.

Photo of author

World Desk

World Desk at Archyde.

“Essayer de faire une première rencontre à l’extérieur où on va mettre les deux chiens à distance